Best beverage store on South Shore, bar none! The two gentlemen running this establishment are well informed, helpful and run a clean and well stocked store. Just ask one of the owners when you enter the store what you need and they will grab it for you. Truly a well run business. read more

I'm looking for Heineken Dark beer........very hard to find. So I walk into All Island and look around by the german beer, they got Heineken and Heineken light......no dark. So I go to the counter and asked if they carried. Wow, both the guys at the counter were, polite, informative, told me they would get it and would call me when it came in. Simple customer service the old fashioned way, won them a customer for life................ I would go 5 stars but parking sucks.................worth the suckiness read more

This place did NOT raise prices for ice during hurricane sandy. They sold for $2 when they could have sold for $5. I respect that and I promised to shop there forever Huge selection of micro brews and ipa's. Good prices on sale items. Nice people read more

I've been shopping here , if I'm not mistaken; since 1995. These guys are the absolute Best! I often want the hard to find items.. certain juices.. wAters etc.. never to much to handle with All Island. Thank you guys for always having what I want, I don't drink beer but they have what looks like hundreds of choices. They also take your empty cans n bottles. Snacks, mixed nuts.. propane, chilled kegs . Bags of ice.. etc..one stop shopping! read more

This is my go to beer distributor on the south shore. They have the most taps to fill up growlers and the widest selection of beers in the area. The staff always offers a helping hand. Some of the folks at All Island are incredibly knowledge and offer fantastic recommendations. They've turned me on to Maine Brewing Co amongst others great breweries. I'd rate it four and a half stars. read more

My go to beer distributor for all my craft beer needs & wants! Lol Everybody behind the counter is so helpful! They always have my favorites in stock in and if they don't they get it special the very next day! Prices are competitive,All the beer is ice cold, sometimes I go in I tell them what I want and they have the kids bring it up within seconds! I love the new growler station, they have plenty of chips and snacks to go along with my beverages, I even fill up my propane tank there within minutes ,the store is always clean well laid out and there's ample parking right off Merrick Road! Perfect! read more

Great spot friendly guys definitely have a great selection and they carry propane as well. One stop shop.

I've been trying to find a beer distributor with an extensive collection of craft Brews. To date, this is the largest selection I found in South Nassau County. Friendly, courteous staff. Reasonable prices. On par with most major distributors. Carried Founders, Southern Tier, Founders, Allagash, North Coast Brewing, evil twin, left hand, and many many more. read more

All Island Beverage - Just picked up these beauties for St Patrick's Day. - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Bellmore, New York

This place has really picked up their game, picking up the slack of the once great beer dist on Merrick Rd that got a raw deal from their landlord. All Island has an ever expanding craft selection, & keep a nice selection of taps. The staff is awesome and are friendly. Recently, they hired a new member Courtney. She is super helpful, will go through her contacts to try and find that hard to locate brew. Super knowledgeable & very accommodating. Overall a great place to find your suds read more

I don't like bringing my propane tank to be filled and they give me back someone else's propane tank. Mine was brand new I got back some ones old junky looking one. Wow and not in a good way read more

Great selection of beers plus nice growler fill station. I also get my propane filled here. The staff know their beers so feel free to ask questions, always happy to assist. Parking is limited to a few spots out front but no one stays too long so it's usually not a problem getting a spot. read more

Great selection of craft beer. The prices were very good too. Though they did not have a favorite of mine, Dogfish Head 120 Min IPA at the time, they had a great alternative, Dogfish Head Worldwide Stout. Both are 18% ABV and regularly go for $10-14$ per bottle, they had it for $7.99. I also found in general the beer was bout 10-20% less than other places. A small growler selection. A great selection of the usual Miller and Heineken everyday beer and also a nice selection of non alcoholic drinks such as sodas Service was great!! I was always being asked if I needed help, despite a super busy early Saturday afternoon. Some beer was even recommended to me based on the ones i bought. I definitely recommend this place. They seem to sell a helluva lot of propane tanks as well. read more

They screwed up my order not once but three separate ways and then they have the nerve to leave a nasty message on my cell phone. When I called them back how interesting that the person that left the message was gone and when I asked to speak to the delivery boy to verify my story and show how they were repeatedly wrong he was also gone. They have terrible customer service and terrible attitude. How dare you call any customer and leave a nasty message on their VM you are a disgusting excuse for an individual. I advise anyone to avoid shopping there especially when there are beer distributors at every corner!! read more

My neighborhood beer distributor. Has done the trick for me the past 11 years. I like it for the convenience and for the vast selection. It's like being a kid in a candy store. When the season hits, they have the Abita Strawberry which is one of my fiancés favorite beers. Took my buddy here, who just graduated beer school, and he left very happy with his selections - and it was tough to narrow down. Not sure what else to say, beer school graduate selection approved, parking right in front, helpful staff - what more do you need from a beer store? I won't be going back until September, but doesn't mean you shouldn't. read more

Stopped by to get a few cases of water and Fresca. Prices were reasonable and the girl at the register was super friendly and efficient. They carried all my stuff to the trunk of my car because I'm recuperating from knee surgery. I will be back! I have been in the area for years and never went in here before. Great spot for beverages! read more

Large selection of beers and good prices on most stuff. I just wish the store were a little more organized. They get Other Half and other hard-to-get beers, but I've noticed that the Other Half sits around for months at a time. At $8-9 per can, the least they could do is keep it in the refrigerator rather than having it sit on a rack near the entrance. read more

What a great beer distributor! They have a huge selection of craft beer and a big growler section. If they dont have what you are looking for, just ask and they will try to get it for you. The staff is knowledgable and can recommend whats good based on your crave. Dig through the shelves you might find the gem of a beer you've been looking for. read more

Rude management and poor customer service. Purchased a keg midday for a party at night, tapped the keg at 10pm by a barback (so it was done correctly). The keg was all foam and no beer. Was absolutely disgusting and I had to go out and get cans for the rest of the night. Bright the keg back for my deposit and to see if I can get any money back because nothing was drank out of the keg and the manager said "why wouldn't you call us when it was foam" and I said because I tapped it at 10 pm when you guys were closed and his response was "who taps a keg at 10pm". My guests didn't arrive until 10:30, why am I tapping a keg and letting it sit at 7 pm. Didn't get my money back and was left disgusted. read more

The best beverage store I've been to on the island. They always have the beer I want or know who I can go to for it. The parking (if that's what you can call it) is very very small and hard to maneuver when people pull in like they've had a few too many already. The staff are very helpful and courteous. Wouldn't go anywhere else to stock my fridge read more

Great prices, great service, these guys are always helpful. Highly recommended especially since their prices are lower than the competition

Picked up supplies to celebrate our nations independence this weekend. I'm no high-roller, but All Island treats you like #1 and has carry out service when you need more then 2 hands. So classy, priced right... they are so good I travel 3 towns for their service. read more

Excellent beer selection. I never have any trouble finding what I'm looking for here - weather it be one of my favorites, or I want to try something new. The staff is extremely helpful and what ever they don't have, they will get for you. They keep a good rotation of beers available on tap, as well. The prices are the best I've seen on Long Island. read more

Can't ask for a better beer distributor. The staff is always helpful and knowledgeable. The craft beer selection is unbeatable and is continuously expanding. I went in last week to buy my dad the Hop Daddy IPA for father's day. Unfortunately they didn't have it in stock but ordered it for me! Hands down best beverage store on Long Island. Keep it up. read more

Ive come here a few time for my adult beverage needs, the place is small and there is not enough parking, but if you can get over that then the place is a good source for beer and other drinks. Their pricing is on par with other places in the hood....REMEMBER PEOPLE DON'T DRINK AND DRIVE! read more

I wanted to try this new Evil Twin Sour Bikini and found it right away at this spot. They also have Spiked Seltzer which i totally wanted to try but didn't have the cash on me!!! Looks amazing they have everything you could want there and are super helpful...Def go and get your booze on. read more

Had to pick up some beers for a BBQ!!! They had amazing selections of beer and everything you would for a party. Very clean and helpful. They help me carry everything to my car with out asking. read more

In addition to all the fab things the other reviewers have commented on, I also love how they have lollipops for kids. Seems silly, but some places give you the stink eye if you have your kids with you... if I'm out doing errands and need to run in here quickly for supplies, they're super nice and don't make you feel bad hauling the kiddos in. read more

Great beer selection, some rarities, and they've cleaned the place up. They have an impressive selection of bombers and their prices are within reason. With the exception of some hard to find limited release beers they keep the prices on par with their competitors. They'll fill your growler with a rotating selection of beers, though I've yet to take mine there. I would assume they keep the tap lines clean based on my experiences with this store. If you're planning a BBQ they'll fill your propane tank too. read more

Best Beverage place I have been to on Long Island. Fantastic selection of drinking beers as well as large bottle specialty beers. Staff is helpful and informative. read more

This is where I barter for beer! Plowed their parking lot in exchange for a month supply of rare craft beer! Running low! Hope it snows again soon! read more

In addition to pizza and steak, I'm also a beer connoisseur. They have a HUGE selection of craft beers at fair prices. (Duvel is my all-time fave.) What else can you say about a beer store?!? read more

Great place to get beer, Lotto or your propane tank refilled. They have many varieties of beer and even have growlers of craft brews refrigerated on tap. I recently asked if they had Lowenbrau in stock? They said it was now made in Germany with the original recipe and they would get a couple of cases on their next beer shipment. Can't wait to stop this Friday for some. They always have specials and the beer is reasonably priced, the guys are always helpful and carry your stuff to the car without asking. Love this place. read more

Good place. Reasonable price. Has mostly everything. Easy parking. Great for bulk buys.

Great service and friendly. I've been going here for years. Beer, soda, ice, water, lottery tickets and more.

Local beer distributor that has been in Bellmore many years. Has a good selection of domestic beer and imports. Parking lot is small so go early before the crowds get there.... read more

So many selections!! Similar to colorado liquor stores except more of a mini warehouse feel.

I can not believe the way All Island Beverage in bellmore on Merrick road is managed. I have shopped there countless times and was just treated like trash. I called to place an order for delivery for a 6 pack and manager said he would not deliver just a 6 pack. I told him thats fine but just for his knowledge I was told before there is no minimum purchase for delivery. He responded by telling me there is not a minimum but he will not deliver just a 6 pack. So what exactly is their policy? The kicker was he told me I was lazy! When I asked his name he hung up on me! I called back and asked again for his name and he said he does not have to tell me and hung up. I'm not mad that they wouldn't deliver a 6 pack. I am angry because in the same breathe the manager contradicted his own policy, and then began to call his customer names. read more

Let me start off by saying I love this to store and most of the staff. There is a cranky old guy in a baseball cap there somedays, but I deal with him. They have a great selection of beer, and if they don't have it they will get it in for you. My problem with them lately has been how unorganized the store has been. They recently expanded the retail part of the store to accommodate the growing craft beer market. But that expanded space is unorganized and filthy. They have the bottle return area within inches of product. It seems all that new space is just used for can soda and pallets of water, if that was the plan why not keep that space part of the warehouse?? They have a ton of craft beer but no organization as to how it is displayed. The aisles are crowded and have cases all over the floor. Most stores have beer separated by region or even beer type, here it feels like they just toss stuff on a shelf wherever there is room and nothing has a price on it. If I ask for a beer form Oregon they have to search the store for it. So all in all I love this store and it's still my go to spot, but please get your store cleaned up! read more

This is my go to beer distributor. They have a large selection of all different types of beers. They are very helpful and have no problem getting whatever you need as well as helping unload you returns. The only slight negative is the growler selection usually only 5 or 6 choices. They also have propane exchange. read more