Peconic Water Sports - from my research - has the most boats to rent in the area. They have…read moremultiple locations, so you can toggle around on their website to see what's available. We were a group of seven, so our options were their tritoon or motorboat. But since we waited 'til the last minute, only the 'toon was available. But all good - we had a great time. You can rent for a half day (4 hours) or full day. We did a half day (1-5pm) with the option to extend it a few hours for extra $, which we turned down. Book and pay online; and show up early for waivers (every passenger must sign). They rec' showing up 15 min early for that, which we did, but after my beau did the test drive, we didn't hit the water until 15 min past our res, and then we returned 20 min early because we're unfamiliar with the time/distance to return... so we lost a half our on the water :/ Next time, we'll remember our noodles or ask about renting some water toys.

Rented a boat for a 4 hours. Nik and Eric were really chill. Had an amazing on the boat. It was…read morebrand new, amazing speakers and beautiful water. Had an amazing time!! Definitely going to be back soon. L

Hands down the best thing to do on the North Fork. Erick, Hannah and Christian took 8 of us out…read moresailing for several hours on the schooner Bonnie Lynn, and it made for the most memorable, vibrant and relaxing time. Bonnie Lynn is an incredible boat, with Erick and Hannah the perfect hosts. I can't think of a better way to introduce people to, and share with them, the beauty of the North Fork. We cannot wait for next time, and neither should you.

Great experience. We had fun, very enjoyable sail. Our hosts were very kind and welcoming. Will go…read moreagain.

Completely made my 2nd wedding anniversary perfect! Captain Liz and Brigitte were not only…read moreincredibly professional, they made the experience very special for us with their service. I've been sailing on several other private charters before, mostly in Miami, but this was surprisingly more relaxed. If you're looking to relax, do something that is off-the-beaten path, I highly recommend #sailing on Layla in #Greenport.

I don't think there is any review that could possibly do Layla Sailing the justice the trip…read moredeserves! There is something so magical about this boat and it's Liz! As soon as you meet her there is a joy and a love for the water that you will feel in your soul! I'm tragically afraid of the water but every time I step onto Layla the Old Man and the Sea inside me takes over. I swim every time! Every detail is taken care of and all of your needs are anticipated. It is truly a magical experience and if there is an available slot I suggest you book it now! Do not hesitate you will not regret it! Liz - thank you so much for making the day so special!

Great marina in Greenport, tucked away in a quiet neighborhood. Facilities are very clean and…read moreupdated. Nice pool and Billy's By The Bay is always fun for food, drink and music. Staff is very helpful and the seasonal people are very welcoming too. A favorite!

This is a first rate service yard. Have visited several times as a guest and always had great,…read morefriendly service. They provide a hourly shuttle van to downtown and had a small store. Recent visit show me how great their marine services are. Had damage on the way to Greenport. Didn't know how I would get it fixed and my boat back home. The service manager just stepped up and made it all right in one weeks time. Way beyond that normal customers service I would expect. Make a bad situation into a easy repair.

They cancelled our charter with 15 minutes notice to arrival time as we were already about to…read morearrive with a party of 15. "Mechanical issues on the charter prior." I bet. This was my plan for my 25th birthday. I had a party of 14 about to be there, and we all already paid. Beyond disappointed as this last minute cancellation has ruined my birthday and left a party of 14 in sag harbor with no backup plan since we received a final confirmation the night before. Thanks American Beauty. Not feeling beautiful.

Very nice boat ride around sag harbor with great views. David did.an excellent job telling and…read moreshowing us all the history around the area

This was a highlight of our bougie Bachelorette party in Montauk! We rented our own private…read morecatamaran for six people for three hours. It was about $700+ after fees, tip, etc, and it was totally worth it. Our captain, Mason, was super cool. He was friendly, knowledgeable, and we felt comfortable being really annoying and weird in front of him. The sail itself was just a short ride in the bay, where we anchored close to a beach. We loved dancing on the boat, trying out the SUP board (included), basically chugging our BYOB drinks (no hard liquor allowed on board), taking pics lounging in the net, gawking at the yachts, and pretending the pool noodles were seahorses that we were riding. Bachelorette stuff! I think we had the Mon Mini boat, probably the smallest option. Included: one SUP board, bluetooth speaker, cooler, two pool noodles, the captain.

I booked the 26' catamaran for a Friday sunset cruise from 5-7pm. The catamaran was larger than I…read moreexpected. Also, the bean bag chairs were very comfortable compared to other boats. They provided two Yeti coolers and a Bluetooth speaker for music which was nice. The staff were very friendly and helpful. They helped take pictures for our group and the sailing was very smooth. I would definitely book again, probably earlier in the summer for the 3 hour cruise to be able to do the paddleboarding.

Rob was great as always. His understanding of the tides and weather always puts you on the fish…read more He timed the day perfectly for black sea bass in the morning and fluke in the afternoon. He even provided me with a new ceviche recipe to try that evening that certainly didn't disappoint me or my family. I will absolutely be booking another trip with him soon.

This was the best charter I've ever taken. Caught the biggest doormat ever 6lbs! Captain Rob really…read morebrings your hook to the fish.

Great place, great atmosphere. Pool was clean, clear and warm. The bathroom facilities are so much…read morebetter than the ones at our yacht club. Restaurant next door (Way Point) was absolutely great. Little expensive but food was great, awesome views, great atmosphere, and always live music. Can't wait to book our next trip there.

This place is a rip off! If you have millions of dollars to waste, this is the place to be. If you…read morehave a boat and want it to be taken care of then this place is not for you! Over priced, their service department is CLUELESS and overcharge for everything. If you have problems with your boat or engine they brush you off, mainly because they have people who have no idea what they are doing. End result will be damage to engine and have to buy a new one. Yes they have a pool to swim but you dont need that. Boaters want a reliable and dependable marina to care for their boats. This place is the opposite.

Fantastic! Wonderful captain and crew! Relaxing and inviting. I highly recommend and will…read moredefinitely sail again.

From the owner: We are a family owned and operated business, sailing from our dock in New Suffolk for the last 20…read moreyears. Both Captain Bob and Captain Bobby have extensive knowledge of sailing on the Peconic Bay, and each charter is designed to make you feel at ease on the boat and have one of the best days you can remember! We love what we do, and can’t wait to take you out.