A lovely experience everytime I stop in, which is quite often. Love their cookies and cupcakes.

Went all the way to New Braunfels to try this place. They have a cute store and a cute name. I was very disappointed that the baked goods were way to dry. Like they had been in there for a month. We ordered 4 items for $30 and it wasn't even good. You need to rethink your menu guys. cinnamon roll was hard and dry. Worst one i have ever had. read more

See all

What a daring little bakery. I was feeling like a little dessert, but at 9pm, what's going to be open, certainly not a bakery. Bakery close early or when inventory runs out. Not usually open late at night. Was so happy that 2Tarts was open, not only open at 9pm, but actually open til 10am. It was very obvious that this was the place to be. Even at 9pm there were about 7 people there. And a few people came in after us as well. There is street parking, which was easy to find a spot. I think there may have been a small parking lot on the side, but I'm not sure if it's for another business. The store is packed with all kinds of decorative candles, party supplies, stationary items, and even socks! Really fun to look around and take it all in. It was late, so the inventory was a little low. They had some cupcakes, cookies, and cheesecake! I'm here for the cheesecake. I got the New York Cheesecake. Velvety Chocolatey, really rich and satisfying. Hit the spot for dessert. read more

See all

Kinda indifferent. I loved the fresh deserts they were chewy and soft. My favorite has been the rice crispy triangles w sprinkles. I got a brownie (not in pictures) that was on one of the bottom racks and when I bit into it then crumbled like ash. It was hard as a rock and crumbly you can tell it's prob been there over a week. I bought a cake from their other display for my birthday (teal blue buttercream with rainbow sprinkles confetti cake) it was amazing! I've only visited here a few times so I definitely will update. I like the decor of the place plus all the gift shop things. It's very tiny inside for the amount of business they get so don't think about sitting at peak times. The service people are cold, don't want to answer questions (or know anything about the product). I've had good and meh experiences will update when I visit next. read more

2tarts Bakery - Beautifully decorated sugar cookie! 7/13/25 It was so pretty I didn't want to eat it but it was so yummy!!!! - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Cute little shop in New Braunfels! I tried the Cookies and Cream Cupcake and the Ferrero Rocher Macaron. Cookies and Cream Cupcake - Pretty standard--chocolate base with cookies and cream frosting. While it wasn't bad, it also wasn't anything unique. Honestly, I don't think I would have been able to tell if it came from HEB or a bakery, which was a little disappointing. Ferrero Rocher macaron - Great flavor profile and really captured the flavors of a Ferrero Rocher. The texture could have been a bit crispier, but the flavor made up for it. Overall, it's a cute spot with decent treats, but nothing that really stood out to me. read more

2tarts Bakery - Cookies and Cream Cupcake, Ferrero Rocher Macaron - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I was looking for a place that made Apple and Rhubarb pies for Christmas. 2tarts Bakery made both so I ordered 1 pie of each and everyone enjoyed both pies. The Apple pie and the Strawberry Rhubarb pie were very delicious. read more

If you find yourself in New Braunfels you have to make it to 2 Tarts Bakery. The area is open and welcoming, as you walk in you can see the pastries showcased for display or to entice you to try them all. The bakers answer all the questions and give their recommendations. I tried the apple pie slice and it was as expected very decadent. They have options if a cake is needed for a special occasion with a tasting room so you'll know what you will be ordering. The inside is open and plenty of space to sit and a few seats outside to enjoy the view. But if a pastry is needed I approve this place. read more

See all

We love stopping in to 2Tarts! Every dessert we've tried has been amazing! I think their pie slices are my favorite, my favorite being the Blueberry-Lavender, followed by the PB&choc! The lattes are delicious too ! Cute shop with lots of sweet gift/party items . It's ALWAYS hoppin' but dont let that deter you. The line moves quick! read more

2tarts Bakery - Strawberry cream pie & latte - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I took a ride to San Marcos to pick up a few items from the farmers market. As I was leaving I saw "2tarts Bakery" and my weakness for pastries put me in auto-pilot. I turned around and was lucky enough to find a parking spot in front of the door. The line was pretty long but moved pretty fast as well. There was also quite a few people seated at tables as well as outside enjoying the food. They had tons of pastry options to choose from! I decided on a few and a vanilla latte to match. I perused the bakery to discover the scrumptious cakes that they also offer in wedding style and beautiful celebratory style as well. My order was ready pretty fast and I absolutely enjoyed them all on my drive back to San Antonio. I am so glad that I stumbled across this place and it will be a mandatory stop for the next times that I go to or through San Marcos. read more

See all

Equally beautiful and delicious. We travel to NB twice a year, once to float in the summer and again for Wurst Fest in the fall. 2Tarts is consistently a favorite stop while in town. The coffee is delicious and the baked goods are such a treat. This time, I tried the savory blueberry sausage biscuit. It was not shaped like a traditional biscuit. It was more like a sausage ball (those holiday appetizers) with blueberry glaze. It was pretty unique but I'd recommend giving it a shot. read more

See all

My friend and I stumbled on 2tarts Bakery and decided to pop in. The shop has a cozy, quirky vibe with a gorgeous display case full of colorful, tempting treats. It was tough to choose, but I went with a lemon tarte and my friend grabbed a cookie and a latte. Everything was fresh, rich, and made with care. The cookies had that perfect chewy-crisp texture. Their coffee drinks were on point too! The staff was super friendly and you could tell this is a spot loved by locals. It made for such a nice little stop to break up the drive. Definitely recommend if you're in the area or passing through, it's worth the detour! read more

Love this little cute spot in new Braunfels, they are always friendly, helpful and give amazing recommendations. Service is quick, fast and the treats are amazing!! read more

2tarts Bakery - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

2tarts has amazing assortment of baked goods. I tried the lemon lavender blueberry cheesecake. WOW!!! Blew me out of the water. It's creamy, rich, with a great balance of flavor. Their lemonades are also delicious. They are tart and NOT heavily sweetened. I definitely recommend this bakery to all newcomers to this quaint little city. read more

See all

This place is da bomb for desserts and baked items. I stopped in to see what it was all about and I think my hemoglobin A1C went up before I even ordered l. Really large selection of pies, cupcakes, etc and very professionally prepared and presented. Nice decor too. I had a slice of the banana biscoff cream pie. First bite.. amazing. Texture, flavor, eye appeal, all 10. As I worked on it I wished I had a friend to eat 1/2 because it's definitely filling. Somehow I managed to scarf it down. Amazingly good stuff. I'll come back after I work off the calories. read more

I used to love 2 tarts. The workers are always so sweet and kind to my 88yo mother. One evening we bought slices of cake. They were dry, and not really up to par. The next Saturday we tried them again and bought a slice of cake each. I did not finish it, one of their holiday specialty flavor and didn't enjoy it much . That's ok about the adventurous flavor but the cake was dry again! Not sure if cake slices are day old ( no sign saying this ) . each time it was BOGO. The latte was good. I'm going to take a break from 2 tarts and try again in the future. Which is sad because can't think of any other bakery that sells cake by the slice read more

2tarts Bakery - Yummy - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Quick take on 2tarts: great selection and quality baked goods in a jumping little venue. I really love their cupcakes, not only for the variety of flavors but for the fact they are the "baby bear" of cupcakes, not too big or small but just the right size. Their buttercream frosting is very light and not overly sweet. The store also has an eclectic selection of knickknacks so it's definitely worth a visit. Recommended. read more

Always busy because it's always delicious! Parking: We have always been able to get a street parking spot right in front. Even on mother's day morning we had no issue. That being said, I don't know if there are any alternatives to street parking Seating: They have a few 2-3 top tables outside on the sidewalk and several 4 tops inside. So you can definitely stay and eat, though I don't find the ambiance to be the best for that just because of how busy it gets. Selection: They have a huge selection from cookies, cakes, and cupcakes to breakfast options (kolaches and quiches). They also have pretty good coffee ! All their food is delicious but very sweet too. They also have a lot of party decor items like candles, plates, cards, etc. They're all unique and very cute. Wait time: You can move through pretty quickly if you're just getting food. If you get coffee and it's busy, you may need to wait a bit Price: I find the prices can be a bit high, but all their items are large and great quality so it does feel fair. read more

See all

My girlfriend really wanted to try this place, since she saw that the owner was on a television show she liked. We decided to try it out since we were in the area. The place is in downtown area and is easy to find with decent parking. Once inside you get a nice little cafe vibe with the sweet smell of various sweets in the air. The employees are cheerful and the rush of excitement hits you with all the options to choose from. There is so much to choose from and the employees are very helpful with the description of each sweet. There is also coffee and other drinks to choose from and the selections are vast. The only small downfall is that it is pricey, and the to go boxes are huge! So be prepared. Other than that we do come here often to try all the variety of sweets. read more

See all

I rarely post poor reviews but it just wasn't good. First off no treats were labeled. And many items were not obvious on what they were. We did ask the girl that served us whom was nice about it. I got the key lime pie slice and a decorated sugar cookie. The cookie was hard as a rock , possibly the worse I ever had. My husband got a regular cookie which was equally horrible. The key lime was the best part , but I ate it like a handheld item because there was no way the plastic fork was gonna penetrate the hard crust. We paid $20 for 2 cookies , a slice of pie and a cup cake. Trash was overflowing and all tables were dirty. We visited on a Sunday afternoon so I wouldn't expect these conditions on a weekend. read more

First time swinging by from out of town. The bakery was so beautiful & had the cutest vibe to it. It was very chill with great customer service. I asked multiple questions & didn't feel like I was being a bother. The choices were endless but I picked 1 strawberry cupcake & 1 biscoff cupcake - both were DIVINE. Highly highly recommend. read more

See all

Wasn't impressed. Price not worth it. Will not be going back. Kids at counter not very helpful.

Everything we got was hard and stale. Rice Krispie, cookie and brownie..not worth the money

Went in to this quaint lil place and instantly received glaring looks. I ordered a slice of pecan pie and a cinnamon roll the young woman helping me was not friendly didn't greet just simply took my request proceeded to take the items to check out and the cashier was stand offish and absolutely not friendly just charged me and that's it. I am a Latino person and I have never felt this type of unwelcoming behavior here in New Braunfels I come here every other weekend for shops, farmers markets and parks. This establishment will not discourage me from visiting however I will not be returning which I'm sure they would be grateful for as well. read more

2tarts Bakery - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Great pastries and cookies. Excellent customer service. Good selection including cakes and pies.

Great cupcakes! Terrible cakes!! Wasted a birthday and way too much money for one of the worst and oldest tasting cakes I've ever purchased. The cupcakes always taste fresh though and the coffees are good, so stick to the front case and avoid the other one. read more

The sales agent from Coventry Home brought me here when she finished lunch in April 2025 timeframe. I was so impressed that I started coming regularly and invited my daughter, who was also impressed. On my last visit with my pup, I bought 7 dessert items and asked if my pup could get a pup cup. Normally, it's just a small container of whipped cream, nothing fancy or elaborate. It was a hot day and we had walked that area, exploring. The sales girl said she had to ask the manager, who said it would cost $2.50. C'mon! I just bought 7 desserts and had been coming there at least once every other week since moving to New Braunfels May 2025. Their desserts are expensive but I thought they were good. It would've kept me coming but after that, no more. That one unkind response killed my mood and appetite for their desserts. They don't want or deserve my business. read more

Gift shop part has some cool things - the jewelry, for instance, is clever. The treats vary in terms of quality. As one of our friends said, you're paying for the ambiance. As mentioned in other reviews, the key lime pie is solid, but the flourless chocolate was a let down. Had no idea that a cup of water was going to cost $1.50, but it does, apparently. Counter service was pleasant and it's nice that it doesn't close at 8 on a Thursday. TL;DR: it'll do in a pinch, but not all of the goods are created equally. read more

2tarts Bakery - Cheeky jewelry in the gift shop - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I grew up in new Braunfels and have always loved 2tarts, I went back while I was home for Christmas, the person behind the counter was so incredibly rude to me and my family. Every order he took any add ons we got an eye roll and a sigh. Still trying to be understanding I tipped well and made sure to say please and thank you. I wish I skipped the entire thing- drinks were poorly mixed and made, even saying thank you after we got them we got his back turned to us. Unfortunately probably won't visit again :( read more

I ordered coffee and their peanut butter pie covered in chocolate. Good for those with sweet tooth and loves peanut butter. But recommend to share with someone. Too sweet to finish all by yourself. Support local businesses. This is one of them. Charming little place that also sell some cute knick knacks. read more

See all

My daughter picked this bakery as she was in the mood for something sweet. I am so glad she found this place. It's a cute bakery in New Braunfels that we had not tried yet and we always go cafe hunting. We must have arrived just before rush hour because it got packed super quick! The employees are so nice and patient. They have vegan and gluten free options and that was a plus! The cookies tasted great (that's what my girls said) and the cupcakes were "tasty". It was so tasty we actually got some more to go! Price wise it is what you would expect for a bakery, though some may not be wanting to pay $4 for a cupcake; to those I say "support your local small business". This is definitely a place we look forward to returning to. read more

See all

This place has lost its charm!! I purchased a 6" yellow cake with chocolate buttercream and it was not good! Presentation was nice I guess but no one like it. Definitely not worth the money spent. The cake was extremely dry and butter cream literally would break off the cake. That's how dry and old it seemed. It didn't seem like it was fresh at all. It must have been days old. Again, I am disappointed in the quality and the money I wasted on this cake that ended up in the trash. It was way overpriced. It's a rip off honestly! read more

I ordered several desserts, breakfast sausage kolaches and vanilla lattes to try. Super expensive. Over price for quantity and quality. sausages were not good and old. Crust fell off. Coffee lacked flavor. Desserts are Ok but nothing to write home about. The place has gone way down hill. UNFRIENDLY people, especially during the holiday season. Rating on scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being the best, I would give it a 3 on a beat day. I spent $65 and won't be back! read more

Well I had watched the Spring Baking championship season where the owner had won. So of course I wanted to try her place and support local. The ambiance was very cute and quaint. There was a big line and the only options left were what was in the case. We did not get there early enough to snag what we were really craving. Now we know. I think my favorite thing we tried was the mixed berry crumble bars. The fillings of the lemon bar and key lime pie were good, however the crust on the lemon bars was so hard I could not cut it for my son. The chocolate torte slice my daughter picked was good, but it is definitely for someone who likes dark chocolate. Over all I am glad I could check the box and say I have been. But if we come back it will be nice and early to nab some savory breakfast. read more

2tarts Bakery - Chocolate torte - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Had a very bad experience with quality of product and customer service. My family went to get pastries to go, when they got in the car and started eating they found insects in the pastries, not on top or in the bag but inside the actual dough. They took them back with the insects found in the food. The workers were not helpful and only offered to pick another pastry which my kids didnt want due to the begs from the last ones. Nothing was checked for the contamination and nothing was pulled from the case. They ended up refunding our order via a gift card a couple days later. We usually go here and get pastries for family events. Working in retail/ customer service this experience was not handled well. Check your food before eating it. read more

See all

Oh I wanted to love this place and was so excited to visit it since we followed the winner on Holiday championship. It was an okay bakery. Cupcakes were on the small size. I ordered a dirty chai and it was really bad. Out of the 5 things we ordered only one of them was good. The store itself is super cute lots of pretty candles and party supplies if i was in the area I would pop in again and try something else. read more

See all

Latte was great but they sold me 2 VERY old cookies. I know the economy isn't great and they are saving money where they can but come on...hard snickerdoodle cookies?? read more

This is a local favorite. I had been once years ago. Once I saw the owner win the holiday backing championship I knew I needed to come back. There is a boutique quality to the store as they have merch and super cute birthday supplies.The tiramisu cup was to die for. The cream was the best I have ever had.It was packed with flavor and the chocolate cake crumples made it that much better. The coffee compliments the chocolate well and it was not overwhelmingly sweet.WE WILL BE BACK!! read more

See all

Adorable bakery! Fantastic breakfast options! Our group had the Chorizo Fritatta, Coffee Cake, Pig in a Pancho (big sausage however), Cookies & Cream Scone, Vanilla Latte! Everything looked divine. New favorite! read more

I've been a patron of 2Tarts since it's opened in 2010. I remember when the store front only had a few tables and then it became a regular hangout spot, and they had to get more tables. I think they've lowered how much seating is inside since COVID, and they focus more on to-go orders. When it comes to the baked goods, they're amazing. Everything I've had from there has been delicious. Some of my favorite things over the years have been the fruit tart, red velvet cupcake, and the chocolate peanut butter pie. Some things are in the case daily, but they rotate out special items as well. They make a lot of their revenue in catering, so the storefront isn't as prominent. Let's talk about pricing--this place is not cheap. I was floored by their prices when they first opened, but you are ordering premiere baked goods. This isn't a sheet cake from HEB, after all. I do not recommend the coffee--every time I've gotten a coffee from there, the milk has been burned. Walk to Crosswalk or NB Coffee to get one instead. This gem has been an NB dessert staple for years, and will only continue to be popular. Ashley, one of the owners, just won a competition on the Food Network, so this place is starting to get national attention. Definitely worth going to, but I'm not sure I would laud it as hard as some people. read more

This is a nice little bakery that bakes a mean cupcake. Always fresh and never dry. Great flavors to choose from. Affordable. So good. read more

2tarts Bakery - Desserts Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all