I don't know where to begin! I visited this store in March 2021 while I (and a small group) was…read morespending a few days near Lewisburg. I primarily collect military antiques but my girlfriend was in the market for a vintage necklace so we popped in as it appeared they had some jewelry. Turns out they have a fantastic selection of antique/vintage jewelry and watches. The owners (Lucie and Barry) were kind, helpful and very knowledgeable. They have an amazing selection of vintage pieces and their prices are reasonable. My girlfriend and her sister bought several pieces of jewelry and I walked away with an awesome, art-deco wristwatch and Civil War belt buckle! The watch I picked out needed to be serviced so Barry did the work and then mailed it to me a few weeks later. It works and looks fantastic. While relatively small, they do have an assortment of smaller antiques but most of their inventory is jewelry/wristwatches. We went to the store three times in four days and we hope to go back next time we are in the area!

This little store is chock full of delightful surprises for those looking for something different…read morein a gift to either a relative, friend, or yourself! Barry and wife are very friendly, helpful and especially good on watch repair, watch history and watch inventory. Barry keeps an impressive collection of classic watches on hand, the kind of dependable time pieces you've not seen in decades, from the 50', 40's and more. This store is a must visit in Lewisburg for items you won't see anywhere else, items you loved once upon a time, but have forgotten about. As you browse at your leisure with no pressing salesman hanging over you, it's likely you'll find something small or large that you just have to have. And prices are more than reasonable. This is the kind of shop that any town would be proud to have, owned and operated by some very nice people.

I don't think it's possible for me to visit any place now without consigning. I think it is a…read morerelaxing hobby, past time, etc. This store is on the mid-end of consignment shops. I like the fact that they have several vintage pieces that are back in style again now. The store carries shirts, brooches, sunglasses (RayBans for $20), jeans, skirts, dresses, handbags, scarves and gowns to name a few. Well organized store and racks. Prices are reasonable. Nice added touch is that the owner is personable and has very good customer service.

In town with 3 college best friends doing some shopping. We always check out "resale shops"…read more Immediately upon entering the proprietor barked at me "shut the door!". I remarked that not all of our party had entered and yet she still felt the need to repeat her demand in exactly the same tone of voice. She then proceeded to follow us around the store, straightening things as if we had rifled through the clothes and left them in complete disarray (we did not). I felt that she was rude and unwelcoming from the start and throughout the time we were in the store. I will never go back there again and want to warn others to steer clear of this business!!!

Fantastic combination clothing shop! Some thrift, some brand new, huge selection. Very friendly…read morehelp. You can find something for nearly everyone here.

I gave the store my clothes to sell. They never gave me my money and every time i've tried…read morecontacting them about it they have left my messages on opened. Extremely unprofessional behavior from this store!

The store was recently rearranged and looks great! It feels a lot more spacious and well organized…read more A decent selection of clothing and a lot of fun random finds. The furniture is in good condition and very well priced.

I was able to find a few cool thrift finds at this place with very affordable prices. The staff was…read morevery kind and there is a spacious changing room.

If you're a true antique lover, Vintage 61 might disappoint. Much of the furniture is painted over…read morewithout care, stripping away its original charm. While the back section has more authentic vintage pieces, they're often overpriced. The shop doesn't accept offers, and staff can be overheard gossiping about customers.

FANTASTIC STORE! Melissa (the owner) is not only kind, she knows her stuff! Hence, I know I'll get…read morethe best eBay price for my treasures. Thank you, Melissa, you're the best!

I absolutely love my most recent pair of shoes from Champion. Everyone is so friendly and helpful…read morethere. I definitely love supporting a wonderful family owned business. They were so patient with me while I tried on different pairs, trying to decide what was best. They gave me very sound advice and I absolutely love these new sandals. I can walk for miles in them.

I REALLY, REALLY try to support local businesses , having a very small home run business myself …read more BUT I was not happy when I went to purchase a pair of shoes here today (which they have a large selection of) and tried to use a $20 customer loyalty discount. I showed them the voicemail I had from them and they said they don't do phone calls ."Oh it's from 2020 and Covid , that expired". Well when you buy good quality shoes you don't need to spend hundreds on shoes each year because they hold up and last! Sure I got the $10 Spring Sale discount. But needless to say I can get any of their shoes online at the same price or cheaper ,plus get miles using my travel credit card. Sorry but you should take care of ALL your customers, not just the really regular ones.

1/12/25 I have never been in Fenstys until now. I really enjoyed meeting the owner he was very…read moreproud of his business that he has turned over to his son more or less. Since I hadn't been there he graciously told us the lay of the land. I really enjoyed looking through the market. As with any antique mall there are vendor booths that are well priced and then insanely expensive. There is a lot to see for sure. One main drawback is this is a "CASH ONLY" business. If you read my reviews you know I hate cash only businesses. Luckily I had plenty of cash- as it turns out I ended up not purchasing anything. I was tempted to purchase a few items but did not. I highly recommend visiting- I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area. They have a little snack stand and a nice. Lean restroom to make your shopping spree comfortable. I did not eat here but I thought that was great! I was tempted by the enormous Valentines cards for 1$- but there were no envelopes. There was a cute seasonal booth where everything was a dollar and some booths had decent sales.

Found unbelievable deal on a new guitar. Guy had a lot of used and a few new ones, great…read moreselection, great condition!! Sounds great! Found other good deals here too! Was there for a few hours but didn't feel like it

I love their half off day but some of the staff needs a refresher course on friendliness.read more

High priced thrift store in small town. Not especially clean or set up with nice displays. The…read moreclothing offerings were lower quality brands and sorting and organization was meek. Linens were limited as were household items. Overall the building felt dumpy and dirty. Pricing was high for what was offered as well as the quality of the items. Parking is metered on the street. I stopped in because well I stop at all thrift stores. I did manage to find a few items. The staff was nice, although a little on the rough side. I felt like the town might have been impoverished which would explain the lower brands of the donated items. I probably will not stop here again.