YUM!!!! I love their cheese pizza and grandma slice. I had friends in from out of town recently and ordered a full pie, but usually just grab a slice on the way home from a party or work. I can't speak to other toppings, but the cheese pie- delish! read more

I ordered a margarita pizza with half pepperoni and half meatball. The presentation was delightful, and the taste was great! I haven't had pizza in a few months, so this was a real treat. I just wish they could have warmed up my cookies. :( read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Margherita LG - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Another cozy pizza joint in Williamsburg. Thought the pepperoni slice and Margherita slice were ok (pepperoni was on the salty side? Liked the Margherita slightly better)...both large slices. They sell whole pies and slices! Super cozy with limited seating and some stools along the window. Friendly service. read more

See all

Small storefront pumping out pizza with big taste. Stopped in quickly for a slice only to be met with a plethora of artisanal pizza. Thought the place is small, there was a crowd of people here on a Wednesday. I got these vegan pepperoni and a slice with marinated tomatoes. There was a nice white slice which I got to go but they had many others that looked good as well. read more

See all

They make a decent slice here at Williamsburg Pizza. The aesthetic definitely fits the shop and it's in a good area. I tried a variety of the slices and Margherita was my favorite. It was my first time trying the Sophia Loren and it was not bad. Service is good here. Decent pizza. read more

See all

Wow! Best tasting pizza in NYC. And I also ate the crust. Definitely worth taking a trip here. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Cup & Char Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza is absolutely disgusting. Eating this crap was insufferable. The dough is both hard and chewy. I struggled to pull bite and pull it apart. The cheese melted like a thin sheet. The sauce had no flavor. The crust would make a good chew toy for a dog. The white pizza was slightly more tolerable in flavor but still difficult to chew. The meatballs were the saving grace of the order. A dollar slice is much better. read more

Solid NYC pizza place, polite and efficient help from the staff, had me a cream soda for the first time awhile and it hit the spot per usual lol. Good pizza hit the spot, had a pepperoni knot too and it was too good. Once I saw there was create your own pie I saw the unlimited potential of this place! Ate inside with friends before we checked into our hotel room and liked the dining room. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Hands down the BEST pizza in Williamsburg! Employees and owner takes his pizza business to the next level and offers really wonderful service and difference types of pizza. Everyone greets each other and it's the best of the best in Brooklyn neighborhood pizza! The restaurant is authentic, cozy and the vibe is easygoing. There's still lights from the 40's & 50's and it's clean and inviting. read more

See all

Williamsburg Pizza has the perfect sauce to cheese ratio! Love this place for a perfect plain slice! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Cheese slice -- perfect cheese to sauce ratio - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A neighborhood late night pizzeria. They offer many unique slices but they're a little dry for my liking. Margarita slice is my personal fave. Regular cheese slice is a pass for me. They also offer garlic knots and pepperoni knots. Have only tried the garlic knot and it's pretty good. You get 1 for $1.50 but it's pretty large. read more

See all

The pizza here was AMAZING!! Especially the Margarita slice!! The bread was crunchy and fresh. The employees were nice & quick with my order. The place is small but homely feeling.. This may be the best pizza spot in this area. read more

See all

Not sure as to why this place has some bad reviews. Came here a couple of times and pizza is really good. Tastes very fresh! Not too oily or overly seasoned. You know you're getting your moneys worth! I always get margherita and grandma slices and they taste so delicious! it tastes authentic and the pepperoni and ingredients are very fresh and authentic. Place has enough tables to grab and dine in. The last time I got there all the tables were filled so that was a bummer although there was outside seating but it was too cold to do that so I took it to go. You can also stand by the window to eat but then it's weird so I took it go to. Condiments like cheese and pepper were readily available. read more

See all

A solid slide shop with a cozy interior. We got the apple bacon slice and the bianco slice with ricotta cheese. The apple bacon slice was unique but we could tell it had been sitting out for a while. The garlic knot was delicious. The Bianca slice was perfect. We went on a Saturday night and it was about a 10 - 15 minute wait in line and then to get out food. Overall 7.79 / 10 read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Apple Bacon, Garlic Knots, Bianco slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here for a very late night slice after hitting the bars and overall it wasn't bad but definitely one of those slices that tastes a lot better at 2am instead of 2pm. I got the margherita slice which was a pretty huge portion, definitely the largest slice I've ever gotten at a New York slice shop and a good value at around $6. The pizza itself was fairly mediocre, without much flavor from the crust and the sauce being pretty plain. The cheese was decent but definitely nowhere near the quality of the really good slices. Still, for a 2am slice it did its job. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Margherita slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Man, I love me some zah. I think I've tried almost every pizza join in manhattan already and needed to step outside of my comfort zone and try some of the Brooklyn pies. Heard a lot of good things about Williamsburg pizza and those things were absolutely correct. I was in the area and looking for a spot for some dinner. Unfortunately, there aren't a lot of options, so when I saw this place, I thought I was saved. Walked in near closing time so it wasn't too busy. Was greeted immediately and ordered a Grandma's and a regular. They were very quick and I was out of the door try these slices at home. I at first wanted to stick around and dine-in but it didn't seem like the best place to enjoy the food, but then again I came in near closing on a weekday, so it might not be the best gauge of the vibes or atmosphere. Overall, very tasty pizza. -cheese pull? Check -firm crust with a little flop? check -not too greasy but full of flavor? check check -chewy and soft interior dough? check This place hits my already high ny slice standards and that's really saying something. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I don't like leaving bad reviews unless there's something truly just terrible, and even then I usually don't leave a review because sometimes there's just a bad day. But I gave this place two shots before leaving this review, because sometimes there's just a bad day or it's just a preference thing. So the first time I didn't love it but I thought okay maybe it was an off day since it has some pretty good reviews and I didn't order it for a long long long time and then decided to try it again. So I tried it again and it was inedible. They must be making the dough and freezing it because it tastes like it has been kept in the freezer for months, and I know it was the dough because it was the pizza and the garlic knots. I tried so hard to eat it and couldn't. It was probably the worst pizza I've eaten in a very long time and definitely in all of brooklyn. read more

Very very good had two slices the Sophia Loren and a pepperoni piping hot and great taste great crisp. Def up there for a great slice read more

See all

Food is always good even the vegan slices and I'm not vegan. Always get my pizza fresh and customer service is great. Small place but I always find a spot to eat inside. Only thing I wish they had was beef patties but that's just me knit picking. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I usually buy pizza from here they are really good, but today I bought 2 grammas and 3 slices, 1 of the slices I asked to be put separately on a bag and not in the box with the others because it was going separate, when I opened the bag that black little thing was on the plate, it appears to be rat poop. Won't be buying from here anymore read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Rat poop - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Williamsburg Pizza was my first meal in Brooklyn and one of my last meals as I'm about to move out. I thought I review the place before heading out. This place was dependable especially when working late and needed a quick bite to eat. The auntie working the front is always friendly and serves you fast. The place gives a very neighborhood vibe exactly what NYC is all about. On to the pizza, the pizza is not the best in Brooklyn due to the sheer amount of competition however it is definitely above average. They have a variety of specialty pizzas both NY and Sicilian style (square kind). Definitely going to miss this place. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Apple Bacon - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They say NYC has the best pizza. Williamsburg Pizza is on the top of it! Best crust, and juicy slices! Dine-in or to-go, consistent quality! read more

Unfortunately I got super sick not long after eating here. Would avoid, plenty of other options.

Ordered a grandma pizza ahead of time so I was able to walk on, pick up my pizza and bring it home hot to the kiddos. This pizza was so flavorful and perfectly cooked. My kids are picky and even they loved it. Highly recommend! Please support your local and small businesses! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My boyfriend and I stopped by here for a late night snack. At around 10:30pm on a Saturday, it was fairly busy. I had a slice of the Sophia Loren, which had mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, garlic, and basil. It was delicious-- very heavy on the garlic! While it looks like an old-school pizzeria, I thought Williamsburg Pizza was more gourmet/modern than that, due to the prices and the quality of the slices. Had to reset my expectations a bit. read more

Great pizza, solid service. I've been during normal hours and got the grandma slice, then again at 3 am and they only had pepperoni and margherita but it was still really good. Highly recommend! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The grandma slice is outstanding! Fast service, super cute place. They also a have a vegan pizza which looks great!

10/10 pizza one of the best pizza spots in town, every bite feels like a slice of heaven

Came here for a late night meal and I was a bit dissapointed. I had high hopes going in, having heard of this place before. The prices of pizza by the slice don't justify the flavor, which was lacking. I got Tartufo, Bianco, and Paesano slices. They all looked great and were not the common pizzas having fresh and appetizing ingredients. Sorry to say they all lacked flavor, they were good just not something I would spend money on again. I was very excited for the meatball hero and it tasted very fresh, but again, bland. Didn't even have much saltiness to it, especially compared to some pizza slices. Overall I guess it's a nice spot if you have no other options after a bar, but not a go to during the day. read more

The food was not appealing after it was delivered. It looked like it was under cooked and when I called they said oh sorry contact Uber. Both companies sucked. I think a dog would've not even touched this. So freaking pissed. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Messed up veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great experience. One of my favorite spots in NYC. Love that they are open late and they have the nicest staff!

Stopped by this pizza spot twice during my last trip as it was close to where I was staying and open late for a bite post-concert. What we got: - Sofia Loren Slice - Pepperoni Slice - Margherita Slice - Garlic Knot Final thoughts: Spot is okay, but I've had much better pizza elsewhere. I found the slices to be thin and crispy, but also quite oily and lacking in the cheese department (though the bites with mozz were great). I like my pizza saucier and with more cheese, but that's just my taste. A protip if you get a garlic knot is to save that marinara sauce and add it to your left over slice if you also like a little more sauce! read more

See all

Ordered pizza here for our daughter's third birthday and I just want to acknowledge how accommodating they were in designing some of her favorite pizzas, and cutting them into small slices for her and her friends to enjoy! read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Brooklyn! Their specialty square slices are the best and they're also fresh since the food turnaround time is quick. My favorite one is the Tartufo which has mushrooms, truffle oil with mozzarella and parmigiano-reggiano cheese! One simply amazing square slice! Of course they also have the traditional pizza slices as well, there's something for everyone! read more

See all

While visiting from out of state I had this place bookmarked to try the vegan options. I got two of the vegan pepperoni slices and they met all my expectations! Crust- crispy outside, airy inside- not too dense Sauce - perfect amount of tang and flavor. If I was ordering an entire pizza- would definitely go "extra" on the sauce Pepperoni- - Be-Hive brand- if you do not know, this is hands-down the best vegan pepperoni product out there! Cheese- its vegan cheese what do you expect- but the components all together were a masterpiece. Tip: Do not bother with the standard slices- only go for the gold with the square pies! Just wish they had a few more tables or a bench outside to sit. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Vegan Pepperoni Slices - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tried the margherita pizza and the cup and char grandma. The margherita was my favorite flavor wise but it seems like all of the pizza has a very thin soggy bottom and is hard to eat that way. My friends literally had to roll their pizza to eat it. read more

Opens pretty late and honestly hits the spot on a night out. My friend and I stopped by after a party around 1am Saturday night and there was a line but it went by quickly. There weren't many options left so we both got the margherita but it was so good! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This little corner pizza spot was surprisingly very good. The service was so friendly, it just put you in a good mood. I tried the Cup and Char Grandma and the Vegan. Both were amazing! I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - The Vegan and Cup & Char Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very small, but there was no wait time for us on a Saturday afternoon around noon. The pizza was hot and tasty, there were a lot of good options to choose from Which is always a good sign. The pizza was crispy and held well. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

not really sure what's with the bad reviews. it's not trying to be the best pizza in brooklyn, but it does what it does well (which is a neighborhood pizza joint), and it does it with a smile. my favorite thing about this place is the service. fast, swift service that is kind and friendly, even when the line is 10 people deep. most unique slice is the tartufo. mushrooms galore with rosemary - delish! read more