We pre-paid for this hotel sight-unseen (and by "sight-unseen", I mean "without reading any reviews") because we generally trust the SPG brand collection; however, when searching the reviews later as an afterthought, we did get a little nervous in advance of our stay and chose to lower our expectations since the room was pre-paid.
Luckily, we did not have to keep our standards low for long. We were greeted warmly upon arrival. It's amazing how much the simplicity of welcoming and gentle smiles can energize you after long and stressful travels, and we continued to receive friendly and speedy service throughout our 3-night stay.
While all of the staff was prompt, pleasant and informative, we would like to include a special mention of "Tour-Guy" (sincere apologies for the ignorant, phonetic spelling). He was helpful, kind and playful, and made us feel comfortable and relaxed throughout our stay. He was also critical in collaborating with our amazing taxi driver in the execution of getting us back to the airport in a timely manner after my husband's last business meeting ran long. We made our flight to London just in the knick of time!
The location in Beşiktaş is definitely the best feature of the hotel. The brick-paved street is gorgeous and charming and we often opened the windows to enjoy the sights and sounds of Istanbul. We loved all of the coffee shops and cafes just outside of the main entrance. While some guest reviews complained of both street and party noise, we were relatively unaffected at night by any outside sounds with the windows closed on the 3rd floor ... but we are also New Yorkers -- so we inherently find comfort in the hustle-and-bustle.
While the stairs throughout the main common areas of the hotel can be cumbersome for travelers with small children (e.g., strollers), the staff went out of their way to make accommodations as comfortable as possible (e.g., providing a rollaway crib upon request, rushing to help with the stroller when I approached a set of stairs). And the staff was diligent about ensuring that we would never have to manage any luggage ourselves in any of the common corridors.
The property could use some improvements:
1. We know that the W's vibe is generally a dark and seductive mood, but it would have been nice if the "Work" lighting setting in the room were a bit brighter. Also, I wished there were a brighter lighting setting in the bathroom (particularly as a woman trying to put on makeup). Also, the very dim lighting in the foyer, which didn't have much of a higher setting, made it difficult to see in the closets.
2. The shower is very smelly. We had anticipated this flaw based on the other guest reviews about poor bathroom ventilation, but one truly cannot prepare for how bad it can be on some days (hold your nose!). The grout in the showers could use a heavy-duty mold & mildew remover spray and a strong scrub, particularly in corners. And the fixtures would benefit from a little updating (the shower head, for example, had some rogue lateral sprays that one might not appreciate if not wearing a shower cap). Thankfully, the floor tiles did not feel dirty, and we were able to exit the shower feeling fresh and clean despite the smell.
3. A waste basket under the vanity in the bathroom would be helpful.
4. The carpet was not dirty (to the naked eye), but it felt like it was probably time for a routine shampoo. Same with the sofa.
5. The furniture and decor is probably due to be freshened up, but the outdated atmosphere did not take away from our experience.
It was the excellent staff, who truly made our initial impression of Istanbul -- and our overall stay -- so wonderful. Thank you so much!
(This review was written for TripAdvisor in December 2017.) read more