Cancel

Open app

Search

Treasury Reserve

5.0 (1 review)

Treasury Reserve Photos

Recommended Reviews - Treasury Reserve

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Curt C.
2559
4229
1494

7 years ago

Helpful 7
Thanks 0
Love this 8
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Melbourne Girls' College

Melbourne Girls' College

2.3(3 reviews)
3.5 km•Richmond

As a former international student with my parents paying a lot per year for my education, I entered…read moreMGC with high expectations for both the quality of education and the overall experience. Unfortunately, my time there was marred by blatant racism and what I can only describe as borderline discriminatory behavior. At MGC, being racist as a teacher is a prerequisite to achieving a high position within the school. There is a deeply embedded culture of favoritism at MGC. Unless you fit a very specific mold;outspoken, popular, and consistently performing at the top you are overlooked, ignored, or even treated as a burden. I am resilient, compassionate, and shy. I didn't fit the school's narrow definition of "exceptional," I was often dismissed, unsupported, and made to feel invisible. Teachers, who are supposed to be role models promoting values like diversity and inclusion, often end up perpetuating systemic racism through their actions and attitudes. In Year 10, we were made to analyze Animal Farm by George Orwell, a novel that warns against the abuse of power and the dangers of inequality. Yet, within the very same school system, assistant principals and other staff members abused their authority, especially targeting students and parents who didn't speak English fluently. It's ironic that we are taught to recognize oppression in fiction, yet experience it in real life. The people who are supposed to protect and support us often end up exploiting our vulnerabilities. I personally witnessed troubling instances of mistreatment. On one occasion, I passed two year-level leaders who were openly speculating about another student in a negative light with their door wide open. Teachers repeatedly mispronounced my name, as well as the names of other Asian students, despite us making repeated efforts to correct them. I also witnessed blatant unequal treatment. While white students were running around screaming, Jo Jepson took it upon herself to reprimand the Asian students for simply peeling glue residue from their hands after completing an art project. Carolyn Zimmerman, an irrelevant figure at MGC, makes it her business to get involved in all the school camps, spending her time yelling at Asian students as a hobby. Tonia Douglas Scarfe never lets you speak for yourself. She constantly talks over you, dismisses your words, and refuses to listen. She is completely unreasonable. The treatment of students of color during school photos was especially distressing. Teachers handed out makeup wipes to several students of color, instructing them to remove their makeup, saying things like, "You look too brown," "Take your cross off," and "Take your hijab off." This behavior is appalling and highlights the deeper issues of racism at MGC. Even the wellbeing counselors, who preach about privacy and offering support, are not genuine. They frequently share your personal matters with others, including teachers, betraying the trust they are supposed to uphold. Racism at MGC often goes unspoken because students of color are frequently silenced by those in power, while white students are the ones benefiting from the favoritism. Tonia Douglas and Leigh Hanley seem to show a clear pattern of favoritism towards white students. On multiple occasions, these teachers have been seen letting white students off with just warnings, even when they've displayed behaviors similar to, or sometimes less disruptive than, students of color who receive harsher disciplinary actions. This behavior suggests a racial bias in how they apply the rules, which results in unfair and disproportionate punishment for students of color. White students appear to be treated with more leniency, often avoiding serious consequences, while students of color seem to be more frequently reprimanded or punished for actions that would typically warrant a less severe response. Tonia Douglas's behavior in the kitchenette has raised concern. It has been noted that she often gives students of color "weird looks" when they happen to be in the same space. This non-verbal behavior is a subtle but telling example of microaggressions; small, often unconscious actions that can convey bias or discomfort. These looks can create an uncomfortable atmosphere, leading students of color to feel judged, unwelcome, or scrutinized in an everyday, neutral setting. Even though no words are exchanged, these non-verbal cues send a message that these students are not fully accepted or may not belong in the same space as her. There have been multiple instances where Tonia Douglas, Leigh Hanley, Kate Nicholls have been overheard gossiping about studentsin their office, often with the door open. This behavior is not only unprofessional, but it also creates a toxic and disrespectful environment. Instead of maintaining confidentiality and treating students with the respect they deserve, these staff members seem to engage in conversations that undermine the students' dignity and reputations.

Melbourne Girls' College is sometimes regarded as a "private" public school. But with a series of…read moreunpopular reforms instigated by the new Principal, Karen Money, the gloss is gradually being taken off this formerly prestigious school. The Principal has won very little respect, admiration or affection since she took up her position at the College last year, but has earned a great deal of bad feeling. She doesn't seem to be a great fit. While she is recognised for her work transforming an outer-suburban school that needed rescuing, Ms Money has not successfully adapted her methods and approach to suit the more sophisticated MGC demographic. The once vibrant, relaxed and happy mood of the students is no longer apparent. Already long classes have been made even longer (now 75 minutes each). These can be very difficult for students to sit through, let alone learn in effectively. A lot of time is wasted, and spent socialising or surfing. Free-time, traditionally given on Tuesday afternoons for extra-curricular activities, has now been reduced in order to accommodate the new schedule. Morning house-tutorials have also been abolished and partly replaced with a Wellbeing Program that many students find "boring" and "pointless". Adherence to the uniform code has been enforced using demeaning sorts of rewards and punishments, described by student leaders as "ridiculous", and not consistently administered. The criteria for selected entry to the College has been changed from a leadership theme to one of science and technology. Respect for the student leadership has been notably diminished, with the Principal even refusing to discuss or negotiate some concerns. It sometimes seems that the College identity has been hijacked. I suppose that new Principals want to make their mark, but this school was already humming along very nicely and didn't need much adjusting. It had a few problems, namely the length of lessons and the double-maths component during Year 7 - this doesn't work at all well if the teacher is not good, and can put some students off Maths altogether. Languages are not introduced until Year 8, also as a double-component, which is problematic. If students feel swamped, they may not elect to study a language after that, and so will have had very little exposure to this important kind of intellectual development. My impression is that the education is not particularly rigorous: girls may do well on the basis of their talents or their parents' investment in tutors, rather than on the basis of their learning at school. We were delighted when my daughter started at MGC. Less so now.

Treasury Reserve - publicservicesgovt - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...