PROS:
1. It's a nice, smooth boat ride with lovely captains.
2. You are instantly welcomed with dozens of birds hanging out at the wharf, and feel the immediate sense of one with nature.
3. The trails are well-carved out (although not always marked, so be careful).
4. There were indeed a multitude of birds on the island!! The are not afraid to fly right up next to you, which is awesome. I checked so many off my list - the green Kakariki, the Kokako, the bellbird (so many bellbirds), the Tui, the whitehead, the Takahe, the saddleback, and the North Island robin. Did not see the penguins or the wood pigeon, unfortunately.
5. Gorgeous scenery, but I had to RUN to get just a taste of everything in order to make it to the departure on time (see the "cons" list). The beaches are spectacular, with the clearest water I've seen in all of Auckland!
6. If you dash away from the crowds as soon as the boat lands, you really do feel like you are almost by yourself on the island. It's very serene.
CONS:
1. $78 is FAR too expensive for what you're getting. $50 would be more reasonable. And on top of that, they CHARGE for maps (which is absolutely necessary or else you'll get lost, as the island has many unmarked forks in the tracks. Tip: Google a high-resolution map and print it out beforehand).
It's a basic island with hardly any amenities...not Disney World. It's so much cheaper to go to Rangitoto or Waiheke....why hike the prices for this one island? Yes, there are birds. But Rangitoto has the volcano element, and Waiheke has the vineyards element. Each island has its own niche, and I don't think BIRDS is a reason to more than double the price.
2. The guide walks are a waste of time, unless you really only want to see 10% of the island and are too lazy to research the island history/birds beforehand. Spend those 2.5 hours exploring on your own, so you're not bogged down moving at a snail's pace learning about every tree that was ever planted on the island. Trust me - you don't need someone to point out the birds. They are EVERYWHERE. Not to mention the incessant questions asked by the other people in your group, delaying you even further from seeing more of the island.
3. My biggest peeve - Why does the boat leave the island so early?? 3:30 (translation: 3:10 arrival to board), after arriving to the island at 10:20 AND having to sit through a long talk from the ranger that is full of reminders that are painfully obvious ("When you look up at the birds, be careful to watch your step and not fall off the track" - REALLY???), most of which are also repeated before boarding in Auckland. Could this not be done on the boat to save time??
By the time you FINALLY get moving, that's only a little over 4 hours to explore everything. Again - if the boat ride was $50, I'd be happy to come back and cover more ground on a different day....but I'm paying upwards of $100 and then I'm extremely limited with my time on the island. I was literally eating my lunch while hiking, just to see 80% of what I wanted to see.
4. The children. I was warned about this. The entire boat was ready to depart in Auckland, then a school bus full of noisy, bombastic kids boarded. What was supposed to be a relaxing, enjoyable hour on a boat turned into a McDonald's playground. Screaming, yelling, jumping from chair to chair....I didn't exactly arrive to the island feeling "fresh". No wonder I didn't want to sit through the excruciatingly-long ranger speech once we arrived. Thank goodness I didn't get stuck around them on the island, or all of the birds would have avoided us from all of the screaming.
TIPS:
Be sure to bring extra sunscreen! I put some on in the morning before I left, but by the end of the day I was baking in the sun. There are lots of open areas where you are fully exposed.
Be one of the first to get off the boat and then hightail it for one of the tracks as SOON as the ranger talk is over. You don't want to be stuck in a large group of slow-moving people who are talking loudly and scaring off the birds.
Like most people have said, either pack a lunch or buy a sandwich on the boat.
Keep an eye on the time, and know that you can't see everything unless you literally NEVER stop to enjoy the birdsongs or to observe a bird in your path...you don't want to be on the East Coast Track at 2:30 when the boat starts boarding at 3:10! read more