Best pizza in Prescott. Period. Vibe is great, prices are low. REAL NY PIZZA. Im there every week. read more

I only stopped in Prescott to use the bathroom on the trip to Sedona but why not get some food while I'm at it? I didn't expect much before walking in but this place took me by surprise. A small pizza is $10~$12 and you can buy the large slices for $4~6. I got one slice of each of ricotta, deep dish, combination and buffalo chicken and all of them were equally as satisfying. The marinara sauce was exceptional. It's a little more on the sweet side but it went well with the toppings. I'm excited to make a stop next time I'm going up north. I saw some reviews with remarks on the "attitute" of the employees, but really, they will treat you the same way you treat them. Plus, look at the name of the establishment before comparing them to God's chicken sandwich employees. read more

See all

Hello greasy pizza by the slice after a night of drinking? Yes please. The pizza was good here I will try other things next time. I will be back. read more

Born and raised in northern NJ eating arguably the best pizza and naturally my reference point . Been in Prescott the past 8 years and hadn't found anything close until Grumpy's came to town. If you like an authentic NY/NJ style pie this is it . Molto Buono. read more

Location, location, location. That's the only thing keeping this place in business. They were understaffed enough to make the wait time over 20 minutes just to order a couple of slices. Their attitudes fit the name of the restaurant, I almost thought they were being deliberately dismissive of me and the other customers as some type of shtick. Finally, I wouldn't be surprised if the paper plate had more flavor than the pizza. read more

Ordered a large pizza with two topping to go. Paid $32.00 and was not impressed with what I received. Although a very thin pizza you could not pick it up without it going vertical. I have had better frozen pizza's. Red Barron pizza would be a comparable comparison. read more

Pretty descent pizza for a walk-in sort of place. It smells amazing when you walk in and it's pretty clean inside. There were two guys working there today that seemed like "don't mess with me New Yorker type of guys," so they weren't exactly people friendly, but good enough to hear you up a slice of pizza. For a small pizza parlor, they had a lot of options of pizza toppings. We ordered 4 slices in total: pepperoni, buffalo chicken, margarita, and the house favorite: the Grumpy Sicilian. The crust is good, but the sauce lacks flavor. The specialty pizzas were actually really good, especially the Grumpy Sicilian. Super good. We also had a caprese salad, which was tasty, and the Grumpy salad, but I thought it was too sweet with the raspberry dressing they put on it. read more

See all

This pizza joint is nestled inbetween restaurants and bars in the heart of whiskey row! Small , quaint and full of goodness ! Just walking by the entrance you are swept away by the warmth of the pizza ovens and aromatic shells of pizza! The service is awesome ! Quick , efficient and honestly on point! The pizzas are deliciously displayed behind a glass covering in a buffet style setting. The options were plentiful including fried zucchini and calzones. Once you select your pizza of choice , into the big oven . It goes to get piping hot and get that melty cheese! The crust my friends is amazing , not thick not too thin but has that amazing crusty cornmeal texture so good! The sauce was dreamy not spicy not bland ! Definitely great for now and later ! Get it to go , take it to your fave bar nearby that dies not offer food options! Share with the bartenders or heck the locals! Keeping it on my hot list for my next visit ! Ready , set and go! read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Pizzzzzza! - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Some of these reviews are hysterical. Best pizza in Prescott?? Not even top 10. Pizza is a 3, being generous, and service is a 1. I get that it is called grumpy, but the owner is awful. I have been there a few times and was my place for cheap slice. I am in the food business and know the ingredients are very cheap as well. Today was last visit. There are much better options. read more

I like the pizza but every time I order the same pizza, I get charged a different price. Please update your wall menu to the correct prices so it's not deceptive. I shouldn't have to ask how much the same pizza will be each time. The owner is very unfriendly but the other employees are nice. read more

Food Service help was greatly appreciated was running low on calories that day trying to send some money western union

Grate Pizza, very grumpy. Love the place. Small store n I t much seating but worth the wait if crowded.

The literal Grumpy Sicilian that took my order was a disgrace to the service industry. I get the grumpy bit being your "schtick" but this guy was a proper ass. Just plain rude. read more

We think it is the best pizza in town with fast service! Cannot wait to order more. Thank you.

Great pizza, and sold by the slice, which is rare in AZ! Fairly close to NY pizza, which is also rare in AZ outside of Phoenix. Buffalo chicken slice was great. Regular cheese was good, although the sauce is a bit too sweet for my taste. They did also have Sicilian-style. I didn't try it, but it looked good. I'll be back when in Prescott. read more

There wasn't a lot of options for a late dinner when my boyfriend and I arrived in Prescott around 9 PM. This spot was right down the block from our hotel so it won by default. I'm not usually a big fan of reheated pizza slices and this pizza was what I expected. Decent for what it is but I'm sure their full fresh pizzas are better. We each got a couple of slices and took our pizza back to our room. read more

#CoVid Getaway Review: It's the second slice where it counts. The pie had just enough time to simmer down a but and GAWD you can taste the marinara. The crust was just right. This is how the Margherita is done! Thank you for a great meal and the 805 to wash it down! read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

The freshest ingredients! The crunch of the crust and the sauce all pairs so well. Prices are great!! read more

See all

Good service. Food was awful. Fried zucchini was rancid and not sure what was up with the beer but blah! Pizza was reheated bottom burnt and top was luke warm. Would not go there again unless hammered and even then maybe I would pass. read more

This is my husband's favorite pizza in town. We were enjoying some music down at the Bird Cage on a Sunday and ordered a couple pies to nosh on while listening to music! Quick, hot & tasty! read more

We absolutely LOVE this place! We never miss going in when were in Prescott. The pizza is unbeatable! My husband is from NYC and he swears it's the best pizza he's EVER had! We also love the New York attitude from the employees. Makes hubby feel right at home. read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - We always get a Sicilian pie to take home when we leave Prescott. - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

It's not just a name, one grumpy dwarf himself. Was so grumpy and miserable questioned why he was working there. They have several pizzas on display. They are not fresh. They take a slice of what you want and reheat it in their oven. It was gross. Do not go here. Even papa johns is better. read more

I honestly don't know why the reviews for this place are bad. This is one of my favorite places to eat for relativity cheap, and I think the fact they're open till 2 Friday and Saturday make up for closing at 7 other days. Not to mention the variety of stuff they have a really good. Overall just a good pizza place. read more

Pizza is delicious. Best mozzarella I've had in a long time. Veggies are tasty and succulent. Highly recommend! read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Main saloon - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Wife and I smelled the amazing aroma walking by and knew where we were having lunch. A couple of slices and some of their zucchini that was absolutely delicious. Would stop in for a slice without hesitation. read more

I had a slice of Sicilian cheese. It w As tasty with a crispy crust. They have some exotic pies , but I'm just into a good slice on regular pizza. When trying out a new pizza joint, like like to try just the cheese. Overall, I liked it! read more

Worst pizza ever. The dough completely lacks flavor and chew. All the pizzas are over cooked on the bottom. This combination creates cardboard. And the owner is simply not a nice person. read more

Great pizza, great cannolis and great service all for an amazing prize!! Will definitely come back.

We came here once before and the pizza was so burnt it wasn't edible, but we decided to give them another chance. Tonight we went back, the pizza wasn't as badly burnt but still not good. The 1 star isn't because the pizza was bad, the 1 star is because the guy behind the counter was an ass. read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Burned pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Excellent pizza! Legit and lovely ambiance on the square in prescott. Excellent easy casual service.

Hmmmm Walked in to order a pizza to take home and saw they had french fries with gravy Yum yum I ordered the pizza and than asked the person what kind of French fries do you have ? Looked at me and said something passive aggressive ..like the long kind I said ...Are they crinkle cuts ? Are they like Mc Donalds? Are the real potatoes that you cut yourself ? Mr smart ass said they are the kind from France ...as I left I told him there was no need to be a smart ass . I will never go back there ever again. Its should be called the A-Hole Sicilian instead of The Grumpy Sicilian. I dont care if their food is good ...I will never know .. read more

I left NY a few years ago. Went down the east coast and ended up in the Phoenix, AZ, area. Grumpy Sicilian is the ABSOLUTELY BEST pizza outside of NY. I bit into my first Sicilian corner in the past 10 years. Don's skip out on the fried zucchini...delish! Great food and good value. Don't miss out. read more

The grumpy Sicilian saved our night after waiting over an hour for a seat at another place and never even being seated. We decided to bail and see what else we could find, and we are glad we did because otherwise we wouldn't have tried the grumpy Sicilian. It was quick and convenient which was awesome, and the prices were outstanding since they serve by the slice. We were pleasantly surprised by the pizza too, it was really great! They have lots of different topping options which is awesome. The staff is awesome too. Overall we're glad we tried it and will be back soon! read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Pizza bar - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

I'm from St. Louis, Mo. Italian/Sicilian restaurant and Pizzeria capital of the United States displays the grumpy Sicilian sucks. It's not Sicilian pizza I've had better frozen and I'm very serious about this. I ran a pizzeria in St. Louis, and ours were the rated the best in St. Louis by the Post-dispatch newspaper read more

Simply the best! Fresh ingredients. Perfect sauce. Great crust. Prompt delivery via GrubHub.

One of the best slices of pizza I have ever had. Nice crisp, great flavor, great price and lovely owners. read more

The Grumpy Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Went in last night and got a couple slices to go and some fried zucchini per the recommendation of an employee. The slices were barely heated up before putting in the to-go box. The zucchini was bland and without flavour and the slices were ok, but nothing special. Totally understand the business thrives on late night, drunk patrons. read more

It's the only place open late in Prescott! Must go after bar hopping. They do have the "Grumpy Sicilian" persona, but pizza at 1:30 AM? Yeah.. I'll deal with grumpy, for that. read more

First time visiting from Southern California, we were greeted with a smile from the young man behind the counter. I could tell who was the Grumpy Sicilian, the cook. Lol he looked grumpy as hell. But don't let that fool you , he can make a delicious pizza. We ordered a Veggie pizza and a salad . Both delicious. I wish I lived closer. We will definitely be coming back on our next visit. I'm glad we ordered a large pizza to go . We are happy travelers. read more

The pizza is good. I like this place been here a few times. Nice and fast service too.