Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Coffey Compass Group

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Contact Agent

    You can now contact this agent directly from Yelp

    Services - The Coffey Compass Group

    Buyer's agent

    Listing agent

    The Coffey Compass Group Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Coffey Compass Group

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Coffey Compass Group

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Real Estate Agents 1,152 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Stewart Home Group

    The Stewart Home Group

    (4 reviews)

    Highly discourage anyone from doing business with this company. I attempted to purchase a home, in…read moregood faith, in Heritage Lake. Unfortunately, the disclosure at the home showing was not accurate --failing to mention mold, a furnace that is an explosion hazard, electrical issues, and foundational defects (Main beam of the home being held by shims). FYI, the house was not being sold as is and I would not have went through with any of this if they would have properly disclosed this! (Ironically, the owner of this agency boasted to be about strong communication and paperwork accuracy.) They basically stole took my earnest money due to claims that I did not submit my inspection response in time. Their agent, Melissa Cameron, said, "If you want your money back, take us to court." So I had to file in Putnam County Small Claims Court against the homeowner where the judge reviewed the evidence and ruled in my favor--but neither the homeowner nor Stewart Home Group has returned the funds. I'm a disabled U.S. Marine Corps veteran, and their actions nearly made me and my family homeless. This happened just two weeks into the purchase agreement, while the home I was selling was in escrow with a 30 day close leaving me with about 3 days to find a new home. To make matters worse, owner Stephanie Miller‑Stewart personally called me, bullying me to drop the small-claims case. She offered to return the money only if I agreed to back off--reminding me that the MIBOR Association dropped my ethics complaint, and warning that most people don't "do well" in court especially since I did not have an attorney, so I should just accept the money. They also retaliated against my realtor after I notified them of intention of small claims action against their homeowner. The stress, anxiety, and frustration they've caused my family and me is absolutely disgraceful. And they weren't even our realtors! Just sharing my horrific experience and I didn't even get the house!

    Buyers beware of Sarah Noel who is part of The Stewart Home Group. We purchased a home that she was…read moreselling that the owner had urinated so badly on the carpet and walls that we have to replace all of it. We were not able to look at the master bedroom, which is the worse, because the seller has dementia and was in bed. We were respectful and didn't bother the man. But this same man showed up at our closing fully dressed and pretty coherent. Unlike Sarah who was in Mexico on vacation and sent another realtor to face time the closing with her which was ridiculous. After 4 cleanings the room is still unusable. Sarah had the nerve to tell me she didn't notice the smell It burns your nasal passage it is so pungent. Shame on the owner and their realtor Sarah for not disclosing this and playing on our goodwill to be respectful to the elderly. They also pulled this same stunt with our Inspector when he tried to look in the master bedroom. It is a costly mistake, not to mention we over bid to get the house and they still said nothing. We did not get to do a final walk through before closing on the home. We were told the sellers needed more time to move out so we agreed to let them stay an extra 7 days after closing. That was a BIG mistake on our part and if you read the review below from Christopher Hargrave, this seems to be a pattern with Sarah Noel.

    Jackie Anderson - Trendify Realty

    Jackie Anderson - Trendify Realty

    (4 reviews)

    I am a lender and working with Jackie & Chrissy has been so good. Their whole model is to focused…read moreon the client, learning their needs/wants and meeting them. Communication is clear and consistent. I will also say they are top tier when it comes to presenting and negotiating an offer because they consistently come out with the accepted offer. If you want a real estate team who works with your best interest in mind and knows how to get that accepted offer, Jackie Anderson and Chrissy Steele are the best!

    Well, what to say about Jackie Anderson as our real estate agent. IT DON'T GET ANY BETTER!!!!!!…read moreWe've now sold and purchased multiple homes with Jackie and she is simply AMAZING!!! She listens intently to what you are looking for in your home and then goes about finding that perfect home for you. And does she deliver!!!! We have found our forever home because Jackie is relentless in finding that perfect home and doing everything she can to get you into that home. Our new home hit every "want" on our list and within budget. From recommending great mortgage brokers to fit your specific needs to recommending the most thorough home inspector on the market, Jackie will get the job done. And when it came time to find contractors to help us do some upgrades to the new home, I reached out to Jackie and she had all of the connections. She saved us a TON of money!!! Jackie is just as attentive and AWESOME when it came to selling our home. She was in regular contact with the buyer's agent and constantly kept us in the loop. When there was a couple issues that showed up in the buyer's inspection, she recommended the most affordable, timely, (did I say affordable?) and flat out likeable plumber I've ever used. He fixed the problem in no time, came out on an evening but didn't charge "evening" prices, and saved us a ton of money. The HVAC guy was even better. He came out and fixed the problem for 1/2 the price of all other quotes. This HVAC guy was super cool as well and went above and beyond. When I wanted to upgrade the heater in the new house's workshop, you know who I called. Once again, he was amazing. And to think, I would have never met this dude without Jackie. On both the selling and buying of our homes, we had problems with the other agents. But Jackie handle ALL of that for us. There are agents out there with zero scruples and we ran into those issues, believe me. But not Jackie, her ethical standards are the highest I have ever encountered, not just in real estate, but in business. She is always honest and truthful, will shoot straight with you without being condescending. She truly works for you as your agent. She took the hits for us and fought for us beyond what ever could be expected. We truly love Jackie and consider her now a friend, not just our agent!!! Let me just say it this way, JACKIE WAS SENT FROM HEAVEN ITSELF. She's an Angel agent and you're crazy if you go with anyone else. Yes, there's a ton of good agents out there but there's only one Jackie Anderson. She'll get the job done and treat you with respect, kindness and incredible professionalism. And not matter how much you bug her with the smallest of questions, she is always responsive and always acts like it's no big deal. I know I HAD to be annoying at times but she never once acted like it. We don't ever plan to move again but if we do, we're calling Jackie. YOU BETTER CALL JACKIE TOO IF YOU WANT YOUR DREAM HOME or if you NEED TO SELL YOUR HOME. If you want it straight from me, I give Jackie permission to give out my cell number to anyone that wants the BEST AGENT ON THIS SIDE OF ETERNITY!!!!! Yes, seriously, reach out to me. I'll tell you to hire Jackie on the phone, in a text, in an email, in Morse code, using the NATO alphabet, I'll plane write it or even send smoke signals. The message will be the same....HIRE JACKIE ANDERSON AS YOUR AGENT!!!!!!!!!! YOU WON'T BE SORRY!!!!!

    Joel Aguilar

    Joel Aguilar

    (14 reviews)

    Fountain Square

    Joel is an ALL STAR team player and real estate pro (and this is coming from career realtor and…read moreinvestor). I am proud of myself for doing the research before going with Joel as he was highly recommended on BiggerPockets forums - a place where real estate enthusiasts congregate. Joel helped us plan out our investment property selling strategy from 12 months in advance and he did an impressive job throughout the way, not to mention going above and beyond to help me with my rehab and saving me alot of money and headache! In the end he helped us closed the property at an incredible price at an astonishing speed, no words can express our gratitude and I just hope this honest review can help this man get the kind of business he deserves! Call him right away, you will not find an better Realtor in Indy. Guaranteed.

    Joel is an exceptional realtor - he just helped us sell our first house in Indianapolis and we…read morecouldn't be more grateful for his hard work, guidance, and expertise over the past few months. He is a clear and patient communicator, extremely knowledgeable, and just plain GOOD at what he does! Joel clearly loves his work, and that translates into a great experience for his clients. His personal engagement in the process is truly next level - we always felt heard and understood, and easily put our full trust in him. We unequivocally recommend Joel, and hope we have a chance to work with him agaian!

    Mathis Real Estate

    Mathis Real Estate

    (2 reviews)

    Realtor Jan Mathis is not responsible. She brought buyers to my house and would leave the lights…read moreon after leaving. They also used the toilet and the chain was caught and caused the water to run continuously. It made my bill be $150 dollars for the month. When I mentioned it to Jan she said I was responsible for that, but I gave her permission to be in my house to show it and make sure everything was the same when they left. She said she would pay half at closing, which she said was $50 bucks. I do not know what kind of math she took but that is not half. I never had a bill over $28 bucks when I lived there for over 7 years. I would not trust her to be in my house alone and you shouldn't either. She also gave the code to the buyers and they showed up at least one time without an appointment without Jan. I would not recommend them for anything.

    My landlord uses them for their property manager, my landlord is great I've known her since I was…read moregrowing up, however Mathis is the slowest and cheapest company at getting something repaired. We had a leak in our house that ended up flooding most of the down stairs, as well as a leak in the cealing upstairs. The contractors didnt find a source to the leak so they redid the messed up portion of the cealing and replaced the tile that had mold growing from the water leak. This took over a month to get done, they haven't even mentioned anything about putting us up in a hotel or something since we obviously couldn't live in the house with mold, we had to move our cat and dog out haven't heard anything from them about that we are ready to move back in to the place we love. They are just inconsiderately taking their sweet time having simple tasks performed.

    The Coffey Compass Group - realestateagents - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...