OK, short and sweet: Had bagels in NY and NJ, these are as good or better. Certainly the best I've had within 1500 miles. Re: Less than stellar reviews folks gave. 1. Yep, the sandwiches are not the cheapest for the size, not really overpriced either though. I find the meats and such to be good quality. Given the massive crowds getting sandwiches, charging less would cause the line to go out the door more often, people getting cold and wet. 2. Toasting... While it could be a "real bagels should not be toasted" thing, I suspect that the problem is that when it gets busy there is no way to speed up the toasting process. Thus, same as above, line going out the door = bad. As it is, even with a long line, it moves pretty quick. My only real complaint is that they don't have whitefish salad. Or whitefish for that matter. For the uninitiated: Whitefish salad is kind of like tuna salad, made without celery and with a rather pickled flavor. All over the place on the east coast. A manufacture in Federal Way WA used to make it (Samolux?) and it was sold on the east coast. Can't find it on this coast at all. read more

Bagelry bagels are so good, they have completely ruined store bought bagels. They close too early. Cash only? WTF! read more

We get bagels to go from here, good quality and good cream cheese, can't speak of service since the new year and new ownership, but I hear it's improved. read more

Hands down some of the best bagels you'll find anywhere. New York included. Their bagels are the best. The scene at the Bagelry is "classic Bellingham". It's an organic, laid back place with people from all walks of life lined up for a bagel. All are welcome. The breakfast special is da bomb. I take mine eggs over medium with a poppy seed bagel. Nice. Like bagels? Go here. They also make Bialys here. Finding Bialys outside of Manhattan is quite rare. These guys make real good ones. Most bagels you get elsewhere these days are huge, fat, puffy flavorless rolls with no soul. The Bagelry bagels are dense, satisfyingly chewy and wonderfully flavorful. They have a large number of spreads to put on, all made in house. Yup they make their own cream cheese. Now let's get this whole "But they don't have a toaster" crap out of the way. Think about it for a second. These guys do nothing but make and sell bagels. They even make bialys, something most people have never even heard of. It's a big shop churning out tons of bagels. No other bagel shop can survive in Bellingham very long because the Bagelry is so awesome. If they WANTED to toast your bagel they'd have a toaster. But they don't. Given all that you should conclude that they don't have a toaster for a reason and that reason is a good one. The reason is simple, their bagels are perfect. By definition doing anything more to them would make them no longer perfect. You can't make something perfect more perfect. They make bagels all day and no matter when you walk in there the bagel is going to be fresh and chewy just like a bagel should be. I'm a firm believer that the customer is not always right and I love it when an establishment has the balls to give the customer what they need rather than what they want. The Bagelry gives you exactly what you need: perfectly warm, tasty, chewy bagels. read more

I should have checked the reviews and saw that the place was cash only before I came, but that isn't why I'm rating this place so low. (Though in the time I was there, six different people didn't have cards. Suck it up and pay the damn fee, it's 2013). First, the good: my latte was delicious. Now the reason I'm rating them a two: 1) ordered a toasted bagel with lox and a toasted everything bagel with cream cheese. It took 15 minutes for that to come out. 2) My toasted bagels were allowed near the toaster for a few seconds but needed more time because it was basically a slightly warmed up bagel. 3) People who say you don't toast a bagel, correction: if the bagel is well made and can stand on its own, you don't toast it. These taste like ones I can get at the supermarket and hence need some toasting for any kind of flavor. 4) Lox were nothing special. Overall, I try not to hold a bagel to Montreal standards but this place was just not that great on any level. read more

I first tried their pumpernickel bagel when stopping at the co-op and grabbing lunch. I tore the bagel into bite-sized pieces and then dipped them into a house-made hummus. The latter was forgettable but the former filled my heart with joy. Good pumpernickel is a wonderful culinary treat, but excellent pumpernickel is a blessing from the heavens above. Pumpernickel in Seattle is nothing to write home about, but what The Bagelry has is something divine. We made tracks to The Bagelry so I could buy a baker's dozen. Two visual affronts come to mind when recalling my purchase. First, two mounds of flavored cream cheese in the refrigerated display case next to the bagels. I get that cream cheese is mostly fat, but those heaping mounds really drove the point home. But at least the mounds were smoothed into a pleasing ovoid shape? Second, a mannequin perched above the dining area wearing merch from The Bagelry. That mannequin looked like Dina Martina's best friend Doreen, and I don't necessarily believe that is a compliment. The bagels freeze beautifully. As I typed this review I enjoyed a toasted bagel with a wonderful crunch on the crust and a chewy center. I am already thinking about winter and making pumpernickel bagel chips for a hearty mushroom-barley soup. That is if I still have bagels left in the freezer before winter. Otherwise, yes, I will drive from Seattle to Bellingham just to buy pumpernickel bagels. read more

I'm going to venture to say that if I hadn't opted to slather my whole wheat bagel in peanut butter that I would have been able to discern the quality of the bagel better, but all in all, great breakfast! Agreed, a good bagel doesn't need to be crisp & toasted, just baked to prefection. We got our schmears and a NYT and thoroughly enjoyed being among the locals for what appears to be a town fave. Good coffee to chase it and all is well. I'd try again anytime, which will be soon, since I have a crush on sweet & charming Bellingham now. IF you are lucky, you'll see the old truck outside with four gorgeous dogs in the back, loyally awaiting their owner. read more

Been going here since I was a wee little lad...and I'll continue to return when I'm in town and downtown! Tasty fresh bagels, friendly waitstaff, and tons of creamcheese flavors to choose from! Go for breakfast or go for lunch either way you will NOT be disappointed! read more

Great selection of house-made bagels and soooo many schmears, it makes my heart (and stomach) happy. A true Bellingham gem. The only downside is that it's cash only, which I don't mind, but I know some people do. read more

The best bagels I have ever had. I haven't found anywhere that compares to the Bagelry. My usual is a whole wheat bagel with veggie schmear or a veggie sandwich. The staff is friendly and order come out pretty quick even when it's busy. One important thing to note is they are cash only. So don't go in expecting to pay with a card. read more

As someone who devoted 7 years of my life to the East Coast (learning where all the good Jewish bakeries were and more importantly where the best bagels, bialies and challah are), I cannot even begin to impart on you how hard it is to find a good bagel let alone a good bialy on the West Coast (hell, even finding a bialy in the first place is impossible) Well, low and behold, a trip to Bellingham, a jaunt for breakfast goodness and I stumbled on the treasure trove of oniony, poppy-seeded doughy goodness....otherwise known as a bialy. I subsequently bought what remaining ones they had and savoured every last bite. And they were just as good and fresh as the ones back in New York. I would definately go back for sure. read more

The bagels are fantastic; bagel service is fast; prices are reasonable; the daily vegan cream cheese option is bomb.

The owner threatened to "put the biggest curse on me" because I brought a small coffee in from my work. The staff is extremely unfriendly, the bagels are nothing better then something I could make at home, they only take cash, and they are overpriced. I would say stay clear from this place, there are a lot better eateries in bellingham that don't have crazy owners running after you cursing you. He cursed me because I told him I thought he was being rude for hassling me over $1.50 when I come in and buy $16 worth of bagels for my boyfriend and I 3 times a week. He then told me "coffee pays the rent, next time just take your bagels and eat at starbucks". I then got up and left and he ran after me. He said "I didn't say you had to leave, just don't come in with coffee again" I then told him again how much money I spend weekly at his business, and because of his rudeness I would never come again. He response "Well I'm putting the biggest curse on you, I hope you own a restaurant some day". You know I won't actually because I don't want to be a sad old man like you who gets mad at loyal customers. read more

Right at Bellingham's heart, Railroad Ave, lies the ever busy Bagelry! A prime Bham eat establishment with tons of bagel options- get the bialy- no hole! All deliciousness! They have plenty of seating for noshing your bagel sandwich or enjoying one of their multiple spreads on a perfectly toasted round. It can get especially busy on weekends and mid morning, so don't forget to bring your cash (CASH ONLY ESTABLISHMENT) and pay your parking meter. I'm a huge fan of their italian cream cheese, and will order sides to-go and a bag o bagels for camping trips or picnics. It's a great little place, and I definitely know your dollar goes far here for breakfast or lunch. They DO close early, check the hours before you set your heart on going. read more

The bagels were fine, generous amounts of stuff inside the bagel oh most sandwiches however very little flavor, egg sandwich had no seasoning, not even salt or pepper, the wait was about an hour so I definitely recommend curbside pickup, prices however are pretty solid. Overall it's an average bagel shop no more no less. read more

I'm probably spoiled because I grew up in the northeast and even with tempered expectations, these bagels are very mediocre. They're small, flavorless, and when I ordered a a lox sandwich, I got one tiny slice of salmon in my bagel. I'm not shocked at the high star rating for this place because most raters seem to be native Pacific Northwesterners who don't know what good looks like, when it comes to a bagel (the same reason why all the pizza places in town have a high rating even though they're not that good). A word to advice for those who've never been to New York, New Jersey, Montreal, and any other place known for good bagels. A good bagel is BIG and chewy. When you order a bagel sandwich, it should be piled with your chosen protein; the cream cheese should be generously spread onto the bagel. And a lox sandwich, even if it will cost $10, like it does out east should have heaps and heaps of smoked salmon! read more

UPDATED to 4 stars from 3. I live nearby and have been here a few times. Their bagels are good and the prices are reasonable. Our favorite is coming after church on Sunday, grabbing our toasted Pumpernickel bagels with Feta or Lox cream cheese and heading home to enjoy with coffee and eggs. Getting hungry just thinking about it! The art on the wall adds a nice touch and I like the wide open and relatively inviting atmosphere. The staff has always been fast and friendly. However, as most people have stated, cash only. Which I get. They say to keep prices low and keep the place local, but man it makes things a little challenging and it was incredibly embarrassing the first time I was there and didn't know and had to step out of line after I ordered to use their ATM. Overall, I have enjoyed my experiences here. I used to have it at 3 stars because it just didn't seem that special to me and only taking cash really bothered me. Now (having been here almost every week for the last year and a half. I see that the prices are basically unbeatable, their service great, and their fresh-baked bagels are the best in town. read more

Their bagels are excellent. They also offer good quality deli meats and cheese. I bought some to put in the fridge at work to make sandwhiches for the week. The only reason they don't get 5 stars is becuase they don't take plastic. Cash only. That's also the only reason they don't get much business from me, I very rarely carry cash. Otherwise I'd go there all the time. read more

Ok, so much has improved since last fall! Maybe the new kids are broken in, or the crappy ones have left, or maybe the owner read some reviews and runs a tighter ship now. It's not what I remember teething on as a child, but hey... what is? The bagels are better and fresher lately, they're a little less skimpy with the cream cheese, and the register folks are much more efficient and friendly. The one downside is, if you order anything other than a bagel with an schmear, expect to wait. And wait. And wait some more. Even for a cheese sandwich (I like the muenster one!). Ohhh well. Can't argue with the prices or the taste. I will ALWAYS hate that damn mural, though. read more

Best bagels in town. The rosemary sea salt is what dreams are made of. I haven't had their sandwiches so I can't say how good they are but the bagels deserve five stars. read more

We would have rather gone to the cafe just up the street with better reviews, but it was full, and one of us was having ugent bathroom issues, so we went into The Bagelry. Outside of the service, which was excellent--the staff is working hard and very friendly--It was not a good experience. 1. The tables were filthy. Covered with the remnants of a few past meals, it was so busy, none of the counter staff could spare time to come out to wipe down the tables. 2. Cash Only. They accept cash only. No sign on the door states this, the person taking my order didn't let me know. In fact, there is no signage anywhere that states they are only accepting cash, except at the register, which you get to only after you have placed your order and have waited in line for 15 minutes. At the register there is a sign that thanks you for your patience since the checkout system is new and the staff is unfamiliar with it. There, on that handwritten sign telling you about the new registers, in parenthesis at the bottom--as an afterthought--it mentions "We aren't accepting credit or debit cards, yet." Fortunately, I had $10 on me and didn't have to cancel my order. 3. Though, I wish I had cancelled my order. I asked for a toasted everything bagel and a drip coffee. The everything bagel came out warm and crispy, but not browned or toasted in any way. I could have lived with that, but the coffee, even after adding cream and sugar was undrinkable: bitter, burned and far too strong. It tasted like it was the dregs of the carafe and had been sitting on the warming plate for hours. I suppose what I am saying is: don't go. read more

If you are a true Bagel lover this is the place! They make just about every type of Bagel known to man and just about any spread for your bagel as well! My personal favorite is the Sesame Bagel with the lowfat Italian cream cheese, w/ tomatoes and sprouts! I got this atleast once a week, such a yummy treat to fill you espicially on a Saturday afternoon when you are walking around downtown! read more

See all

The bagels are good, but the line for them is very confusing. You're given a ticket, wait in line, and then step out of line to wait for your bagel; plus there are so many counters that I wasn't sure where to go at first. I'll go again because they price fairly and I look forward to trying their bagel sandwiches. read more

Those are some seriously good bagels and cream cheese. The bagel shop trend has all but died in Vancouver, where I'm from, so this place is a destination when we visit Bellingham. We buy this crack by the bagful and gobble it down before it goes stale. The Bagelry's bonus is equally good coffee. And friendly service, a rare and precious gift. "Ehhh, no bagel, no bagel, no bagel!" Sorry, I was moved. read more

It's. a. bagel. Haggen, Grace Cafe (great place and people), and so many other places sell them. But all of those other places will happily take my credit card. If I want to buy my office a bunch of bagels and cream cheese from the Bagelry, I'm expected to bring in $80 in cash. Please don't tell me to use that rip-off cash machine. When you join the 21st century and accept my credit card, I'll gladly go...until then, i'll happily get my round puffy bread elsewhere. What is it with local Bellingham businesses and their "greater than thou" mentality? read more

Omg so. Slow. So painfully slow. There are two counters but the signs made it fairly clear where I needed to go to order. I ordered a toasted rosemary salt bagel to go. Then I waited. And waited. One person ahead of me, one person ordered after me. At least ten people working but no one really doing anything? It is so hard to explain what I experienced. Nearly 15 min later I was handed a non-toasted bagel. It was tasty (I bet tastier has it been toasted!) but I won't be back when visiting B'ham. read more

A bellingham classic! Bagels made fresh every day, all kinds of amazing flavors of cream cheese, and vegan options too! They do a great job. Don't expect any frills, but definitely expect great food. I just wish they'd bring back their house made hummus! read more

For being a west coast bagel shop...these were very very tasty. A nice crust with a soft inside. Yummy coffee! The omelets to match up with your bagel very good! My friend was very pleased that they had bialy and bought what they had left to go as he hadn't had good Bialy since living on the east coast! We would go back! read more

Bagels are a food group, right? You'd think so from the people at the Bagelry. There is nothing... absolutely nothing like getting a dozen bagels in a bag, and eating one on the way home. So good. Their sandwiches are excellent. All varieties available, including those you make up yourselves. From breakfast to late afternoon, they are there for you. The line for ordering and order delivery is confusing only the first time. They have bits of halva, and other desserts if you are so inclined. If I had lived closer, I would have walked there every day. Fortunately, I lived in Fairhaven so it took a bit of a drive to get there. Of course, one could forgo the dessert and go next door to Mallard's Ice Cream shop. Now talk about delicious -- and inventive. But that's another review! They even take special orders such as whole wheat sesame by the dozen if you order a day ahead. Make it a regular stop when you're in town. read more

The Bagelry has been nothing but good to me. Their bagels and spreads are the most delicious thing I have ever encountered. You can find my friends and I "recovering" their most Saturday mornings. I wouldn't dare get a bagel anywhere else. read more

I don't understand how the Bagelery only has 3.5 stars on yelp. I grew up on these bagels, and they're by far the best bagels in Bellingham, and maybe the best bagels I've ever had. I highly recommend their chocolate cream cheese, strawberry cream cheese, and their bagel sandwiches. read more

Love this place. Ken the owner hires students from WWU and WCC and treats them well. (I actually hired one of them away from him years ago - Denise was that amazing) He is fiercely local/loyal - so don't bring in your starbucks or bring in a giant ego - you won't be appreciated in our city of subdued excitement. Cash or local checks only - credit cards cost too much to process (and raise prices). The food is quite good - you can tell by all the locals coming in and enjoying. Come early in the day if you want a warm bagel - they don't toast them at the Bagelry (it's somewhat of a religious issue). A warm buttered Sesame Seed bagel is nirvana - love them! My dream breakfast is a farmer's omelette (they'll warn you because it'll take awhile to get to you but it's amazing) with the above sesame or a bialy (slight extra charge for the bialy). Combine it with a great cup of coffee and you won't be sorry you stopped in. Family friendly, student friendly, music on weekends (outside). If you come early enough, you don't have to feed the cities meter... read more

I love the charm of this place. The servers are super friendly and it just feels like there have been some good times had here. One of the friends we came here with ate here since he was a wee lad, and said not much has changed (in a good way.) If aint broke don't fix it. But yes, one thing we might agree upon as being 'broke' is that they only accept check or cash. I was going to buy six Bialy's, but instead only bought one because of the cash factor. The bialy's are delicious, the difference between it and a rego bagel is there's no hole, But there is almost a hole, it's just poppy seeds and onion and so forth baked (like the thickness of a sheet of paper) where the hole of the bagel usually is. Also, Bialy's have less sugar and salt, and are not boiled. I love them. I had their vegan soup, it was north African something or other, not my cup of tea...or soup. read more

Not many places around for 'real' bagels. If you've only ever had bagels from a store in a plastic bag, you need to get down here! Nice crispy exterior, soft and chewy inside. I had a toasted sesame with cream cheese. Brought me back to my younger days back east. Took home a dozen, of everything, and poppy seed, and a few cinnamon raisin. read more

This place is cute, but fairly noisy. They only take cash, so be prepared for that. Their bagels are absolutely fantastic -- perhaps the best I've ever had. Their coffee is great, too, and everything is very reasonably priced. I would not recommend any of the omelettes. They are spongey and utterly flavorless. The cheese is bad, the eggs are bad, the fillings are mediocre. However, it is called the bagelry and not the omelettery, and their bagels are, in fact, superb. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

We did walk up ordering and the service was great. According to my husband he had the best bagel ever! I had the mushroom barley soup which was heavenly! Sure wish they were closer... read more

The Bagelry is one of my favorite lunch spots in Bellingham. I would always grab a tuna salad on garlic. It comes with a pickle and baby bag of chips, and it's was always enough for me to spread out for two meals unless I was absolutely starving. It's always pretty crowded but it adds to the fun atmosphere, and the staff is always really quick. The food is definitely worthy of five stars, but I grabbed an iced mocha and it was actually the worst coffee drink I have ever gotten anywhere. Also, I always forget that they don't accept cards and have had to grab food somewhere else if I was in a hurry. read more

So I stopped in for bagel and lox sandwich which I ordered. I asked for NO onions on the bagel. When I opened it up it had onions on it, as well as lettuce (not sprouts like I wanted as well as being advertised) also the tomatoes that were on it were slimy. This was at 8:15 in the morning! I will NEVER eat here again! read more

They got my order wrong, were incredibly rude to me, and refused to refund my order. Do not every buy food here, the store and its employees are garbage. read more

Pretty good bagels and a nice ambience. 75 cent fee if you use debit/credit under $5.