I recently ordered 2 cakes from Starry Night for a joint 70th and 80th bday party. One was carrot cake with cream cheese filling and cream cheese icing - BEST carrot cake I've EVER had. It was so moist, icing was amazing and it was very dense. The second was a devils chocolate with raspberry filling and buttercream icing/ again, AMAZING! People couldn't stop asking where I got it from. It's 4 days later and I'm eating it every night as a "guilty pleasure" until it's gone. It's that good. You don't get tired of it! I unfortunately didn't get a picture of the cakes, but they were beautiful. One was a teacher theme and one an owl theme. I ordered them over the phone so I was scared, but they were perfect! Will be back for EVERY occasion! read more

I ordered a 12 mixed gluten free cupcakes for my sons birthday. Not very good at all. They seemed like they may have been frozen. Dry and disgusting is all I can say. They were not cheap either. I have had better from there. read more

The people who work here suck. They are so rude and complain when they actually have to work! Their hours suck and they are barely ever open. They act so stuck up but they literally are in the worst spot ever in some little hidden shopping center. It's literally only westminster not like New York or something get over yourselves honestly. One of the workers made a loud rude remark within earshot of me about me! Because I wanted a cupcake and they were closing soon. Literally all they had to do is put it in a box and ring me up. Imagine actually having to do your job. Sucks would never go back. Overpriced and overhyped. read more

We paid $50+ for cupcakes for an event. If you're buying from a bakery and paying high dollars you expect a better than decent product. Cupcakes were very dry, which imo is worthless. How can a bakery not make a moist cupcake? Do they think if you put mounds of icing on the top that folks won't notice their dry cupcakes. Wish I could get my money back. read more

They redid the inside of the bakery to make it bright, white, and rather sterile. I miss the comfy couches and the otherworldly vibe that made Starry Night true to its name. It was a great place to hang out and drink coffee and eat delicious baked goods, but now it feels a little too fluorescent. I haven't been back since. read more

From what realm do the wizards queens behind these cupcakes hail? All nerd-age aside, oh my god the vegan cupcakes here are good. I took a half dozen into my work and the non-vegans exclaimed delight also. I had the chocolate, the red velvet and the vanilla (and there are lemon too, but those were sold out). You get to pick what frosting you want, and there is vegan chocolate ganache that is straight up fudge heaven, and vegan vanilla buttercream that is a pillow for angels to sleep on. This place is a little tricky to find, but for such a gem, who cares that it's a little out of the way? It's not like it's that out of the way - it's just in a cluster of stores off a street. Puh-lease, people who say it's hard to find. And honestly, it feels good to get away from the busy, hectic parking lots of grocery stores and Targets. The service was super friendly, the inside has kickass art all over the walls; it's an eccentric pastry paradise. Try it! read more

This place and the staff are amazing! I drive up there from Bmore because they are the only bakery I will use. I'm diabetic and this is the ONLY place that makes sugar free items. They will be making my wedding cake and cupcakes and doing sugar free! I had other places laugh at this request, they took on the challenge! The staff will go above and beyond for you and your needs. Have some of their products missed the mark? Very few and they welcome the feed back. I love this bakery and will continue to use them for all my special occasions. read more

Tried this place out because of a Groupon deal. The signage isn't very good , and even the front door was not labeled or welcoming at all. While I was looking at all of the fancy cupcakes an employee was cleaning the interior of a bakery case by spraying windex directly onto the glass and in the direction of baked goods for sale! I of course chose something out of a different case. I ordered a 12oz latte that allegedly had 4 shots of espresso, but it was not strong at all. Fortunately the baked goods all tasted fine and seemed fresh. read more

I have gotten 2 special order cakes/cupcakes for parties that I was hosting. Although they had a variety of flavors for cake, filling, and icing, we weren't super happy with the flavor. It just tasted...sweet. Texture of the cake was good, as was the texture of the icing. They also did a great job with the decorations and colors on the cake. Looked great, but the taste wasn't there to warrant the higher prices. I believe in giving a place a few tries before I write up a review, especially for small businesses. I have gone in a few times for coffee and grabbed a cupcake or scone or whatnot. Coffee good, but the food wasn't good enough to bring me back. read more

I have gotten several cakes from here and they've always been delicious, but hear me out. The cakes are spectacularly priced and undersized for what they say they serve. I once ordered a custom cake in the shape and flavoring of an eclair and they charged me $65 for it. What it really was, was a cake baked in a rectangular pan, covered in chocolate icing and filled with cream filling. They charged me $65 for a giant turd looking cake and it was probably about 5 inches wide and 9 inches long. I've since stayed away from their fondant and icing work because it's truly uninspiring and mediocre when compared to other cake makers in the area. That being said, the only thing I continue to order from there are their whimsy cakes. They really are adorable and taste good. They hold up well in the fridge and freezer for a number of days. The only down side is that they charge an arm and a leg. Your cake will cost you anywhere between $70 and $150 depending on a (reasonable) size to feed less people than they tell you it will. Overall they make good cakes, have a wide variety of flavors, and if it weren't that they were so damn delicious I wouldn't pay the outrageous prices for them every few years or so. read more

Way too much icing on the cakes! Who likes lard and sugar? Is that the only kind of "icing" available up here? Yuck. The staff are also very unfriendly and boring. I tried to have a conversation with the girl ringing me up and I felt like I was talking to a wall. read more

Their specialty cheese cakes are amazing. I love the cannoli flavor and the "turtle" style the best! Sometimes I have gone in to get something for a special occasion and instead of getting one big cake I'll just get several cheese cake bars or cupcakes so then my party can all try something different. The inside of the bakery is decorated and painted so cute! Shannon the owner is so talented and professional and is a great person to have running a small business in town. There is a large parking lot so it's never hard to find a spot. read more

The cakes look amazing, no doubt about that. The cupcakes don't taste homemade though. I'd be surprised if they didn't come from a box mix and bucket frosting. They have that fake, plain flavor. Not worth $2.50 a piece. Like someone else said, the staff is courteous enough, but certainly not friendly. read more

I went in because they were in cupcake wars, I thought they would be great. My first visit last month was great. The customer service was good with the young girl who took my order. I returned specifically because I wanted to see her again and she wasn't there, there was a new girl who just started who was bad. When a month ago the other "new" worker was so much nicer. I won't return due to customer service at this place. I thought they would all be as good as the first girl a month ago was. read more

Starry Night made my wedding cake. We were a little worried about the cake being dry because some of the cupcakes I've had at the Bakery were dry, but this did not turn out to be an issue. Everything was delicious. Our wedding cake experience started out with a complimentary cake tasting. The bakers at Starry Night helped by making suggestions on which cake and filling flavors worked well together. We did not want our cake to be too fancy looking so we picked a simple design. A few weeks before the wedding, I unexpectedly lost my job. The bakers at Starry Night provided options for me to help reduce the cost of my cake. Instead of doing a 3 tier cake, we went with a smaller 2 tier and a half sheet cake. This ended up working out perfectly and we took a large portion of the sheet cake home to enjoy later. It also reduced the cost significantly. I was really impressed by their willingness to work with me to reduce the cost of the cake. They did not have to do it because I had already signed the contract. This is great customer service! read more

We needed a last minute cake made for a 40 person party and they nailed it with only 24 hours of warning. We were nervous about the 12 inch square cake being big enough for that many people, but had plenty left over. The cake was moist and delicious. Service was excellent and they have great coffee to boot. read more

The service here is amazing. It is a nice cozy environment with great music! The girls are very pleasant and enjoyable and the cupcakes and cakes are absolutely to die for. Multiple different options for diets and allergies. The coffee is easily the best in town. I will continue to come here! I'd reccomend it from daily coffee trips, to hang outs with friends (free wifi!) Or big celebrations! (Cake prices are so reasonable!) read more

Ordered yet another awesome cake from Starry Night Bakery. The cake was moist and delicious even despite the fact I served it a day later than I ordered it. Highly recommend the oreo mousse filling! My 4 year old son adored his colorful, creative Paw Patrol themed cake! read more

Starry Night Bakery - Scrumptious Paw Patrol themed Birthday cake made by Starry Nights Bakery! - Bakeries Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

I have had starry night cakes and cupcakes multiple times and have not been disappointed with taste; the decorations are good for the price. The chocolate chip cake that I got for my sisters graduation had probably 20 chocolate chips total which was a disappointment because it was basically vanilla cake. While I find their cake delicious I have been told that it isn't homemade; a former employee told me that the cake mix and the icing comes from a box. read more

Hands down the best bakery in town! I don't like typical bakeries and the stuff they produce because it always seems really dry to me. Starry Night is now my go to place for any bakery need. After years of making my own cakes/cupcakes for birthday parties and get togethers, I no longer feel the need to do it myself. I've found someone who does it so much better! read more

Great bakery with an eclectic flair to go with the usual standards. Great coffee too. Prices can be a little steep, but worth it. My fave is the Boston Creme, so thick and high a slice barely fits on a plate! Biggest complaint is they don't make meringue, replacing it with a creme topping instead. It's good but still not meringue. Love supporting local businesses and this place is one of the best in Carroll County! read more

AMAZING atmosphere. They get a 3 for food but a 5 for cupcakes. This place has the best cupcakes you will get anywhere around. Vegan cupcakes, and Gluten-Free friendly. read more

Great coffee and desserts, a must stop for travelers in the Baltimore area! We had the Cookie Dough Cupcake (awesome surprise in the center) and the Red Velvet (icing was ). read more

From butterscotch puddings to cinnamon rolls, this is the pastry place that has always delighted every member of my family. I am so happy we live so close by. I can easily go and order if I need anything. read more

WOW!! Talk about going beyind our expectations! Recently, I had the pleasure of ordering a groom's cake from Starry Night. I was really not sure how a Navy Diver's Helmet would turn out in cake form, but I should not have worried for a moment. This cake was absolutely beautiful! It was as realistic and professional as it could possibly be. I transported it an hour away to my nephew's rehearsal dinner and Starry Night had it in a very sturdy box that made it so easy. Everyone decided the cake was too amazing to cut, so we took it to the wedding the next day! It still looked perfect and tasted absolutely delicious. Thank you Shannon and Starry Night for making us smile!! read more

Starry Night Bakery made our cake and cupcakes for our 8/16/14 wedding and they were beautiful! The whole setup was amazing and they made the cake exactly to our specifications. We had our initial taste testing and despite our difficulties in choosing what we wanted (everything was so good) they were extremely patient and accommodating. The cake was delicious and the cupcakes were a great option for those guests that did not want a piece of cake or wanted to take their dessert with them. They also came and set up the cake and cupcake display which turned out perfect. I would definitely recommend them for a wedding or any other event that requires a great dessert. read more

I ordered my wedding cake here and it was amazing. It was SO good. It couldn't have been better. It was exactly what I wanted. Everyone raved about it. We didn't have any leftover. I would definitely go here again. read more

Made me a decent Americano but I didn't like that they only had a size small or large. Their baked goods are a little pricey but the pumpkin white chocolate muffin I had was excellent. With Starbucks just around the corner though, I'm more likely to head there instead of here. read more

I visited this store after hearing rave reviews about this place and after seeing it on Cupcake Wars. Unfortunately, they did not live up to my expectations. The cupcakes I bought (for $2.50 each!) Were a bit dry and stale. The frosting was crusty like they had been sitting out all day! I went back another time and had a cheesecake, which was much better. The employees were courteous, but by no means friendly. The decor is funky and eclectic, which I appreciate most of all. they have open mike nights and those seem fun, but there is very limited seating so when we went there was no place to sit. I have never had any of their drinks so I cannot comment on those. It's just ok, I've definitely been to better coffee shops, but unfortunately none of them are in Westminster. So basically, it's convenient, so it's where I end up when I want a laid back coffee house environment read more

After reading all reviews on Starry Night Bakery I decided to give it a try. I bought a cake from the case so this cake was not made to order so my review is based on this experience. The cake itself was a little dry however the icing was stated as a butter cream. It tasted like whipped lard with a hint of sugar. It was bad enough that I told my guests toss in the trash. Sorry for the bad review the cakes were very beautiful just wished that the flavor was there. read more

Best cakes ever! I've gotten 2 custom cakes done for daughters' baby showers and they were beautiful and delicious! Exactly what I was looking for! Shannon made the designs exactly how I pictured them and they were also so tasty! read more

We came here because we read they were on cupcake wars and we wanted to give them a try. Very on par of what you would get at a basic supermarket bakery. The children liked their cupcakes, but my husband's blueberry scone was extremely chewy and underbaked. My coconut macaroon was also extremely chewy and did not taste fresh. Pricing was appropriate for the offerings. read more

I can not say enough good things about Starry Night. Once again they made my family an amazing birthday cake. For 8 years our little girl has been so happy with her cake. Princess themed this year. Not only is the cake so pretty it tastes amazing. thank you starry night & staff. always there to help and create a wonderfull cake. read more

What a disappointment! Went here for lunch and dessert with a friend who raved of the bakery and I left sorely unimpressed. The staff was not very friendly and the sandwiches took over 15 minutes to prepare (for a kid's grilled cheese?!). The cupcakes were dry and the frosting was hard, perhaps they were made days before instead of fresh. I have been to plenty of unique coffeeshops and tried many cupcakes and Starry Night doesn't even compare...it's THAT BAD! Save your money and your time and go to "corporate" Starbucks or Panera. At least you know you'll have quality products for what you pay for! read more

I ordered a 3 tier cake from this bakery for a very special occasion for my grand daughter. Upon arrival the cake just fell over as it was cut from the original box. The owner would not call me until the next day when a public posting was on facebook. Then she took the time to call and was very angry about the posting, not at all concerned about the issues with the cake. I was expecting a good customer service call and that is not what I received. I have been a very loyal customer for 12 years which meant nothing to her -- as she stated "we don't keep records of our customer's purchases" so this meant nothing to her. Quite astonished and very disappointed and will never use them again. Just a kind response would have gone a long way...... read more

Coffee is hot, fresh and tasty! I don't go much for the fancy coffees but they sure can make them all. The hardest decision of the day is trying to decide which delicious treat to have with my coffee. My dad's favorite is the mousse bar - creamy mousse wrapped in the dark chocolate shell... decadent and perfect with black coffee! My go-to is the kona coffee cupcake, i like the espresso sugary glaze. If I'm on the go, then I grab the biscotti, awesome stuff. Fun environment and people too! read more

Everything we've tried here is excellent (love, love, love the sticky bun!) The coffee is also great (a big plus for us) and the service is always wonderful. Coming here has become our weekly treat since moving to Westminster. read more

Ordered a 2 dozen cupcakes for 50 something dollars extremely overpriced. Very boring decor and the frosting was too sweet. Thought I would splurge for a first birthday but safeway would have been better. Not saying bad what cupcake can be bad but soon not worth it. read more

Starry Night Bakery is wonderful! I recently had my bridal shower and one of my girls purchased the cake from this bakery and it was stunning! It was a wedding dress and not only was it beautiful it was absolutely delicious! Everyone was raving about the cake and wanted to know where it came from! I would highly recommend Starry Night Bakery to anyone around the area looking for any cake or cupcakes! To accompany the bridal cake was the adorable bridesmaid cupcakes that looked similar to the bridesmaid dresses! Absolutely amazing!! read more

I picked up a chocolate chip cake with peanut butter filling and chocolate icing for my husbands birthday. We were celebrating with friends at a restaurant well outside of Westminster. The cake was amazing! Our waitress commented on how beautiful and colorful it was. I shared what flavor the cake was and where I purchased it. I offered her a piece later in the evening, thinking she would politely decline. She happily accepted and asked if she could have two! By the time we left the slices of cake were the envy of the rest of the staff! I was very pleased and will be returning next week for another cake! read more