Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta

    4.3 (42 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 2 months ago

    Order Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta Takeout or Delivery

    Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta Pizza Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    SID'S PIZZA - ALPHARETTA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Order take out at the counter
    Lala C.

    Since I stopped by the next door tailor, pizza sounded like a great lunch take out idea! Indoor seating was filled so that was a good sign. Option for NY or thin crust options. Various lunch pizza drink specials as well as by the slice prices. I decided upon the thin crust veggie sans cheese. It was cracker crunchy thin with enough sauce and veggies. Disappointing that no fresh basil available though...kinda takes away from authenticity for me. Convenient and tasty for basic options.

    Buffalo Billabong and The Pipeline

    Delicious local family owned pizza!! Their dough is incredible and their pizza sauce is the best I've ever had. The thin crust or the traditional crust are both worth trying! We love the Buffalo Billabong with ranch and the traditional pepperoni. Their service is always wonderful and their outside seating is great for groups.

    The Wedge with mushroom but no onions .

    Hit this pizza restaurant spot!!! Orders the Wedge and it was full of toppings! Pizza dough cooked and fluffy - ordered crispy and the crust was perfecto!! A splash of oldie surfer decor! Longboard Beer fit right in! Waitstaff all on point! Ample parking right and near town of Alpharetta. For sure we will be back with the gang!!

    This is the owner's idea of extra crispy?  He was the cook the night I was there
    TooHonest F.

    So I've been waiting to try this place since they opened but every time I tried to go, they were either closed or there was nobody inside which is not a good sign. I was hesitant after reading other reviews that said the pizza was undercooked so I asked for mine to be extra crispy based on the reviews that I read, the cashier told me don't worry because the owner is the one that's cook tonight and he wouldn't not ever offer something he was not proud of. Well being this is a franchise I guess this is all I should've expected because that's the picture shows you that's his idea extra crispy? The pizza itself was nothing special. The pepperoni had a little more bite than I would've liked to have had but the worst thing about this place is the dough has absolutely no flavor which means the peach virtually is very bland and despite being offered a frequent visitor card by the cashier. I don't think I will ever be visiting again and I don't recommend that you do either. And what about the Decor you ask? Unless you like retro 1980s that's as bland as the pizza there was no excitement here either.

    the front of a restaurant

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta

    Review Highlights - Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta

    Tried their Haole (White Pizza) and Da Feast - Meat Lovers and both of them were great !

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Crust Pasta & Pizzeria

    Crust Pasta & Pizzeria

    4.1(711 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    This place is so cute and cozy with amazing friendly staff. We usually just slide in and sit at the…read morebar with not much of a wait. I can only speak to lunch as I have not been here for dinner as of yet, but this is becoming a go to spot. They have a great lunch deal for salad and a slice with a drink or two slices and a drink. You can add toppings or choose a specialty pizza slice. I highly recommend the Thai Chicken Pizza. My friend usually gets the Margherita pizza slice. The ceasar salad is also delicious. We will continue to be back and will have to come for dinner one night to try out the wine and other menu items.

    Did not love the ambience or vibe at all. It didn't smell like pizza inside- just like cleaner and…read morecommercial food service. We were seated outside, where we noted cheap wine glasses and plastic Coca Cola cups. I asked our waiter if they had filtered water, and his response was not impressive or professional. "Uhh... I mean, well... I think it just tastes like water... I don't know how they filter the water but it's fine." Dude, it's a yes or no question: 'yes, we have a filter for it,' or 'no ma'am, it comes from the tap.' Throughout the service we could tell he was not being attentive or personable, if we said anything off script he didn't know how to react. We ordered the house salad because of how it was described, but when it arrives, we were shocked at the presentation and quality. We told the server about the disappointment of having only four slices of radish on the salad when it was listed as a main ingredient and he did nothing to remedy that. The chef could also consider mixing all of the ingredients together so it is a harmonious marriage of salad, not just arugula with a sprinkle of pine nuts, drizzle of dressing, FOUR radishes and a handful of pre shredded, from the bag Parmesan. The least you could do is hand grate it. Now to the pizza- they are very large and the crust has nice flavor and a good crunch. The Bianca sauce was very heavy and greasy; tasted like it came out of a jar. That was our least favorite item by far. The bbq chicken was decent, however the Gouda cheese they used had a very cow aftertaste, and there were cubes of the cheese all around, which were rubbery and not good to chew. We couldn't tell if the sharp tang came from the tip of bbq sauce they used or some cleaner leftover on the chicken. It's sad, because Crust came recommended highly to us and we were excited to try it out. Overall, our meal was very disagreeable and we will not be back.

    Photos
    Crust Pasta & Pizzeria
    Crust Pasta & Pizzeria
    Crust Pasta & Pizzeria - Fresh Pressed

    See all

    Fresh Pressed

    Colletta

    Colletta

    4.0(559 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    Literally round of applause to the entire staff, front and back of house!…read more Valet set the tone on arrival. Warm greeting, friendly, incredibly efficient and didn't mind answering my questions at all. (complimentary but we love to tip for great efficient service right guys?) Immediately upon entry i was warmly greeted by Vicky and Destiny. I'd already decided on bar seating and they were more than happy to show me the way to get settled. The bar was a fantastic choice, Avery, Cam and Alex crushed it! From maintaining the flow of the restaurants beverages to their lone bar guest with lots of questions (me lol), they handled everything to perfection while giving stellar recommendations. Their menu knowledge both beverage and bar is impressive. Kudos in that regard for sure. My goodness, i should've gotten the chefs name because every single bite was impeccable. The buratta bruschetta and tagliatelle are unlike any I've had before anywhere else! By the time i was stuffed full i still had leftovers which they graciously boxed for me, i wasn't leaving it at all lol. Kudos to the beverage director as well, the spring cocktails are on the money! I tried the Collette Spritz, Tramanto Sour and Old Corpse reviver. Of the 3, the spritz is surprisingly my favorite. I'm not a beer gal and sometimes don't enjoy Aperol but every ingredient blended well. Try it, trust me, Avery and Cam, those were some of their suggestions! The manager Leo is very kind and personable, i appreciate the brief convo we had. Miss Destiny, You're knocking it out of the park! From the flow of the restaurant, to the ambiance, to staff engagement, to plain ole convo and customer service i have ZERO complaints and overflowing compliments. I wish i had more names because i to drop, Tristan and one other male server that came by the bar were also very kind. I will definitely be making the drive back out! Thank you guys for an incredible Easter Sunday brunch experience. Please never stop being exactly who you are

    Very lovely restaurant. Great staff, great food and good location. Dined here a handful of times…read moreand it was always great! Food is fresh, consistently made great and staff is eager to please. I almost always get meatballs, black pepper tagliatelle, and tiramisu is always good. Ravioli and spaghetti are also to die for!!! Rum old fashioned, White Negroni and Boulevardier are always slam dunk. Manager Destiny runs this place very well...

    Photos
    Colletta - Interior

    Interior

    Colletta - Margarita pizza

    Margarita pizza

    Colletta - Calabrese pizza

    See all

    Calabrese pizza

    Sid's Pizza - Alpharetta - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...