To be clear: I have never ordered from Murray's, but I did order three authentic Indian patch…read moremadras shirts this spring from their associated store, Castaway Nantucket. I love the shirts, but they are extremely oversized. I ordered xl for the first two and one of them is in reality an xxxl, while the other one is in reality a xxl. So, for the third shirt, i ordered a large, and it fits perfectly--and I'm getting the first two taken up at my seamstress. The shirts are all gorgeous, with a very durable, hefty fabric, but quite expensive, like all of Castaway's products. I doubt that the inconsistency in sizing is uniform throughout Castaway clothing, but probably confined to their madras clothing, which is made in Chennai (formerly Madras), India, as I have found wild inconsistency in madras shirts from another retailer. I cannot say that for sure, however, as I have no other items from Castaway. Last note: each of my shirts are long-sleeved, and the fabric is so thick they are too hot to wear on a very hot day.

Island staple…read more Still the best of everything: merchandise, service, prices, and experience. Every time I'm on island, I always visit! I buy small stuff and toss it in my knapsack, and for larger items I have those shipped back home. Murray's also has an order online catalog too. Nothing is more representative of ACK than Murray's! No negatives whatsoever.

My mom and I both found some awesome t-shirts here! Like other reviews mention, its all simiarily…read morepriced to other stores and they have more unique designs. I think this is definitely a great stop.

3 Girls is just like Annie T's with a little less variety but same, relatively classy designs. The…read moreprices are pretty much the same. I feel like there are a few more designs here with some creative differences from other T's you see on the Island.

I really like this gift shop! We have been in a few times during our trip and they have a huge…read moreselection of Nantucket themed items from mugs, jewelry, to books and toys for kids. My son was having a fit about not being allowed to have a squishy a few days ago, and the owner was super sweet. We got the cutest book for him and prices are better than average. Definitely recommend!

My mom and I both found some AWESOME finds here. We stopped…read morein after we got Jack and Charlies. It had everything I wanted and more. I got the most incredible blue turtle neck with stitching that discreetly spelled out NANTUCKET. I love all the souvenirs, but this is so subtle, it's beautiful and great quality. We also got a couple little extras and ornaments and tea towels Seriously of all the gift shops, this was full of gems.

Snobbiest store I've ever been in. The woman refused to serve me and then would not pull items I…read morewanted. I have not idea why she had such an attitude; she was literally openly hostile to me. I've never been treated in such a manner, especially in a clothing store! Avoid. Just avoid.

Great store, not sure what the prior review was all about but I had a wonderful time shopping here…read more Not only do they have wonderful merchandise but I found them to be very friendly and helpful. When on Nantucket, go to Island Cashmere!

Katy has a great shop in the heart of Edgartown! She was…read moresuper friendly and very helpful and has a great selection of custom island clothing and pajamas!

I love this shop. Katydid is a tiny shop on Main Street. They always have a nice selection of…read morelight sun dresses and casual tops for the summer months. Handbags, shawls, etc. That sort of casual summer vibe is abundant here. Dressing rooms are a little wacky, but you can quickly slip things on and off. Staffing is always nice, although they do get busy sometimes, so be patient with them. I bought a pair of pajamas last time I was there.

What a delight this well-run shop is that is staffed solely by on island volunteers. There were so…read moremany treasures to be found there. Unfortunately, I did not see many things in my size but I did manage to pick up a cute blue and white christmas tree as well as a hand knit quilt that I can't wait to use.

I always walk away with something to love. The clothes are lacking, although this last time I…read morewalked away with 2 jackets. Where this spot shines is the home goods - wooden duck decoys, brass candlesticks, baskets... if those old types of things are your jam, this is your spot. They also sell: old books, beach chairs, furniture, limited jewelry, coolers, kitchen items from silverware to coffee makers and everything in between. Overall, a Nantucket gem. PS: I turned my back at the register to try on some earrings and answer a question some ladies had about my dress and some tourist took a broach right out of my pile (it was very clear that it was taken). They were sneaky and not the vibe. Don't be that person.

The Green Room is a great clothing store. We shop here every year while on vacation. The selection…read more& quality are excellent. The store is clean and very organized. The staff are friendly & helpful.The prices are slightly on the higher side.

I don't live on the vineyard anymore so I only get to shop here a few times a year when I'm…read morevisiting family. I came this past weekend and the woman who helped me was incredibly patient, I tried on seven pairs of jeans and she helped me find the perfect pair. Worth it to save up and shop here when I visit! When I buy jeans here I wear them for years.

I've never been to Scrub Oak. I've never even been to Nantucket or Massachusetts for that matter…read more But thanks to a magic machine in my house that connects me to businesses far away, I'm able to order things from all over the world from my desk. When I fell in love with an Ace & Jig dress I saw on Pinterest and needed an XS, I was faced with a very short list of shops that had this item and the possibility that none would have it in my size. Most of these shops didn't have a website, or if they did, there was no e-commerce component to it, so it already seemed like a long shot. I sent Scrub Oak an email inquiring about the dress and to my luck, the owner, Sarah replied letting me know she had it. The whole process was painless and the package was even delivered in a lovely box with a nice note tucked in. I love my dress and have since taken to with me to the Caribbean and Asia. Thanks for going above and beyond, Sarah! Maybe one day I'll make it to Nantucket. I hear it's quite pretty.

What a special store! I walked into this charming place -through the front garden, and was overcome…read moreby the wonderful things that they had in here. Unusual Clothing, handmade jewelry, shoes, funny greeting cards, all displayed well on 2 floors. I was greeted and helped by the owners mother, who couldn't have been more helpful and nice. I'd love to go back and definitely spend more time and money here. Take the time to look around carefully, you'll find lots of intriguing things.