Unsuspectingly delicious!! Pizza is crisp, full of flavors, not too thick, not too thin. House…read moresalad was perfect. And the playlist was legit. Passing through but will remember this spot if I'm ever back out west

Went for lunch, got sat quickly, server was excellent. Food was great. Lots of toppings and they…read morewere fresh!! Look forward to going again.

Excellent service, great flavor, awesome crust and the best: amazing price! We had a 3 toppings…read morecustom large pizza for $9.50! They have a bunch of deals too! We need more businesses like this. Great job!!

Interesting ... Mr Jim's is a takeout pizza place. Didn't see that on the website or in the…read morereviews I scanned. Taking the pizza to our accommodations ... WOW, what a pizza! Had the chicken premier and it's unique (and great tasting) white sauce! The standouts were the veggies (white onions, green peppers, etc.) we're crisp! FIRST TIME EVER FOR THAT! It was incredibly tasty!!! Great pizza and prepped (including baking) in under 15 minutes!!! Perhaps they're not ready for a sit down site and they would need to get a liquor license (pizza without beer? C'mon man...). Perhaps not in Sheridan but this pizza is absolutely legit!!!!!

We are traveling through Sheridan Wyoming on our way to Colorado Springs from Montana…read more We stopped for the night and chose Wyomings Rib and Chop for dinner. From the time we walked in and got seated by the friendly host, to our Amazing server, Lucia, everything was perfect! We ordered a bottle of our Favorite wine to compliment our dinners. My husband had the Filet with garlic mashed potatoes and garlic mushrooms, with a cup of Gumbo soup. I had the Surf and Turf with a salad and baked potato. All was delicious and cooked to perfection! We ended with the Apple cobbler alamode. Delicious dessert as well! I would definitely stop here again during future travels! We also enjoyed the bar ambiance. Great job Rib and Chop crew!

We probably would have enjoyed eating here; however after 20 minutes - no water or silverware, no…read moreservice,acknowledgement, no order etc so we left for Smith Alley where we were served within 5 minutes. Go to Smith Alley!

Always takes WAY to long. I could probably fly to Italy, but a pizza, and fly back, faster than…read moreordering a pizza from this place. You guys suck

Terrible experience. They cancelled both my orders inexplicably. And they took my emergency pizza…read morediscount. First time I ordered at 10:45. Arrived in town at 11:05 only to discover they cancelled my order. Ordered again, was sent through without any prompt that the store was closed. Checked again 5 minutes later and my order was cancelled. Drove to the store and all the signs are off and no one in the store but the lights are on and a car is parked out front. Website says they are open until midnight.

This was an unplanned stop on a roadtrip that ChatGPT recommended and it did not disappoint…read more Rotisserie chicken was delectable, empanadas delicious, kids chicken fingers were even a hit. Service was wonderful. They were busy during the lunch rush and were extremely attentive to every guest, getting tables cleaned and the next guests seated but never rushing anyone and making you feel as if they knew you. We didn't quite know what to expect as it looked like a small hole in the wall, but the small dining room and outside seating quickly became part of its charm. We just left and are already craving the chicken. Good thing we have leftovers in a ToGo box for later. If we're ever in this part of the country again, we'd go out of our way to stop again.

Thigh and leg and rice were good, but like a rotisserie chicken that you can buy at the grocery…read morestore. Tried to finish the taquitos and couldn't. They looked and tasted like they were fried in old burnt oil. Wouldn't go back again

This place was awesome from service to food to the ambiance!!…read more Kate/Katie gave us great service and recommendations despite our late(ish) arrival. We started with the jalapeño poppers with raspberry dipping sauce...very tasty! Then we were able to put toppings of two different signature pizzas onto each half of a single large pizza (of which we will also be enjoying for breakfast!!!) both pizzas were delicious! The dessert calzones were phenomenal as well. Oh, and for the review by the idiot who complained about the slight char on the crust, FYI, that is exactly the way it should come from a wood fired pizza oven! AMAZING!!!

We are driving through, saw the menu on this place and had to give it a try! We had the bacon…read morewrapped jalapeños with the raspberry dipping sauce. They were superb. And we were delighted to find out that you could split a large pizza into two types. Both were absolutely fantastic! Generous portions, we shared the large (two of us) and still had half leftover for breakfast tomorrow! I absolutely love what FIRE pizza, I've had it all over the world, including Italy and they definitely nailed it! We also got the dessert calzones, which were great too, and what a plus that they carry local craft beer on draft! Katie was her server and she was so attentive and kind! We literally walked in 30 minutes before they closed and everybody treated us with great customer service! Bravo, for creating such fun, unique pizzas! And for having great service in atmosphere!