This weekend, I had 2 slices of pie from here (Petee's Pie is what this location is listed as online): a Wild Maine Blueberry Slice and a Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice. Upon delivery, we noticed the slices were a bit smaller than we expected, and the tips were broken off a bit. The pies came at room temperature and so we enjoyed them as is. I enjoyed the sweet filling and crisp pecan crust of the brown honey pecan slice, and my boyfriend appreciated the small, whole blueberries in that slice. We both noted that the pies weren't overly sweet, which we appreciated. While I can't say this is the best pie I've had in the city, the rest of the pie menu looks intriguing and the reviews definitely show a lot of loyal fans, so I'd like to try this place again. read more

Petee's Cafe - Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

So tasty! Authentic and locally sourced this place will have you wanting more. I had the classic apple pie. I'm a huge pie fan and let me tell you this has probably been one of the best pies I've tasted. You won't go wrong here! read more

Petee's Cafe - Inside - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Tried a cappuccino and blueberry pie as I was walking in the neighborhood, and was pleasantly surprised with the winter special pies available as well. The blueberry pie was not too sweet, and the oat milk coffee was perfectly foamed. Would def try more of their pies if I was in the neighborhood!! There's also a few seats in the store, but most people seemed to get takeout. read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Petee's is the best. Every pie I've ever tried here is so good. We were in the neighborhood and decided to have a slice in stores. There's not much seating but it was just me & my partner so we sat in the window and enjoy an amazing slice of pecan pie and cappuccinos. GREAT spot for picking up a treat for Friendsgiving or turkey day. Best pies in the city ?!? read more

Petee's Cafe - Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came here for some pie. The store is small with very little seating. The staff the was friendly. We got a coconut custard pie and a blueberry crumble. The custard pie was okay..too much coconut not enough custard. The blueberry crumble was good. The blueberries was not overly sweet. read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

CUTEST pie shop in Brooklyn! Super lovely and friendly staff, and a large selection of pies by the slice and pie. They also have a very well-priced coffee and tea menu! The interior is tight but well furnished with some counter seating and couch, and generally just a cute ambience. I got the hot national parks tea, which was so fragrant. We also tried a slice of the bananas foster pie and were shocked by how good it was! Thick banana cream, whipped cream, and the most buttery and flaky pie crust I've ever tried. Plan to get a pie here for Friendsgiving! read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

So good everytime. Blueberry crumb is perfect. Banana cream, PERFECT. The ice cream is just fine.

My family has been coming here for years, I picked up the pies this year and placed the order ahead of time. Everything was simple and I love how each pie had photos and descriptions and ingredients. Since it was thanksgiving we got a slot for 9 am but I arrived a few minutes earlier and they helped me. The staff were nice and the service was quick. I am very happy for the lovely experience and the delicious pies! They were a hit again! read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Petee's makes my absolute favorite pies in the city. I've been a long time customer at their Lower East Side location and am so excited they have a spot in Brooklyn. The craving for their pie has struck me in the middle of the work day so often I'm not afraid to say I've spent an unreasonable amount of $ to have just a couple of lone slices delivered to my office for my afternoon pie cravings-- and it's always worth it. I truly have not had a flavor I didn't like, but some standouts include cherry crumb, salty chocolate chess, banana cream and rhubarb. The crust is always crisp, and the fillings are always buttery and not overly sweet. The Manhattan location is just a tiny take-out counter, and the Brooklyn location is only marginally bigger, with a couple of seats at the counter. The pie carries really well and would make a great addition to any Thanksgiving spread. read more

Had a slice of the cherry and apple pie and it was delicious. The staff is very helpful in helping choose a flavor. I sat there with two other friends and talked for a couple hours. There's not much space and i don't believe they have a bathroom. Would definitely go back for some pie. read more

Petee's Cafe - Cherry Crumb Slice - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The Black Almond Bottom Pie is FIRE. Love the other different flavors too. They also have good coffee here to hit the spot, or some milk. Our first time here, and the pies are not very expensive either. Best Cappuchinos ever, and the service is good. I will come back on my next trip. read more

Amazing delicious pies - pecan brown butter- reminds me of my trips to the south definitely worth the calories and kind gent from Brooklyn who chatted with me, very nice. read more

Such a nice treat on Myrtle ave! Had dinner around the area and came by to end the night with pie slices. The banana cream pie was amazing!!! I will def be back. So yummy! Our friends got the chocolate one and it tasted like a chocolate pudding. Nice texture and not too sweet which I like! read more

Petee's Cafe - Banana Cream Slice and Chocolate Slice Cream - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Amazing love the natural sunlight that was giving from the windows. How they allow you to customize your drink to a certain degree,the guy taking the order a little bit dry but the drinks make up definitely try their pastries will definitely visit again. read more

Huge fan of nearly every piece of pie I've had here. You really can't go wrong. The cherry crumb is my favorite, but I've even tried the seasonal flavors I was unfamiliar with and really liked them too. Staff have gotten much better than the team that worked here before the remodel. Everyone seems friendly and they did an excellent job for the thanksgiving pickup this year. If I could make one request... PLEASE BRING BACK THE BREAKFAST SANDWICH!! That biscuit, sausage, pepper jelly combo is the stuff dreams are made of. I guess my health thanks you, but nothing can fill the hole that was left in my heart when you decided to scrap breakfast altogether post-remodel. read more

Firstly the staff here was so kind and welcoming. They recommended I get the Salty Chocolate Chess Slice because it's one of their best sellers and because I said I wasn't looking for a fruit pie. It tasted exactly like they described: a salted brownie in pie form. The only thing I was disappointed about was the at $8 I was surprised to see how small the slice was, but it's probably a good thing because it's pretty indulgent. read more

Petee's Cafe - Salty Chocolate Chess Slice - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

4.5 stars 2-3 tables inside for those who want to eat in Our favorites were the banana cream, key lime Apple pie was OK. Would hands-down go back and try other flavors. A tad on the pricey side, but for the quality it's worth it read more

Pies are amazing! Ive had the Apple Pie and the Almond Chess Pie. Neither were "sweet", the Apple was more tart and the Chess Pie was a good balance of sugar. My suggestion is to open earlier!!! read more

Guys! I'm obsessed with this spot!!! It's honestly kinda wild how much I've come here since visiting the city. It's a small spot with very limited seats. The folks working there were super nice. I REALLLYY REALLLYYYY LOVEEEEEEE their pie!! And the tea is quality tea (I'm a tea snob). They also have tons of other desserts and pastries. I don't t drink coffee but they also have coffee drinks. read more

See all

Petee's Cafe is the larger Brooklyn outpost of Petee's Pie. In addition to whole pies and pies by the slice, they have cookies and other treats. Recently, I've tried the Jersey peach pie, Strawberry rhubarb, NY Sour Cherry, Salty Chocolate Chess and Key lime pie. The key lime in particular was amazing - definitely will be getting that again! read more

See all

Divine, divine pie! I don't know how they do it. I'm not even sure I'd consider myself a "pie person," but Petee's pies would make me a convert. It's probably a good thing I don't live closer... The crust is out of this world. It just melts in your mouth. There are lots of tasty options to try. I would eat any of the ones I had again. My favorite is probably the black bottom almond chess, which also seems to have captured the hearts of many other Yelpers. Anything fruit is also good; plus, it makes you feel like you're eating a little healthier, right? Their set-up for COVID-19 is very sound. They have lots of notices saying only individuals or very small parties are allowed in at one time. The menu is posted outside, too, so you can figure out what you want before entering. (There's also a menu inside, of course.) And there's plexiglass above the counter where you order. It's always a great time to treat yo'self. You can't go wrong here! read more

Petee's Cafe - Menu hanging outside - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Update to say that while their pecan pie is the best pie you'll ever have in nyc (at least for me there the case) the banana cream and the coconut cream are not the best, they're runny so the crust gets soggy and tasted like overly sweet whipped cream. The staff was much nicer this time but the pies didn't live up to the hype (only the pecan does) read more

Petee's Cafe - Display - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

You can't go wrong here. Our favs are banana cream and brown butter pecan. You can't go wrong.

How is it possible that the wild Maine blueberry crumb pie got even better the next day? I just don't understand how this sort of magic exists. I love Petee's because they don't overcompensate with too much sugar. It's all about the perfect flake and crumb texture. The freshness of the ingredients they use is apparent. I really had trouble keeping my serving size to one slice. Thanks for reminding me how summer should taste. read more

Love coming here. Very Parisian vibe with an outdoor patio. Their pies are really good and staff is very friendly and welcoming. Great place to work as well. Love the pink exposed brink. read more

Petee's Cafe - Iced matcha latte and brown butter pecan pie - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If heaven existed on earth in the form of a world of pies it would be Petee's. It is hands down the best apple pie I have ever had right next to my grandmas. The crust is beyond flaky and the apples have perfect texture. Any pie you order, you will not go wrong. The banana cream pie is a home run! For vegans they offer a sour cherry pie which is really good as well. The interior has a chill vibe, and the staff is awesome, and helpful. Right down to the cute golden forks, this place will bring happiness to your soul. The second you walk in, and smell the overwhelming smell of PIE you will know exactly why this place is AWESOME! Cash and credit accepted ! Get the apple pie you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

I was promised freshly baked pies. We arrived at 11AM (when the google page says they open) to a sign saying they have a slow opening and open at 11:30AM. When we went in, I got a plastic container with a day old pie in it and a lousy cappuccino. If i wanted old pie in plastic id go to the supermarket. The cashier told another customer that she just put the pies in... Are we to wait until 1PM two hours after opening to get fresh pies. Sorry just disappointed, the pictures informed me of something else. read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I can't even handle how darling Petees Pie Cafe is. Definitely the cutest spot in the neighborhood. The pink walls are so dreamy. And the plants - litteraly everywhere - makes it feel homey. The marble counter, the milk glassware and the pies all on display make it feel like I'm in a sitcom grandma's kitchen. And I love it. Not to mention the pies are DELICIOUS. Favorites include the chocolate (if you love chocolate you NEED to try this pie) And the apple. Their pear is yummy too. The crust is buttery and flaky. And if you can afford the extra charge -- add their maple whip to your slice. So creamy and so perfect up top any slice. Slices are generous in size, and could be shared if necessary. But really, you're going to want your own slice. And you're going to want to hang out for a bit... gosh, this place is so cute and just so good. read more

See all

I'm not a pie person, I've never really been one however Petee's transformed me into one. I was actually gifted some pies from here and I was shocked when I tried them, please be sure to take their ice cream along with your pies as they seem to have been manufactured to compliment them. Pumpkin Pie: scrumptious in flavor and perfect balance of soft and flavorful. Pear Streusel: my number one fav, very crunchy on top and pear is carefully layered as to not be overwhelming Vanilla Bean Ice Cream: very tasty and will compliment any pie you buy, its actually also tasty and very fresh The pies are in my opinion one of the best that NYC has to offer. It's on my list to try every single one of their flavors and will update once I have. read more

Petee's Cafe - Pear Streusel Slice + Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (4oz) - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered online a month ago: 1 banana cream pie slice and some vanilla bean with honey pecan pie ice cream. Both were really good. Savored the Ice cream over a few days, it was so good, surprisingly creamy and rich yet somehow light and not too heavy. Order was quick despite the late time. read more

Petee's Cafe - Banana cream pie, vanilla honey pecan pie - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've loved Petee's Pies for years. Her pies are about as good as pies get, so I could barely contain my excitement when: 1. They opened up in Brooklyn. 2. I got to meet Petee. I was a little blinded by her celebrity; I'm sure she gets a little annoyed by the paparazzi constantly following her everywhere, and superfans like myself bugging her when we catch her in front of her new cafe here (a very cute spot that will be getting alcohol eventually, and has an adorable backyard). But I couldn't help it. I had to tell Petee all about how we're pie people. How I get her pies for birthdays and parties. How we had pie at our wedding, because fuck cake. And she said, "Team Pie!" You're goddamn right, Petee. I'm on Team Pie, and you're our captain. O Captain, My captain, I want to jump up on a desk like Robin Williams and tell you that I love the wild blueberry, the sour cherry, and the strawberry rhubarb (your manager Morgan's favorite, evidently, and he has good taste). The banana cream pie will make my wife love me again when I've done something stupid, and everyone seems to love the salty chocolate chess, even though chocolate desserts are not as good as fruity desserts. Basically, it doesn't matter what pie you get from Petee, because it's always going to be such great pie. Team Pie. read more

See all

3.5/5 stars! I've always wanted to try Petees Pie Company and luckily I stumbled into their Brooklyn location on Myrtle Ave. The shop is charming and they have a wide selection of pies. Since it was strawberry season, I decided to get the strawberry rhubarb pie. The slice was fairly small, tart and didn't not have enough dough/crust as I would've like. Regardless, the pie was still good. But I wish I got a different flavor like whipped banana or blueberry crumble! read more

Petee's Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

LOVE LOVE LOVE Petee's! So damn good! The service is always great. The place is super cute and the pie is exceptional. And I get discounts on my birthday because it's also pi(e) day.. so there's that :) I haven't had their savory options, but they look delish. One day I'll try.. hopefully soon too! read more

I've been to Petee's cafe two times now. My first trip was a bit by chance. It's funny, I was having dinner right next door with a very dear friend. We had just cleared our bill and stated to make our way to the car to go home. All of my friends know that I have a crazy sweet tooth. It's so bad that I can't hardly have dinner without something sweet to cap the night. So, no sooner then me walking out the restaurant that I said to my friend, all I need is something sweet and boom!!! Hello, Petee's cafe. A window bedazzled with pies!! How could I possibly take another step. If you don't know by now, we went right in and I got two slices to go. The staff here is amazing and they have so many pies to choose from. My favorite so far is their Brown Butter Pecan Pie. They have like 20+ pies for you to get your ever loving life. The pies are made on premises. You can't go wrong with that and you know your getting something fresh. You can taste the freshness with every bite. So, do yourself a favor and pie out. read more

Petee's Cafe - The hostess with the mosttess! - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The staff is very friendly. The cafe is clean, pretty, and would be enjoyable if you're going to go for coffee/tea. All of that is good and well, but I found the pies to be quite mid. The Hudson valley apple slice has a strange aftertaste in the crust, and the key lime merengue was too sweet. People have difference pie preferences; this might still be the place for you! I'll update after giving some other flavors a chance. read more

LOOOOVED the pie!!!! What a great place. So many great choices. Pies tasted fresh like a loving grandma made it just for me... The vanilla ice cream delish! Super creamy and great flavor. Went perfect with our pies. The crust on pie is buttery and well cooked...flaky crust just made me very happy. We are definately ordering again...probably eat our way through menu lol read more

Petee's Cafe - Apple Crumb Slice - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I would give Petee's Pie 5-stars, if it were not for issues with the fulfillment with the order. I had ordered an apple crumb pie to be delivered. The pie was promptly delivered on schedule, but unfortunately the wrong flavor (cherry) pie was delivered. I contacted Petee's to let them know there was a mistake with the order. After couple texts and photos sent of the mistaken pie, they quickly offered a refund or a replacement. We opted for a replacement, which was quickly delivered within the hour. I am very pleased with the prompt response and courteous customer service. They quickly rectified the situation and my daughter got to enjoy their delicious apple crumb pie for her birthday. read more

This spot is a nice quiet work place with great music and diverse staff...that damn sour cherry pie is heaven on your tongue. The prices are KIND OF expensive but shit, the quality A1. I live right across the street...I come here frequently. All of the pies that I've had are great. Lastly, I wish more black folks attended this spot Have a good one read more

See all

Pie is good! Space is really small so there's not enough room to enjoy a coffee/slice but otherwise good vibes.

I fell in love with Petee's Pies awhile ago and leaned about Petee's Cafe just yesterday. A friend and I were looking for a sweet treat and decided to swing by Petee's in Brooklyn for a slice. It's so cute inside with a cozy feel. Music was playing as slices were served up. Small tables to sit 2-4 people were lined up against the wall and there was a backyard seating area that was nice as well. I ordered at the counter and was told the pie would come over to me. It came served on an actual dish with real utensils. I'm glad they're doing their part to save the earth. I went with the cherry slice, a scoop of vanilla and whipped cream. It cost a little less than 10 dollars but I was pleased once again. The crust was light brown, buttery and flaky. The cherries were tart and a bit sweet. Just perfect with the ice cream and whipped cream. The slice is a decent size. I'm sure I could have squeezed in one more slice but I controlled myself. I will definitely be back for another delicious visit. Next time I may have a drink with my dessert. Cocktails, wine and beer are also available for purchase. read more

Petee's Cafe - Sour Cherry Pie, vanilla ice cream and whipped cream - Cafes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all