Cancel

Open app

Search

Penny Farthing Inn

4.6 (55 reviews)
Closed Closed

Penny Farthing Inn Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Penny Farthing Inn

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Greg E.

This is a very nice Inn, located in one of my favorite cities. A Victorian style built in the late 1800s, the Inn is nicely decorated. The inside dining area is small, holding about 5 two tops. Additional dining is available on the main, outside patio. The Inn offers a wine and cheese service from 4-5 pm daily. We did not take advantage of this offer, but I am sure that it is very nice. The rooms are situated inside the main building and in a small building or two adjacent to the main patio. I believe that all rooms have a balcony. We stayed in Catherine's Bedchamber, which is located on the second floor in the main building and was very nice. It offers a king size bed and a jacuzzi tub-shower. The room is pretty small, but comfortable enough. Our patio was large and offered a swing, a comfortable chair, as well as a small table and two chairs. However, it is not completely private as guests in the suite above pass through taking the stairs to their room. Also, the patio for the guests room adjacent to ours was situated outside our suite windows. Even respectful guests, holding relatively quiet conversations can be heard from our bed. For this reason, I would prefer to stay in a different room. The toiletries were sparse, which is rare for most Inns and B&Bs. The complimentary breakfast was very good. (French Toast one morning and Eggs Benedict the other). There appeared to be no fresh decaf coffee available, which is a little surprising given Inns tend to attract older patrons, many of whom are supposed to avoid caffeine. Service was mixed. Richard (the owner/manager) is awesome. He is friendly, personable and attentive. He makes his guests feel appreciated and right at home. The young woman who handed breakfast service was also excellent. However, our chamber service was not up to par, especially for an Inn that generally sets a high standard for itself. After our room was serviced we noticed that the glasses that we used to drink some wine were left untouched and remained dirty. Also, the tiny shampoo bottles that we used were not replaced. Basically, the room service amounted to making the bed. None of the shortfalls that we noted were significant and I certainly would recommend the Inn. However, with some attention to details and with some enhancements, the Inn would easily qualify for a 5 star rating.

Beth E.

I love B&B's, and this is close to that, but on a larger scale. My husband had surprised me with a trip to St. Augustine and chose this Inn for its quaintness, the fact that the rooms had outside seating, and it's close proximity to all the wonderful places we would visit. We were greeted by Richard who explained the aspects of the Inn, and showed us to our room, The Catherine. We had a king size bed, a settee, a small TV, and a whirlpool bath. The room was comfortable and cozy. Our outside area had a small table and chairs, a swing and another chair. The location of the Inn is perfect. We walked everywhere and felt perfectly comfortable and safe. Breakfast both days we were there was good. French toast one day and eggs Benedict another. If I had one thing to change, it would be the fact that the room next to us had their outside seating area on the wall that was next to our bed, which had 2 windows. When we were in our room, we could hear everything they said, and trying to take a late afternoon nap was impossible due to the noise. Perhaps a different room would be a better choice. I wasn't overly impressed with housekeeping. When our room was cleaned, they didn't remove the dirty glasses, or supply us with any more shampoo. They initially had nothing but shampoo, which seemed a little odd when most places provide body wash, hand cream, etc. Most aspects were perfect, and with a few tweaks, this would be a 5 star.

Super cute lobby
Annie B.

My boyfriend and I recently visited St. Augustine and loved staying at the Penny Farthing. We arrived in town early and they were gracious enough to let us park our car in the lot even if the room wouldn't be ready for another few hours. When we did check in we were shown to our room and given the key. The property kind of feels like a treehouse! It's adorable. It was cold and rainy when we were there but the outside porch looked like a great place for breakfast. Inside our room we found brandy waiting which was a nice touch. Our room was tiny but it had a kitchen and a TV. If you are a larger person, beware. My boyfriend is 6'2 and he hit his tow getting into bed because his side of the bed was close to the wall. The bathroom was also small. They had a wine and cheese happy hour at 4 or 4:30, which was a good snack. Breakfast the next day was the star of the show! We were served ham, egg and cheese sandwiches, fruit and coffee. My one complaint was the bed in our room. For some reason when we got in it was slippery, could've been the material of the sheets, but neither of us slept well that night. Other than that I would recommend this place for your trip to St. Augustine. It's a perfect location; we really enjoyed being able to make trips back and forth from the tourist areas to the inn.

Bedroom- Elizabeth?
Amanda M.

Ok this is the most haunted place in st Augustine lol. We made many mistakes and it's our fault that we summoned up some kind of conjuring situation but really nice stay otherwise! Lmao. My boyfriend at the time gifted me 2 nights Over the summer in this beautiful bed and breakfast for my birthday. We changed the date due to a work event and Richard was kind enough to accommodate. However... we changed rooms due to the date switch. I wish I remembered the name of the room but maybe it's Elizabeth? In any event beautiful place, Richard Is very nice, but make no mistake if you stay in this room on a full moon and hang out in the sitting room at midnight you will experience some paranormal stuff. We mentioned to Richard we were considering doing a ghost tour and he said don't bother just sit in the sitting room at night . I didn't really believe in any of this until it happened and I was scared to death until it stopped happening abruptly at 5am the day of our departure. Pros: really adorable bed and breakfast, great management, comfortable rooms. Walking distance to everything! Cons: maybe a con maybe not lol very very haunted.

Exterior
Angel L.

What a great find in Saint Augustine! My son & I truly loved this Inn. It was the first stop on our "haunted inn" adventures:) While we didn't see any ghosts;) We did thoroughly enjoy our stay in the Katherine Room! You can tell the man who owns this Inn, and runs it exclusively on his own, has really put his heart and soul into his work. My son really loved our eggs Benedict breakfast made by him. He was very hospitable, and accommodated our later check-in. I had forgotten my glasses there, and a few days later, he was very kind about me stopping by to get them at 8:00 pm, when the front desk had already closed. I definitely recommend Penny Farthing Inn to anyone who stays in this area:)

Cutest place ever
Cheresa G.

We had a girls trip to St Augustine and chose Penny Farthing B&B for our stay. We loved our room in the Attic. It was so adorable and came complete with a little boy ghost that I called Tommy . Michelle was so sweet and informative. She talked with us about the Inn and about St Augustine and all it's charms. We were treated to a gourmet breakfast each morning, a bottle of Champagne and Happy Hour each each evening. Highly recommended

Teresa M.

Location was good as we were able to walk to old town St. Augustine. Parking spaces are shallow so extra large SUVs or extended bed pickups will not fit. Bed was comfortable. Breakfast was good. We'd stay there again.

Jodie M.

Located on Cedar street amongst a row of 4 B&Bs, is The Penny Farthing Inn. The property is beautiful, well decorated, very quiet ( and not every property in St. Augustine is quiet...), great hospitality and ample parking. The room was clean, and we enjoyed the breakfasts. The staff will accommodate dietary needs. The location can't be beat. The Ice Plant (great food) and Distillery (gotta do the free tour!) is a 6 minute walk west. St. George's Street is another 6 min walk north. I've been to St. Augustine a million times, and wish I'd found this gem sooner. Lovely get away with my husband.

Meal or general seating area.
Alexis H.

Stayed here last night & loved it! We were warmly greeted by David and offered a glass of wine. We stayed in the Buckingham room, which was decorated with nice accents and quite cozy. We enjoyed a touch of sherry there. Room was very clean. He suggested some great sights and eats for us. We had dinner at Preserved, his suggestion and only a short walk, which I highly recommend. Then, this morning he & his daughters made a lovely eggs Benedict & fruit breakfast for us. My only minor frustration (and it's small) was that our room was hot when we went to sleep, but it cooled off throughout the night. Our stay was quick but lovely. I hope I have a chance to return!

Jonathan M.

A quaint bed and breakfast walking distance from everything in historic St Augustine, the Penny Farthing Inn is a delightful choice for short stays in town. The owners/managers are friendly and got us situated in the Catherine Room upon arrival. It's a king sized bed with a large jet tub in the bathroom. The tub didn't seem quite fully cleaned upon arrival and there was a slight layer of dust in the bedroom in certain areas. Nothing off putting, but noticeable. Breakfast is served 8:30-9:30. The two breakfasts we enjoyed were eggs Benedict and sausage and bread pudding. Both were well portioned meals, just the right amount to get fueled for your day's schedule. There is wifi, cable, and a small assortment of DVDs to choose from for in room entertainment. The bed sheets were incredibly soft and from Costco, so my wife and I have a shopping trip to make soon. Overall, I enjoyed my short visit to the Penny Farthing Inn and I would stay again.

Bathroom ceiling
Natasha B.

The place is so charming and romantic. Each room is supplied with some nice English sherry, and if that is now enough, you can go downstairs for a cup of tea, a glass of whine,or port. The owner is incredibly sweet. I felt like I was visiting England, really. The location is very good, right in the old town area. Breakfast is incredibly delightful..The bathroom had a jacuzzi and was very spacious, huge pillow-drowned bed...and some nice DVDs to watch. Check out my pics. of the rooms...We stayed at "The Dawn".

Sausage Quiche with Potatoes and Fresh Fruit

See all

Photo of G W.
2
41
6

16 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mike M.
18
14
3

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Nelson N.
48
11
10

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of C T.
0
5
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

17 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Penny Farthing Inn

Review Highlights - Penny Farthing Inn

Augustine within walking distance of restaurants, shops, bars, Flagler College, The Lightner Museum and so much more.

Mentioned in 7 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hotels 1,768 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Bayfront Westcott House Bed and Breakfast - Schooner in the bay

Bayfront Westcott House Bed and Breakfast

(62 reviews)

We just got here about an hour ago. First thing I wanted was a hot bath. Water was barely tepid but…read morestaff was able to take care of it and get us hot water. We stayed here for our 40th anniversary. Lovely property, room, comfy bed and great staff. Across the street from the bay you have sailboats and schooners . Great views from the Verandas. We ordered the breakfast in bed with mimosas which didn't disappoint. I had a huge piece of French toast with blueberry compote, ham, cappuccino. We're already planning our next visit.

We stayed here two nights on our way to our final destination. It was a great location being right…read moreacross the street from the water and a couple of blocks off the main drag to provide less traffic and noise. Our room was spacious with a nice king sized bed. Shower had room for two. We also had a bench on the deck outside of our room. I sat there and read the paper. I loved discovering a cat curled up there on our last day who was friendly and enjoying the morning sun. Breakfast was delicious with an egg bake and waffle our two days. With fresh fruit, bread board, juice, and coffee, there was more than enough to eat. They also hosted a social for the guests but the timing didn't work out for us to attend. It was quite the spread when we peaked in one night. We really enjoyed eating our breakfast outside on the large porch. The first day it was raining but we were covered so not an issue. The second day it was sunny and clear. Beautiful views of the water. The staff was fantastic and took care of all of our needs. Great stay!

Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast - Ruby room

Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast

(141 reviews)

I found our spot to stay in St. Augustine, forever…read more A gorgeous bed and breakfast, walking distance to the Spanish Quarter, close to bars and restaurants, close to the fort and the intercoastal; it is the bee's knees that allows us to live our best life in leisure without spending too much, so that we feel we would need to do additional favors on the side courtesy of Marriott or Hilton. We came here to see a concert at the AMP outside of town. Being that the rates at nearby hotels were more than I was willing to spend, I looked at local B&B's, and this one fit the bill between it's local and downhome aesthetic, breakfast being included with gluten-free options for my wife, and a relaxing bathtub for my wife to soak and relax. Eva was fantastic in ensuring we had everything we needed. She is an absolute gem who made us feel at home and welcome. She helped us with some concerns and requests. With a house that has been in existence since 1853, as indicated by the plaque by the front door, this has the historical aesthetic and the comfort to match. The lobby area has some lovely velvet sofas shared with the dining area, where you can have either white or red wine or water, for example. The porch is also nice for a glass of wine, people-watching, and enjoying life as it passes by. Food-wise, they served breakfast if you're able to get to the lobby before 9:45 PM. Technically, the kitchen is open till 10 AM, but don't push your luck. But it's nice to have some coffee and breakfast, whether it's eggs and French toast soufflé or whatever is on the menu, and then you're off for your day. If you are gluten-free, make sure you mention it in advance so they can accommodate you. Our room was lovely, with a comfortable four-poster king-sized bed, a classy dresser, and nightstands. No closet, but there are knobs for hanging up shirts, pants, and dresses if you have clothes hangers. I liked the complimentary dark chocolate when we arrived as well. The room we had for our stay had a hot tub and a shower with multiple showerheads. Once you figure out how to use both, it is heaven. It allowed us to live our best lives. My wife enjoyed the tub immensely, then, after the fact, enjoyed the bathrobe. I liked that the toilet was in a separate room from the sink and shower/hot tub, especially, if you need to go and it goes sideways. The outdoor patio is also nice if you want an afternoon drink, fenced off from the street, especially if you want to smoke a cigar. We have already booked for a concert we are attending in July. And that date will not be the last time we book at the B&B. It is grand.

After much thought, I would give Carriage Way Inn four stars. Carriage Way Inn does some things…read moreextremely well, some well, and some okay. I did learn this business was recently purchased by a company that owns numerous B&B's up the eastern states; hopefully that won't detract in the future. Upon arrival, a huge benefit is a dedicated parking area around back. Unless you drive a very large truck or largest SUV (e.g. a Suburban or F250) you'll have a spot. You should park and leave your vehicle. Saint Augustine is very walkable and Uber/Lyft are readily available, if necessary. Make no mistake; parking is premium in this town so a dedicated parking lot is a big plus. We arrived a little early but were greeted very warmly. Like most old B&B's, there is no elevator or lift (which we were aware of and is no problem for us). We were shown our room (Tourmaline) on the second floor and all typical questions were answered. The room, bed and bathroom were very comfortable. Great adjustable AC (a must in Florida), small flat screen tv (which we never turned on and neither should you), bathroom with very good shower and pleasant toiletries, comfy bed and good blinds to pull down for sleeping. A big negative to the room is the soundproofing. This room (Tourmaline) is right on the front of the house and it was the last weekend of a motorcycle gathering in not too far off Daytona. So we heard mid life crisis motorcycle riders and nearing elderlies on their horridly loud motorcycles off and on all weekend; both out and about and driving by the B&B. Not much the B&B can do except more soundproofing of the windows. It wasn't just the motorcycles, noise from loud car radios occasionally, too. The noise didn't ruin the weekend but did detract. I brought a white noise machine to help with sleeping and recommend it. The location of the B&B is phenomenal; centrally located and you can walk almost everywhere in downtown Saint Augustine. Importantly, we felt totally safe the entire time we visited. Saint Augustine is a very safe city; especially the tourist, populated and Flagler College areas. The B&B generously offers plenty of beverages downstairs to help yourself to. Water and cans of soda are available at all times. Wine, red and white, is set out to serve yourself in the late afternoon through mid evening. I believe I recall beer and hard seltzer, too. The snacks put out at happy hour were meh; just okay. But there were some deliciously scented fresh baked cookies in the afternoon. However, I've had much, much better snacks and happy hours at B&B's in Savannah, north Georgia and Charleston. The first floor sitting area is comfortable; plenty of small tables for sitting for snacks and breakfast; we never felt cramped. Minor glitch; the downstairs ice machine adjacent to the soda and water was broken most of the weekend. The Staff was apologetic and ice was set out and or provided by the downstairs Staff; but this was a minor annoyance. Of note, the rooms do not have little refrigerators. A nice addition might be an ice machine on the second floor (especially since that's where most of the rooms are located. Okay, now let's talk about the breakfast...We only ate it one morning, of two, because it was straight up lousy. Please know I am in no way a picky eater. The entree eggs were not good and I suspect they were most definitely not fresh cracked but powdered, frozen or premade. The plated side ham was barely eatable; it was extremely tough and salty. A B&B breakfast should be very good, if not memorable. This breakfast was shockingly subpar. Well, the coffee I made in the Keurig was fine and the server lady was pretty nice... In sum, I'm not sure I would stay at Carriage Way Inn again. Our stay was not bad but there are so, so many B&B's in Saint Augustine. Perhaps if Carriage Way radically upgrades the quality of the breakfast offering and sound proofs the rooms we'd return.

St. Francis Inn

St. Francis Inn

(75 reviews)

Very cute inn in the absolute best location. It's on the right side of town surrounded by old…read moreVictorian houses and a very quick walk to town. The food is superb. Fresh baked goods during the day (the pumpkin snickerdoodle cookies in the fall were soooo good). Homemade dessert at night. Real sangria with brandy in the evenings on the weekend. Classic decanters in the room for reception to fill with sherry. Breakfast comes with mimosas and bloody Mary's on the weekends. Elle was a gem at the front desk. The whole team really puts in the effort to make the entire experience come together.

Amazing BnB inSt Augustine FL. The staff are so friendly and helpful and the breakfast…read moreunbelievable. They served the best biscuits and gravy (second only to my own and my daughters's) on the first morning and incredible French toast, more like a bread pudding on the next morning. I was so surprised by the amount and taste of the food. Pastries, toast, fruit, yogurt, real orange juice, soft drinks, wine (at social hour), cappuccino, several selections of other coffees, bacon, sausage, and so much more. The rooms and beds were comfortable. The pictures were of the small bathroom, comfy bedroom, outside courtyard with fountain, and the breakfasts. So many small home touches, for example between 7-9 PM they served home made desserts. Parking in town is a big plus!!! Not only easy, but everything is within walking distance even in the heat of summer. What a lovely place. I almost forgot the pool to cool off in. Five stars.!!.

Bayfront Marin House - A romantic king-sized poster bed in our downtown bed and breakfast.

Bayfront Marin House

(110 reviews)

$$$

We stayed in the Lookout Suite while we were in town eloping. We had the most wonderful time. The…read moreview from the room is amazing, and the walk straight down from the cottage to the ocean is so nice. The only thing to watch out for is, as nice as that giant bathtub is, you sometimes run out of hot water before the tub is full (this was for us, when we stayed there in early February. Probably not a problem if you're there in the warmer months). All in all, a cute room, a beautiful view, and a great beach to get married on!

Imagine that... singing and being joyful. Some people simply cannot stand to see others having…read moreharmless fun. THIS PLACE IS HORRIBLE.... I used "reservationdesk.com" (Expedia-?) to make this reservation. The agent PROMISED that we would be on a second floor with a BAYFRONT VIEW. When we arrived at the MARIN HOUSE B&B, there was no waterfront view at all, and we were on the first floor, crammed into a little corner on the property. At check-in, we were basically told that, it's your problem because we used a third-party ("reservationdesk.com"). FINALLY, a week later, we finally got our receipt. Marin House said that they could not even give us a receipt because we went through a third-party. So, one week later, I see that we were charged for three nights, even though we checked out after the first night. ReservationDesk.com said that they contacted Marin House, who told them that since we checked out after the first night, it was against their B&B POLICY, and they are refusing to refund FOR THE TWO NIGHTS THAT WE WERE NOT EVEN THERE!!!!! EVEN THOUGH WE WERE LIED TO ABOUT THE ROOM. Sandy, the owner, got her britches into a big bunch because we were singing, and our choice of language apparently offended the geriatric crowd there.... SO, FOR ONE NIGHT, SANDY @ MARIN HOUSE IS CHARGING US OVER $1,500.00‼‼‼. THIEVES. THIEVES. THIEVES. STAY AWAY FROM THESE THIEVES.

Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

(342 reviews)

$$$

Initial Reaction: My mom had initially stayed at the Casa Monica a while back. I had remembered…read morethis hotel was in downtown Saint Augustine, across from Flagler College, when we were going to spend the night in town. I'm glad we did, as we had a lovely night. The room was nice and spacious, with odd closets, but they worked for the time we were spending there. They also had robes if we needed to be bougie and prance around. We slept well and had a nice view of the square between the Lightner Mansion and Flagler College. The staff at the front desk were very friendly and accommodating. They gave good recommendations on how to get around Saint Augustine, which had been a minute for me, so it was good to get a refresher. Sparkling wine at the front desk when we checked in was excellent and helped us unwind after the drive from South Florida. They have a gym and pool that I believe is accessible through the second floor, so I will have to remember that for our return trip. Also, they have a Starbucks on the lobby floor, which was great to get our morning pick-me-up. The bar and restaurant were very stylish, lots of Spanish influence from the 15th and 16th centuries. The cocktails were also solid. I didn't care for the water pressure and temperature, as they were difficult to adjust and ensure we were getting the correct settings. It was pretty scalding hot, so it took a couple of minutes to get it right, and then I kept it on the setting for my wife since I didn't want her struggling to mess with it. Apart from that, the experience was great. We enjoyed the sparkling wine and the accommodations when we checked in. The valet was good to have, as I didn't want to mess with street parking, but it is more expensive; take note.

The restaurant was sub par. For such an upscale hotel, the food does not fit the bill. I ordered…read morethe meatballs and shrimp for an appetizer. The meatballs were stone cold and bland. The shrimp looked pale and completely unappetizing. I didn't even try them! For dinner my daughter ordered the mussels and they were cold. I ordered the Ahi tuna. The waiter told me they were sliced. They weren't slices, they were shreds of tuna. No taste whatsoever. As a travel editor I rate this restaurant with a 1.

Penny Farthing Inn - hotels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...