Not really good pizza. Salty. Crust overworked or not proofed properly. It was dry and lacked the taste quality semolina flour. The mozzarella was not stringy so not quality brand. The pie was loaded with overcooked pecorino cheese which leaves an aftertaste. The sauce was good so perhaps try a pasta dish. read more

Pizza here was excellent and it was very nice inside even though we didn't stay. I'd definitely come back for more read more

OTTO - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburyport, Massachusetts

You sent me a link that doesn't work, (did you do that on purpose?) - I gave it a few days to see if it would work but still nothing (another scam?) read more

Food is great! Got takeout but the store was cute and would definitely eat in in the future. Friendly service. Love the Butternut Squash, Ricotta & Cranberry pizza. read more

Listen, I like this place and the pizza is really good but they definitely have problems. Its very expensive for pizza that is both thin and small. They also have a very consistent issue of taking forever to make pizza. To pick up two pizzas, it said the order was ready to pick up at 6:44pm. We get there ten minutes late, go in, and told the pizza is going to take 15 more minutes. It literally said the pizza was ready and instead they gave it to us about 20 minutes after. Fix how you do your pick up, it's embarrassing and weird. read more

Really interesting and niche pizzas available, worth it to try once at least! Pretty delicious stuff!

Delivery for a semi special occasion. They don't miss at OTTO! These pies are to die for. They're going, going, gone. Artichoke hearts! So perfect with an extra little pile of them in the center. Cup and char pepperoni; not one dribble of the delicious nectar in those cups spilled. Divine! And the basic cheese pizza for the kiddos. Nothing basic about it. The only pie around they'll eat the crust too! It's fresh. Not crunchy in a bad way. It's just so good. Every location. Every time. I am pushing for Fall...the only squash pie l like is yours! Bravo again OTTO. Still as good as the first slice l had in Portland many years ago. In the beginning... read more

I have never written a negative review before, even when it was warranted, but this experience was so disappointing I actually have to. It was my first time ordering Otto, my partner is gluten and dairy free, and we had been told it was the best pizza around for these types of food accommodations. I dropped $50 for 2 pizzas- 1 small GF with vegan cheese for my partner, and 1 large pepperoni for the rest of the group. It cost a little over $50 with tip, which is insanely expensive compared to other pizza in Newburyport, but I figured it would be worth it if the GF/DF meals were really as good as we heard. Well I can tell you that was not the case. The pepperoni pizza was definitely undercooked, which made the slices flop down so much that the cheese and pepperoni would slide right off. It wasn't even warm when we picked it up right on time, so it did not slide off because of heat. Even when we tried to reheat slices in both the oven and the air fryer to try to make the crust not doughy, it still did not improve. While the unreasonable price and the disappointing pepperoni were enough to make me not choose this pizza again, it is not enough by my standards to write a negative review. However, this part of our experience is what caused the negative review. My partner ate a lot of the GF/DF pizza and said it was decent, which was a positive. But it wasn't decent later that night when he was doubled over for HOURS with extreme stomach pain and all the symptoms of food poisoning which kept him up through the night. He has continued to have less severe, but still lasting effects of food poisoning from his pizza in the days since. He is not from Newburyport, and this experience has ruined his vacation, as he has been too sick with food poisoning symptoms. I had thought that the mushrooms on his pizza looked like they were old or potentially unwashed, but I don't know if that was the sole thing from his pizza that made him so sick. All I know is that his pizza made him sick. The only reason we even tried to branch out to Otto was because of the GF/DF recommendation, so I hyped it up to my partner that he would finally be able to have a GF/DF pizza that still tasted like pizza, only for him to get food poisoning from it. Clearly not everyone who has had a GF/DF pizza from here has ended with the same result, specifically because it was recommended to us, but I will be telling anyone in the future who is looking for a GF or DF pizza recommendation to stay away from this place. read more

Crust =10 Flavor=1 I ordered a small cheese pizza. Loved the crust. The pizza was very misshapen and it tasted like tomato paste. Absolutely no herbs to add depth and flavor. Very disappointing. read more

Best pizza in town by far. Great selection of beer, wine and liquor. Helpful staff and good prices.

Pizza was great ..unfortunately ice cold by the time it arrived..had to nuke it..ordered through UE..but still good...pizza 5 ..delivery 1

Love their thin crust pizza and rolls for the sub sandwiches . Prices are very competitive . Will definitely be back

Just had my first Otto pie after years of being teased for not trying the "best" pizza in the Port. I chose a small pineapple, bacon and hot honey. The staff was extremely friendly and professional. Wait time was totally reasonable and I picked up some wine and goodies while waiting . Bottom line is that my poor little pizza was way over cooked. Also there was burnt black residue on the bottom. I couldn't even bite into the crust. It was. total loss. I just don't get it. There was no one waiting , the phone wasn't ringing and my pie was burnt? Super disappointed . read more

OTTO - a pizza in a box with a slice missing - Pizza Near Me - Newburyport, Massachusetts

This Newburyport location is reliably unreliable and they will do nothing to make things right with the customer when they make costly mistakes. Their pizzas cost about $26 and it's a coin flip as to whether you'll actually receive what you ordered when you ordered it. You can expect any combination of burned pizzas, being given the wrong pizza, forgotten toppings, a lack of toppings, or making you wait far beyond the time promised for your order. The corporate office doesn't care either. I've contacted them. Imagine planning your family order ahead of the rush. You show up a few minutes after you receive the text that your order is ready for pickup. You have your hungry toddler in hand to to arrive and get dinner, as you specifically planned. The guy at the counter, Diego, says "5 more minutes. He's cutting your pizza up right now." 45 minutes later... after the text telling you your order is ready... you ask for your refund because you need to have dinner ready for your family. He ignores your request and he says again, "5 more minutes. He's cutting your pizza up right now." You ask for your refund again and he hands you two cold pizzas and a sloppy topping fresh pizza. Once again, I contacted Otto's corporate office for help in making this right and was completely ignored. There are plenty of capable pizza places in our town and I will never order from this location again. They get 1 star because the company has a solid rewards program. See below for the cookie cutter response you should expect, if you ever have an issue with Otto's. They take your complaint and file it in their electronic trash. Zero customer engagement. Otto's franchise is broken. read more

We love Ottos pizza! We love it so much that I decided to order it for our family gathering a few days before Christmas. We ordered a large pepperoni and onion, a large extra mushroom, a large mashed potato and bacon, a large cauliflower and two salads. The cauliflower was for two vegetarian guests. Delivery was timely and great, but instead of cauliflower we got buffalo chicken and instead of two salads we got one. We noticed the salad right away and the delivery person offered to come back which I wasn't going to do two days before Christmas. I asked him to set up a refund and he said he couldn't. Needless to say our vegetarians went hungry. I let Ottos know via their survey but no apology or refund was extended. We'll probably order again because we love their pizza, but this was not a good experience. Double check your order before letting the delivery person leave! read more

This Otto location is inside Leary's Fine Wines and Spirits, 202 Merrimac in Newburyport - absolutely fiendish, in the best sense of the word....you walk in, and the aroma goes right to the amygdala (look it up, it's good) - order the pineapple bacon hot honey, large, with double dough. Oh my God - there is no better bang for your buck (2$) than this double dough. It is not Chicago-style deep-dish; it is...... ....you know that Far-Side cartoon, where the two gorillas are sitting on the ground, leaning against the tree, with a huge pile of banana peels next to them? And one of them says, "you know, I really love bananas.....I mean heck, we all do - but for me I think it goes so much more beyond that" THAT is this double dough, for me. So....Walk around and choose an ice-cold 4-pack of a juicy hazy double IPA; ask the staff for advice, they're experts. Bring a driver, because the urge to have some immediately is overwhelming - and if you do....you won't be driving distracted......you'll be driving transported. It isn't safe. At home, pop it in the oven (ON A RACK !) at 350, just to keep the crust as it was when it left their oven.....Take out one of the mugs you keep in the freezer, fill it.....gently. The ideal pairing? The ideal entertainment pairing? "The Old Man" with Jeff Bridges, Season 1 Episode 1..... enjoy all three....then ask yourself: " what did I do to deserve this?" And: " when is season two coming out, and how can any pizza be this good?" Absolutely fiendish, in the best sense of the word. Patrick read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time! Nice thin crust, and the cheese is the perfect kind of blend! I usually get the pepperoni and mushroom.

Delicious pick up pizza from the Newburyport store! Excellent crust, generous toppings (delicious mushrooms!) and a light, fresh sauce and just the right amount of excellent cheese. Good selection of drinks too! read more

Tasty pizza; fast service. Love that you can shop or browse the liquor and extensive cheese case and other surprising treats while you wait. Pizza in a fine food and liquor store- what's not to like? read more

I want to like this place because I live in town and I appreciate local businesses, but I ordered one large pizza and one small (for $43) at 7:00, the app told me it was ready at 7:20 ... and I'm still waking at 7:50. I watched them put one of mine in the over at 7:42 :( Very unfortunate. read more

It's actually really good pizza / flatbreads. The problem is that they are way to expensive for a tiny flatbread.

Really enjoyed this place! Pizza was great! We got a meat lovers and the one with squash, cramberries and ricotta! Loved all of it! Meatballs were great as well, and the tiramisu was just ok. Definitely will be back. The Newburyport location was in a liquor store but easy to find and parking out front- Service was good. Excited to try other menu items! read more

I've been to OTTO 4 times total. Me and my family order 5-6 pies-- many different toppings. Let me start with the good things, Otto has delicious pizzas and has many unique and fresh topping. It also includes gluten free options which was great for two of the members of my family. It also is inside of a liquor store so we were able to hit the packie while picking up Pies-- two birds with one stone! The brutal downside is that 2 of the 4 times i've been here, my Spice Pulled Pork Pizza(personal favorite highly recommend) has been burnt pretty badly. Now i'm a hungry guy so I powered through but for the steep price can I please get a well cooked Za? Lastly, the pricing is pretty high so expect to ask your boys for a Venmo after ordering here. Would be an easy 4.5/5 star if I didn't have the bad experience so take that how you will if you wanna gamble for a non burnt pizza here. read more

Best pizza crust with unique toppings. One of our favorite is their Buffalo Cauliflower Pizza. Our kids like the pepperoni pizza and their new favorite is the garlic cheesy bread. The Otto app is so easy to use and I love their reward program. read more

Pizza was fabulous. Service was excellent Staff was very professional and friendly. Highly recommend read more

While we've enjoyed Otto's pizza for years, recently, it was a bit disappointing to get like 3 decent spoons of the pulled pork on our large specialty pizza. Please do better next time. The flavors are awesome but doesn't feed a grown man who eats meat. Thanks. read more

Disappointed today. Received a message saying my order was ready, but arrived to find out it wasn't. Waited 20 minutes before they told me they forgot to put in the 2nd pizza. Kept waiting as more pizzas went in and came out of the oven, but not mine. Finally got it after 45 minutes. No discount and the manager never stepped up. It'll be a long time, if ever, before I go back. I'd rather have a pizza from Oregano. read more

First visit for us. Weren't sure what to expect with just a counter inside a store, but the vibe was friendly and the pizza was super tasty. We went with a classic pepperoni as our standard test, and look forward to trying many other varieties. Crust was amazing! read more

Well this is my 2nd review...and I did return twice since. My 2nd time around other than the easy ordering online was a completely negative experience. I ordered 2 small pizzas of which I was looking forward to sharing with my neighbor. I tried using the tracking your order ,but it wasn't operating correctly. I phoned and spoke with rude staff who were not helpful in the least. I was told my pizza wasn't ready but I said I'd be there in a few. When I arrived there were several in boxes on a shelf ..after some back and forth I learned that mine were there. I signed my repeipt and left. Drove home and opened them to serve. . completely inedible, each slice a combo of cardboard and rubber. Horrible and inexcusable. I spent over $30 on awful. I called & got absolutely nowhere. So I sent a message to their corporate office with the details. They sent me coupon codes so I could give them another chance... Did I want to? Well I really didn't want to cook tonight and I thought I would try it again... 8 ordered online which again was simple enough. With my past experience I phoned earlier than pick up time to make sure they wouldn't be sitting for who knows how long on a shelf .. the staff member who answered was actually nasty. But did add that they were slicing them now? I said Thank you and id be right there. I walked right in and there they were in the shelf again ..for how long this time? I asked to open the boxes before I signed the receipt and left with them.... So he begrudgingly did with attitude that I won't add in this review. They did seem ok and before I left said thank you. .did I get one in return? If course not! If looks could kill, I wouldn't be writing this .. so again, I got home and opened the boxes to serve. Not the best and not the worst .. mediocre at best. Was it worth the aggravation? Hardly I won't be doing this ever again! read more

When moving up to Massachusetts from one of the best cities for Pizza in the world, I was a little worried that I wouldn't be able to find any decent Pizzeria. I was so wrong. I first discovered OTTO's in Portland, Maine! When I found out they were opening a branch in Newburyport, I was thrilled! There's nothing better than a double-dough, 4meat Pizza. It just covers all the food groups and the crust is to die for! I highly recommend accompanying a few slices with a nice refreshing salad from OTTO's. It doesn't get much better... I can truly say "Life is good!" read more

Double dough is a must! We live about 20 minutes away from the Newburyport location so placed an online order before we left. Order was fresh, hot & ready when we got there. The Sriracha Chicken with Avocado on double dough is super delicious. read more

Very disappointed, we have been ordering for years and just recently the quality went down dramatically. Order online is disabled and the person who is taking orders on the phone is rude and seems careless in making side remarks . I used to order the spicy pullporks with scallions and there is barely any meat on it. Meat ball ricotta got the same treatment. These pizzas are no longer worst the extra cost because I suspect there is a new franchise owner who is cutting on cost and still changing full price. I can no longer recommend this shop and will bring my business else where unless it changes. read more

The best in town Always fresh and perfect !! A tastebud pizza dream!!! Try the mashed potato bacon pizza ! To die for read more

A very interesting and tasty choice of pizzas. From the staple 4-cheese pizza to a more elaborate mashed potato and bacon pizza. Gluten Free crust is pleasantly good! The online ordering and instore service is both excellent. read more

Quality control? How could they let something like this go out the door! read more

OTTO - Pizza Near Me - Newburyport, Massachusetts

Ordered a large pizza with onions, mushrooms, olives and peppers. They didn't have peppers. Really? What kind of pizza place doesn't have peppers? The pizza had hardly any toppings AT ALL. Like one olive per slice, maybe 2 mushrooms per slice. Seriously. It was a really sad pizza. $25 for this felt like robbery. The only saving grace is that their dough is pretty flavorful and thin. read more

We ordered 3 pizzas for takeout.. each box we opened was fresh, hot, perfectly crisp crust, and just really good! Probably top 5 pizzas we have ever had! read more

I placed a pizza order for delivery today but the food was never delivered. I called the store multiple times and was told my order would be arriving soon. It never came. read more

Fast delivery, perfect pizza and very friendly delivery man! They also delivered wine with it! First time ordering and will buy again!

I ordered a "build your own" pizza. The online delivery process was confusing and I accidentally ordered my toppings to be only on one half of the pizza. Worse, two of the toppings that I ordered and paid for weren't even on half. When I called to let them know they did apologize and offer to make me a new pizza, but I didn't have time to wait for it. They acknowledged that I wasn't the only one to have some confusion with the online ordering process. It's too bad; they have nice pizzas but they seem a bit disorganized. read more