The Neptune is without doubt the best diner in Lancaster and surrounding area. The food is of good quality, expertly prepared and served in traditional Lancaster County huge portions. Even the delivery service is personal and excellent. I look forward to starting my day with them as often as possible. Give them a try! read more

I had such an amazing breakfast here. I loved it and will want to come back here one day. I ordered the harvest moon breakfast that comes with the best french toast I've ever had, 2 eggs, sausage, bacon, and hashbrowns. This was lot of food and I did share part of it with my kid but I was able to eat most of it myself. The french toast had the perfect amount of crispiness and also softness. It was sprinkled with confectionery sugar and was the perfect amount of sweetness. I did not even need to add additional syrup to it. I will be raving about this for a while now that I have had this. The eggs, sausage and bacon was standard and very enjoyable. The hashbrowns were very good! The potatoes are cut thicker than normal but it was still very soft to chew. I really liked it. read more

I have a soft spot in my heart for diners. They are what makes America great: food that makes you feel like you are home after a long trip. If a diner can't capture that feeling, then it is not a diner. Thankfully Neptune Diner hits the mark. Ambiance: The place itself is deceptively large. The front area has a small bar and several seats scattered around, but the restaurant has a large back space. The place looks and feels like a diner, what more can I say? Food: My friends and I came for breakfast, so I can't comment on the rest. We got a combination of omelets and breakfast platters. I got the "mexican omelet" which is filled with chili and cheese. It will give you a heart attack, but it was cholesterol-filled nightmare I wanted. The rest of my friends enjoyed their meals, so it looks like their breakfast menu at least gets a solid review. Service: We had a large party of nearly 10 people and while we couldn't sit together, the waitress did a good job finding tables close together. Food took awhile to come out, but given the size of our party it was understandable. Drinks: Coffee, soda, and tea. That's all you really need. read more

Awesome traditional American diner. Friendly people and big portions. A must visit. Went back the next day. Awesome. People are really friendly. The food is outstanding. Bring your appetite- would go here every day if I lived closer. read more

Neptune Diner - Kielbasa Scrambler - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

The food and service was very good. I had sometime to kill and said let's give it a try. I am glad I did spend a lot of time around here and will be back. It is a very friendly and clean place. Well priced. read more

Neptune Diner - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I honestly have no idea why everyone raves about Neptune Diner. I was expecting so much from this diner and was extremely disappointed. The service was slow and forgetful and the food was mediocre at best. I ordered my eggs over medium and the yolks were completely hard. The pancakes were an absolute disgrace (not much better than a battered brick) and took over 45 minutes to get them. The coffee literally tasted like someone added half a scoop of instant coffee to an entire pot of coffee -- basically water. I honestly don't know why everyone was raving about the Neptune Diner. Don't come here, it's a waste of time and money. read more

Good cheap food. My friend and I stopped by for a quick bite before a Lancaster Barnstormers game. She had The Birds Nest, I the Mexican Omelette. Nothing fancy, just your simple diner food - something that always pleases me. Wait staff could not have been friendlier. I was glad we decided to stop by since it wasn't part of our original agenda. The Neptune Diner was pleasant surprise. read more

Neptune Diner - The Bird's Nest - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I seriously don't understand what most others find impressive about this eatery. So far, the most overpriced and underserving diner in my life. Even Wafflehouse is much cheaper and tastes fresher. I called to double check if it's still ok to dine in at the last hour given that many kitchens close a bit earlier then. The person who answered said just come on in because they meant they stop seating or taking people in by their advertised closing time. It was Saturday night and the place was empty. I should've taken it as a red flag in the first place because I know a diner is good when it's crowded on a Friday or Saturday night even around close. Service was satisfactory. According to our server of the night, it was her first day. Understandable she had to double check with her coworker to pass on menu clarifications. They were being professional as possible. My date ordered a cheesesteak sub with fries and I ordered chicken tenders with mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli. I tasted freezer burn in the tenders and broccoli. Mashed potato was unevenly mashed. Not to mention pretty bland. According to my date (and I agree after trying a bite of her order), cheesesteak and fries were bland. Although having mayo in cheesesteak is typically the norm, having marinara sauce with it instead didn't sound farfetched to me. Adding ketchup and salt to the fries and salt to cheesteak with marinara salvaged things a bit. Honestly the only items with any flavor to begin with were pretty much the soft drinks we ordered. Portions weren't even really satisfying given our check totalled to $28. I should've paid attention to any other 1- or 2-star reviews about this place instead of just being sold on the overall 4-star rating. read more

Nice little spot for lunch. Apparently they are famous for their meatloaf. I had the meatloaf Benedict. It was pretty good. However the poached egg was cooked hard. My wife had the western omelette. She really enjoyed it and it came out in a cast iron skillet. I also really liked that sourdough bread was an option for the toast. My father had the chop steak. It was huge. The fries that came with it were fresh cut. The waitress was very friendly and accommodating. Overall a good experience. If we are in the area again I would stop in. read more

Neptune Diner - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

It was fine. Pretty typical omelette at a typical diner. I hear the meatloaf is all the rage so I'll try that and the scrapple next time and see if that stuff is more exciting. To be continued.... read more

See all

Sunday breakfast in Lancaster should be a special meal. Scrapple, a grilled sticky bun - with butter, an omelette and coffee. The Neptune Diner is now our go-to place for Sunday breakfast in Lancaster. The only disappointments are that their Dutch Fries Omelette does not have enough home fries and does have sliced mushrooms. read more

Ah, the good old Neptune diner... you know, I've lived in Lancaster my whole life and never went here until today. Fun fact, this place opened in 1941!!! I went for the breakfast and got their crab omelet. While it tasted good, I was a little disappointed. Their crab cake inside the omelet was not real crab. I'm pretty sure they used the cheap crab cake sold in 4 packs at giant and the other local supermarkets that uses fake crab meat (could have crab in them but it's filled with lots of fillers and surimi). I'm not saying that they get their crab cake from the supermarket. They probably buy them bulk. Fake crab cake omelet fir $9.25 made me a little crabby to be honest :( read more

Really wonderful place! The food is great, the portions are very generous, and the staff are so kind!! What more could you want from a diner? I had the one of their hometown specials, a cheese omelette smothered in cream chipped beef and a bit of cheddar cheese (I'd leave off the cheese next time but that's just my preference). The flavors were on point. My mom had a Thanksgiving wrap which she said was also incredibly flavorful. I'll make a point to frequent this place more often--so many good things on the menu. read more

Locals do best here. Great little diner, that actually isn't so little. There's a surprising large room in the back that until recently I didn't even realize existed. Portions are huge. read more

Been eating at this diner since I was a small child, 30+ years. Wonderful vintage diner exterior and interior. Service is always great! Food is always fresh, delicious and home cooked!! This is a staple diner for me, will always highly recommend! Never disappointed. read more

Well first thing...wait 10 mins for a seat. Waited another 10 mins for someone to take out order. Waited about her 40 mins for 2 omelets. Never came so we left hungry and mad! Guess what...not going there for a LONG TIME! And they charged us for a coffee!!! COME ON REALLY!! read more

We had a great experience at Neptune Diner. We were visiting from California and went for brunch. We were pleasantly surprised to find that many many items are homemade - apple dumpling, sticky bun, fries, biscuits, just so much!! I had an omelette and potatoes which was great. All of our food was absolutely delicious. The service was 10/10, very friendly servers, we were seated right away. Looks a little sketchy on the outside but in the inside is a great food place!! read more

Was recommended to us by the hotel receptionist for breakfast while we were visiting.. highly recommend! I got the ham steak scrambler, without ham which was SO yummy! Huge portions! Only ate about 1/3 and was full. Being from the south, we love our scrapple so we were excited to see that they have it as well! read more

We heard about the travel channel coming here so of course we decided to try the meatloaf. I had the Neptune Meatloaf Melt: Meatloaf with Swiss cheese, tomato, onion and chipotle mayo, served on grilled French toast. It was delicious! The meatloaf has a great taste and the right bite to it. The French toast had an apple and slightly sweet taste. It was interesting mixing all the tastes together, but it worked. The scrapple was also good! Prompt and friendly service. read more

Neptune Diner - Neptune Meatloaf Melt with fries - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

We heard about this place on the food channel for there famous meatloaf. And the meatloaf was awesome!!! the mashed potatoes were homemade. The portions were very big. I would highly recommend this place!! read more

Neptune Diner - There famous meatloaf! - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

This place has great food and great service cozy seats and warm inside. Also you should get the raspberry tea delicious. read more

Neptune Diner - Yassssss - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

For someone who loves ambiance I was a little worried this place wasn't going to be the place for me. I was so surprised that this was not just another greasy spoon. Service was stellar, and my omelet was expertly cooked. My dining partner had the meatloaf, which comes with a large selection of preparations. While I couldn't have any because it wasn't gluten free she said it was spectacular. Also, the chili omelet is supposed to be on point. read more

Don't let the outside of this place discourage you. It's very clean and the service is excellent. This is a "go to" place for a really delicious breakfast in Lancaster. A very large breakfast menu. Also, for dinner, try the meatloaf, it's delicious!!! read more

Friendly good service, great quality fresh food for an even greater price. Portions are generous enough to share or bring home leftovers (they use foam containers) booth seats need some TLC, but great local vibe. Desserts looked amazing in the case, but that's for another day! read more

See all

After purchasing Oyster Sandwiches at their stand next to my nephew's auction I stopped by and have made it my Sunday lunch locale ever since. Great service and food for reasonable prices. read more

Neptune Diner - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Ok food for a diner. Had expected more but at least the serving size was decent and I'm pleasantly full.

The Neptune was probably good at some point. My parents drag me here if we ever go out together. The service is fair to average. Our waitress brought half of our food with the plates (and food) resting on her chest. Another waitress with a short bob style hairdo carried her tray on her shoulder and her hair rested on top of people's food. Our waitress didn't bring us utensils, napkins, syrup, cream, and some other things we ordered unless we asked - sometimes twice. The ceiling tiles are dirty and drooping. The staff in the back of the house keeps their personal belongings with customer food just what I can see walking in. The seating in the back room is crowded and uncomfortable. The food is reasonably priced but slathered in fake liquid butter and the last few times my scrambled eggs were quite runny. It's just okay. read more

This was less than stellar. Seeing it from the outside, it kind of looks like a greasy spoon, and the inside isnt much better... ---------- FOOD: Almost everything had some sort of meat on it, in it or around it. I got a grilled cheese and some fries, neither of which were very memorable.. SERVICE: Friendly but sluggish. The hostess seats you, but she also rings you up, so if someone is cashing out you get to stand there.. and we did. Then we sat down and got breakfast menus at lunch. So we finally order and it takes an incredibly long time to get food. It says that in the menu, but its still not a fun wait.. DECOR: Its a diner style restaurant. Its really REALLY small and cramped feeling. The guy next to me had a shelf at his head. If he moved wrong he would have given himself a pretty good gash. ---------- FINAL THOUGHTS: Would I go again? No. Its just too small and the wait for food is just too long. Im pretty impatient when it comes to food. It also has that dirty feeling.. read more

Loved this place & food. I had the turkey dinner. Real mashed potatoes, stuffing , & turkey breast. Huge serving! So much that I didn't get the pie. Phooey! Husband had delicious ham dinner. Our waitress was great. Loved chatting with her. read more

Shofly pie, and breakfast omelett, tasty all fresh food. Nice old fashioned diner. Good visit. read more

Neptune Diner - Diners Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Great Diner. A little more pricey than some other local diners but it's worth it. Amazing breakfast combinations! Homemade biscuits and gravy are great. Feels and looks like an old school diner. read more

Drove all the way from delawate to try the famous meatloaf. The didnt have any at 1pm on a Saturday. Had a cup of chicken soup delivered to the table luke warm. Seriouly disappointed read more

Ate breakfast here on Saturday. It was very good. I had an Italian omelette and a side of sausage. The omelette was good especially the pepperoni and provolone cheese. The coffee was pretty good as well. read more

First of all this place smells like piss when you walk in. There was a piece of plastic in my food and the hash browns are like mashed potatoes w brown coloring on the top read more

This is a great diner. Conveniently located near, but not right in, downtown Lancaster, I hit the Neptune Diner twice, once for breakfast and once for lunch. Both times were very good. My friend eggs were made just right, the sausage was delicious and the waitress did not even blink when I asked for a ladle of chili poured over the plate. That's St. Louis style, a slinger. The waitress was nice and attentive. I could not really have asked for more. The lunch was a meatloaf with mashed potatoes. The serving was large and delicious. Unlike some diners, the potatoes were not lumpy. And there was plenty of gravy to go around. The Neptune exudes that feel of diners gone by, where you pop in after a night out and bond a bit more with your pals. I hope the people of Lancaster appreciate it as much as I did. read more

Stopped in the Neptune for breakfast after spending the night camping in the outfield of the Barnstormers stadium. A table for our two families was made pronto, service was good, and the food was decent. Coffee refills came quickly, and the Greek omelet ($8.50) was a favorite by 4 in our party. Waitress was patient when a water spill drenched a table. The only gripe was the prices, which seemed a two dollars too high for every menu item. Was a solid meal, but for the price, I'd shoot for better food next time. Today, we paid the price for diner ambiance and convenience. read more

Stopped in for a late breakfast today and overall enjoyed the experience. I had steak tips and eggs which was cooked well and generous potions. My wife had eggs Benidict. The hollandaise left something to be desired for sure. The service was good and it has a nice classic diner car feel. read more

We were traveling from NYC to PA with 3 young kids(3, 5, and 8 yrs old). On our last day before heading home, we found this diner on YELP and the reviews looked promising. I am not a big fan of meatloaf but this is by far my favorite place to eat in the area! The service is great! We even bought another meatloaf to bring home! The potion is generous and kids love it. read more

A good old-fashioned boxcar diner with great inexpensive breakfasts, waffles, and omelettes served in cast iron pans. Comfort food at a great price and a great alternative to the overpriced buffet breakfasts. read more

See all

My husband and I were in Lancaster for a wedding and the next morning we ended up here. We were not disappointed. The service was great, the food was delicious, the pancakes were huge. It's about an hour and a half from home but we will be back! read more