Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mr. Pickes Bar And Eatery

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM

    Mr. Pickes Bar And Eatery Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Mr. Pickes Bar And Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Paco R.
    4
    107
    13

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Wonder Horse - Mezzanine floor

    Wonder Horse

    5.0(3 reviews)
    0.1 km
    $$

    In Hamilton for 2 nights. Enjoyed this spot twice . One of…read morethe few bars we could belly up to as many in NZ seem to have no stools. Great cocktails and beer selection. Friendly, engaging staff.

    This is a serious contender for best bar in Hamilton. I came here Saturday night with my husband…read moreand a couple friends. Why, why have I not been here before now?! I used to live just up the block! My husband had already been here and, somehow, did not bring me in immediately. This is one of those places where I had a "love at first sight" moment. Even on a fairly crowded night, the vibe in this place is super-cool. It's small, almost uncomfortably so, but in spite of that (because of that?) it has a great intimate feel. The cocktails are pricey, but different and skillfully prepared. There is a good selection of whiskey (my whiskey-loving friend tells me). There was a DJ artfully spinning a weird, awesome, "did-he-just-do-that?" selection of tunes. The decor is comfortable/cool, with walls of exposed bricks and "I never want to get up" comfy couches. The back walls are lined with loads of books and one portion of the ceiling is covered with records. They appear to have some bites to eat, but admittedly, we were just there for drinks. It's a little tricky to find, set back from Victoria Street down a side alley. But, it's SO worth finding.

    Photos
    Wonder Horse - Wonder Horse at 1am on a Friday morning

    Wonder Horse at 1am on a Friday morning

    Wonder Horse - Lounge area

    Lounge area

    Wonder Horse - Nyet My President (white Russian with orange Donald "hair") lol

    See all

    Nyet My President (white Russian with orange Donald "hair") lol

    The Roaming Giant

    The Roaming Giant

    4.0(3 reviews)
    0.8 km

    Would've rated this place better but the one serving us, a young lady, was very impatient with our…read moregroup. We are a large group with a lot of kids so deciding on our order can be a little bit harder than most people who are local to the area and know what they want right away. Too bad, I really liked the pork belly I got and the restaurant looked nice and had a really good ambiance. Service could have been a little bit better.

    At first glance, you might think this place is a pub because of the prominent placement of the bar…read more However, it's more like a family restaurant. The menu selection is very good, and my kids love the burgers, the pizza, and the fish 'n chips when they visit. My partner and I really enjoy the wide selection of mid-range craft beer. They carry one or two premium craft beers, but they're mostly Monteith's and Mac's--nothing to scoff at, mind you! We enjoy the food too; it's got that comfort food vibe, which we like. The people behind the bar and waiting tables are always very amicable, and they seem to enjoy serving children. That can be hard to find in New Zealand. So I certainly appreciate their putting forward the effort. On Saturdays and Sundays, they usually offer live music in the afternoon. The acts are not usually a band but one person. It can get loud, for obvious reasons, so be prepared for that. Otherwise, they're always willing to turn the tvs to watch one of your favourite teams. I go there to watch American football from Aug to Dec and sometimes even make it in for NCAA football (which is a phenomenon that blows Kiwis minds; why watch college football when there's the real thing!).

    Photos
    The Roaming Giant - The Mountain pizza

    The Mountain pizza

    The Roaming Giant - Cheeseburger with fries

    Cheeseburger with fries

    The Roaming Giant - Half of lunch menu

    See all

    Half of lunch menu

    Easy Tiger - Inside decor

    Easy Tiger

    2.5(2 reviews)
    0.2 km
    $$$

    I've lived in Hamilton and haven't had too much occasion to go bar hopping, as a 30-something with…read moretwo small kids. However, a few Fridays ago, my husband and I were out "late" with a friend and this was one of the places we landed. I really love the decor! It's modern and inviting, dark enough for some ambiance and to flatter everyone. I think I may have come in here once a long while ago, saw the price of the cocktails and decided I would never come back. But, I'm glad I did. Now that I'm kind of over the sticker-shock prices of drinking in New Zealand, I realize that this place is indeed pricey, but mostly worth it. It's also entirely possible that the prices of the drinks keeps a certain subset of young party-goers out, which at my present stage of life, I'm completely OK with. I had a "passionfruit cheesecake" drink. We were sitting near the bar and I had fun watching the bartender construct this little gem, which was complete with a "crumb" bottom. It was awesome. I'm not sure it was quite $17-awesome, but I'm just trying to focus in on my enjoyment of the evening and block out the price of the drinks. My husband had chilled amaretto. He was happy with it (not that it takes still to make it). Our friend had the "Winnie the Pooh," and really enjoyed it. This is definitely a good stop on Victoria Street for good atmosphere, good drinks. It's probably too expensive to be most people's "regular bar," but it's perfect for an occasional splurge on a night out.

    This place is pretentious. I came here wth my best friend before a concert, and when she ordered​…read moreher drink the bartender she'd her if she was sure she wanted it as it was 'pretty expensive' (it was $15). She got a bit confused and then asked if he had any good cocktails he could make, and his response was 'not tonight, we're busy'. As she then thought about what she wanted, I ordered 2 fingers of bourbon, to which he responded "are you sure?". When I said I was, he poured a shot, then again asked if I 'Really wanted more'. When I replied yes, I know what two fingers is, his response was "its pretty expensive, are you sure?". This bartender was both offensive, and arrogant. He purely judged us based on our appearance, and then repeatedly implyed we could not afford normal drink prices. Will not ever come again, this bartender should be fired for losing (well paying) customers.

    Keystone - Inside bar area

    Keystone

    4.0(1 review)
    0.2 km
    $$

    We've been to Keystone a number of times, usually for lunch. They are part of a hospitality group…read morein town and share a loyalty card with them (Lawrensen Group restaurats/bars). I've been to Keystone twice in the last week, so figured it was finally time to sit down and write a review. Keystone is a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde sort of place. At lunch, it's fairly quiet, local sports being shown on the TV. There is plentiful indoor and outdoor seating and I've often enjoyed sitting outside and people watching on Victoria Street. The interior decor is warm, with dark wood paneling and a combination of high-top and low-top tables, a bar area and other regular seating indoors. During a recent lunch, my husband had the beef sliders with fries. It consisted of 3 sliders and a small-ish side of fries. He loves the sliders. The fries were fine, but nothing special. I had the vegetable salad, which had pumpkin, kumara, red onion, crispy chickpeas, feta and spinach. I was pretty happy with the size and the flavor. We came a few Fridays ago with a friend, who wanted to listen to the live music. The outdoor seating area was mostly cleared of tables so that there was a dancing area. The place was absolutely packed, barely standing room. The band was playing covers, loudly. The band was good, but it certainly was too loud to really have a conversation with each other. Those in attendance were mostly 30-and-40-somethings, sloppy drunk, and appeared to be trying to recreate their university days. It was more like a frat party gone wrong. There was a heavy police presence on the street, with the police van parked right out front for easy access to take over-rowdy folks in easily. It wasn't really the scene we were looking for at the time, hence the tone of this last paragraph, but if you ARE looking for that sort of scene it would be a great place to go. It really just depneds on what sort of mood you are in. We'll definitely be back in the future. Don't forget to get your loyalty card and use it to collect points at the other establishments in the group.

    Photos
    Keystone - View of outdoor seating

    View of outdoor seating

    Keystone - Keystone's lamb shank. $27.00 ($16.00 USD). The lamb was tender, broccoli al dente and thick, and mashed potatoes creamy.

    Keystone's lamb shank. $27.00 ($16.00 USD). The lamb was tender, broccoli al dente and thick, and mashed potatoes creamy.

    Keystone - Lunch vegetable salad with feta, spinach, pumpkin, jumara and crispy chickpeas

    See all

    Lunch vegetable salad with feta, spinach, pumpkin, jumara and crispy chickpeas

    Mr. Pickes Bar And Eatery - bars - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...