They used to be 20 and $.30 cheaper than everyone else would gasoline and then they decided that they don't have to save everybody the tax even though they don't have to pay the tax. So why go all the way out of your way to save maybe five or six cents a gallon. Think about it if you get 10 gallons of gas, you're driving all the way there to give them the business for $.60. It's ridiculous. if they want everyone to drive in there to buy marijuana and buy cigarettes, they should lower the gas prices. They don't have to pay tax so they should pass most of that savings on to other people so they can get people to come in there to buy their cheap cigarettes. But over the last couple of years they've been doing a lot of building and now they got greedy. read more

This has been going on since the 2 new gas stations opened where the gas is just as expensive as regular gas stations not on the Reservation. Now that montauk gas has been taken over by new ownership and now call Rez gas the gas is more expensive than outside gas. This is pure greed. They took away the use of a bathroom and even garbage can to cut costs only to over charge for gas when they are not subjected to the same tax liabilities. The entire Reservation economy will suffer from the greed. read more

Its not worth it for me to come here anymore. Lots of competition now, gas isn"t that cheap anymore, diesel wasn't cheap at all even in summer. The nicest touch is when you drive in now, lotsa kids on quads tailing you or flying around you. I guess the weed business is the money maker now. I"m done. read more

Always stop by when im in the area. They are not as cheap as they used to be but still cheaper than most.

Gas here is consistently 20 to 30 Since cheaper than anywhere else. Never a line or a wait and Clean. You had a few potholes getting to this location, and there's not usually a receipt paper roll in the machine, but if you go inside they'll print one for you. For the money you're saving, it's well worth it! read more

Montauk Native Gas - Gas logo - Gas Stations Near Me - Mastic, New York

How can you not give a gas station 5 stars that has gas at Georgia prices. I was in the area today, needed gas, and said "screw it" I'll take a 5 minute detour and fill up. I wish I brought gas cans with me! Covid stuff (I love covid because it makes my reviews the proper Yelp length): inside the attendants all had on masks, and there were markings on the floor to keep proper Distance. While on the topic. I've always been a proper distance guy. I always hated when someone rolled up on me when waiting on line. So covid I thank you!!! Anyway, the people inside are really helpful and friendly. I got some smokes for my father when I was there. She went down to basement to get them. So many store clerks wouldn't bother. So yeah they get 5 stars from me. If you stop in don't forget the gas cans. At these prices stock up if you can. read more

Montauk Native Gas - the price of a gas station - Gas Stations Near Me - Mastic, New York

This is supposed to be an Indian Reservation. they do not charge taxes but the gas prices have been higher than regular gas stations that do charge tax. the entire are smells like pot and all they sell is pot and cigarettes. read more

ent there this morning at 5:45 AM walked in the door to purchase a few cartons of cigarettes and was told I was parked in the wrong spot by some employee, the girl at the counter was telling him it was OK for me to park there, I did not see any no parking signs, I was not blocking anything there was not a single car in the parking lot, and was told I would have to move my car to in front of the pumps Didn't make sense to me, won't buy gas there either, SOME PEOPLE JUST ARENT SMART IN BUSINESS LOL, but I know one thing I will never go back again!!! I went down the street to smokes for less, super clean store, friendly people, read more

I like coming here as price is good, the convenience store has almost anything you want, milk, cough drops, snacks. It is extremely clean and the people behind the counter are great! Gas prices are terrific! I recommend to all! I heard a new store behind them selling gemstones opening up. Very cool! Joyce read more

Very cheap I got gas for $3.19 while other gas pumps were $3.69 very good also I was impressed about how cool the people were they all were nice and respectful read more

This station has the cheapest gas. All employees are friendly. They accept all major credit cards and the prices are the same even if you are filling up your boat tank. They also have a place for boats to get gas. This is the only gas station I fill up with gas in Suffolk County. read more

Montauk Native Gas - a sign for a gas station - Gas Stations Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Love coming here been coming here for a long time to get gas and smoke for my mom and husband.

Best price on gas in this area. Normally like $.20 to $.30 a gallon cheaper than anyone else. Cigarette are $25 a carton. Indian brand cigarettes, but who cares. You save $75 or more a carton. The roads to get there are not good. Pot holes and stuff. But a small price to pay to #ave money. Just redid the store, has a deli and other things read more

Just be warned this place closes at 8:45. I rushed there after work and made it 15 min before it closed and they told me to turn around. Very unprofessional. read more

Update Montauk native gas.i just wanted to update my review they did not short me on gas.My gas gauge on my car was broken.just wanted to set the record straight my apologies for the negative review read more