When you think about Aburi oishi sushi in Toronto, it's hard not to think of names like JA Bistro, Minami and Miku. I'm more of a traditionalist when it comes to sushi so aburi oishi sushi would not be on top of my list, but as a foodie, I'm almost obligated to give them a try. The annual Winterlicious was the perfect opportunity for me to check them out.
According to their site, Minami was America's best designed restaurant in 2021. Really? Don't get me wrong, it is a nice setting, but award winning? Plus we are not American. And the restaurant felt like they only spent effort on the top half of the walls in the washroom.
And their menu is supposedly designed by a Japanese Michelin starred chef. Well the thing is, it's not cooked by one.
For the starter, I elected for the beef sukiyaki; the name a bit misleading. There is absolutely no soup in this dish (they did describe it on their menu though). Braised beef marinated in sukiyaki sauce would be a more suitable name. In my books, this dish absolutely failed. The braised beef was decently tough. When the bartender/server asked me how it was, I told her exactly how it was. But her response , even if she didn't mean it was quite unprofessional and insulting. She didn't apologize, nor suggest how she can make it better. Instead, she said it's a bit tougher because it's braised. What is that supposed to mean anyway? Are you saying I don't know my food? Have I not had braised beef before? My response to her was pick cuts of meat that is a little more fatty and slow cook it a bit more. The taste of the beef was also nothing special. However, I really liked the roasted Brussel sprouts (and I'm normally not a brussel sprouts guy) and potatoes were very well done. I would actually order a serving of the brussel sprouts on its own if I could. Although done right, I'm not sure how the onsen egg factors into the dish.
The 6 pieces of sushi were also nothing special. I can tell, high quality fresh fish was used in the nigiri sushi (scallop, salmon and yellowtail), but I hate the fact that they feel like they had to do something to it, regardless if it is torching, adding some sort of sauce on top or overdoing the wasabi. Those things all took away from the taste of the fish. The aburi oishi sushis were not great. They pressed the sushi too much, and the sushi became too moist, dense and heavy. I felt like the sauces used on each piece were your standard oishi sushi sauce. I'm just glad I didn't come at normal times and order 12 pieces of these guys.
Their layered carrot cake was a pleasant surprise. I generally dislike carrot cake, but they managed to make it enjoyable. The cream cheese espuma and sake infused pineapple compote made the difference. I didn't taste the miso, but the miso caramel was not overly sweet.
The service and how much they dropped the ball on the food items that truly "counts", led to a super disappointing experience. If their intention in participating in the Winterlicious is to convince people to have a return visit, Minami has failed in this regard. It even made me think twice about trying, their sister restaurant, Miku in the future. read more