Stopped in with some friends over the weekend having heard that Merroir was a fantastic place to eat. There were a few of us that planned on having some beer/wine and small plates to share, so the restaurant's concept looked really promising. Got there just in time for a late lunch and we were sat much faster than we expected. A nice table outside with some shade and a good view. The restaurant is very well liked and while we were there it seemed like there was a small wait to sit the entire time. Not enough to make people turn around and walk away, but busy enough that you know something must be going on to convince obvious regulars to wait for a table in the August sun.
Waitress got our drink order in fairly quickly, but did not ask if we wanted any water. Not to complain about something that some would consider trivial, but it was a table outside, and it was ninety out. Maybe there is some kind of shortage out there in Rappahannock, because the offer never made it to our table. Even when two in our party asked, a glass was brought for them which was promptly drank and never refilled.
Wine list was succinct, but everything on it would pair well with the menu, so we got a few different glasses to all be able to try and share. Oysters to start and they really were the star of the meal. I am not an oyster fan and they were some of the best that I have had since moving to the east coast. Three of each varietal for each of us. Paired with the white wines that we had selected they were splendid. Again, these were the best part of what we had simply because I am not an oyster lover and I enjoyed these!
Second round of food was the Scallops, the Stuffin Muffin, Crabcake, Virginia Cheese Board, Tuna Crudo, Clams, and the Soft-Shell Crab ( who writes a review on one dish at a small plates restaurant? :) ). I listed them in order of favorite to least.
The Scallops are some of the best that I have ever had, and the kale kimchee that comes with them is a brilliant pairing. I would buy the kimchee alone...
The Stuffin Muffin is a traditional oyster stuffing that was also a wonderful dish. So much flavor and a tough dish to share because you'll want it all for yourself.
The Crabcake was a fantastic representation here. I almost want to compile a list of all of the great ones out here. The east coast does not know how great they have it with this dish...
The Virginia Cheese Board is a very unique sampling of state cheeses, but they need to send out more flatbread with it. Even our server commented that the five or six tiny triangles that it came with couldn't possibly be enough.
The Tuna Crudo was kinda uninspiring. It really feels like a dish that I could find on a chain restaurants summer seasonal menu.
The Clams... Skip the clams. Any time I order shellfish served in broth with bread, the broth should be something that I want to mop up with the bread. It had no flavor to speak of. None. So disappointing.
Then the Soft-Shell Crab. This dish confused the heck out of me. The only place I have been where the crab appears to have been steamed (this is a soft-shell) and sat on a piece of grilled bread. I had a bite, but it really wasn't good enough to bother to try a second bite. The steamed crab pretty much just gushed water (again, flavorless water, maybe he cooked with the clams?) onto the bread below whenever we went to cut a slice to plate. Never had a soft-shell crab steamed before. Never will again...
Overall, I was very pleased with three dishes, unimpressed by two, and downright mad about two. The clams and the crab are two things that I normally am thrilled about and they were both downright bad.
By all means, if you're close you should give Merroir a shot. Just be sure to be cautious with your order. Our meal was a mixed bag which cost several hundred dollars, and sometimes folks don't want to gamble that kind of tab on small plates they may not love. read more