Shopping at Lindy's was a good experience the first time, but unfortunately we had a terrible experience trying to exchange the pair of diamond earrings we purchased because one of the clasps wasn't closing properly. The employee who was working at the time of the incident accused us of breaking the earrings because "gold is malleable" (in an incredibly rude and condescending tone of voice) and said "well I know it was straight when I sold it to you" (when she wasn't who sold us to them the first time). She then took them to the back to bend the post with a pair of pliers, which doesn't really instill confidence in the quality of a piece of fine jewelry. When she brought them back out, it didn't even close the same way as the other earring, but we were told "well I can hear it click". After bringing my fiancé nearly to tears, no one apologized for the experience and we now have a random assortment of other pieces from trying meet the ticket price of the original earrings, since they have an exchange only policy. The owner eventually came out to assist in picking pieces, seemingly unaware of the horrendous experience that just occurred, so hopefully our negative experience was isolated to one bad apple. read more

I love this store. My husband bought me a beautiful necklace with a rather delicate chain for my birthday last year. It ended up being so delicate that it needed repaired after I wore it everyday for a few months. We live a bit far from Amelia island so on one of the few days we had time to make the trip up the store had been closed after a hurricane scare. An employee was present, however, and not only did they agree to let us drop the piece off to have it repaired but they also sent it to my home when finished! For Christmas this year, my husband surprised me with matching pearl necklaces for me and for our newborn baby girl. They are gorgeous pieces for us to treasure. I will definitely be a return customer at Lindy's for life. read more

Your store has a beautiful selection of jewelry. I could shop all day. Lovely, lovely, lovely. It is probably good that I do not live close. I may shop online as the gal mentioned they could ship to me. Thanks so much! read more

Jordan is the best! If you need help, suggestions or any other type of service while browsing in this fabulous jewelry store then ask for Jordan! Lindy's is a fantastic hidden " gem" in downtown Fernandina. read more

Great selection of estate, artisan and fine jewelry. . My sister and I have been going to Lindy's for years. Lindy and her staff are always accommodating. They patiently help out with decisions, They stand by their top notch repairs. Lindy's is truly the Crown Jewel of my town. read more

Lindy's is a fabulous store. Every piece is unique. The owner is extremely talented.

My wife and I just had an amazing experience at Lindy's. We recently travelled back to Amelia for the winter. My wife packed 5-6 of her necklaces for the trip. They all had magnet clasps and when we arrived they were all tangled up. She spent a half of day trying to untangle without any success. So, I spent another day trying my hand but only made the situation worse. We asked a friend for a recommendation on a good jeweler on the Island and they recommended Lindy's. While it took them a little time they amazingly got the job done. All the staff were interested in helping in the task. When we tried to pay they refused and said just shop here when you need something. Well, I was blown away and we will be shopping there this holiday season. Great customer service is alive and well at Lindy's! read more

recently stopped in this store purely on a referral basis. though I really enjoyed the selection of items available, I can honestly say that the customer service there left something to be desired. and that includes the owner who happened to be there the 2nd time we came in hoping for some customer service. It's unfortunate that the owner is clearly grooming her help based upon appearances. Extremely judgey and totally snubbed us and others who were in the store. My husband made it very clear to me when he said "Remember Pretty Woman? this store has the "Pretty Woman" syndrome on steroids. Big mistake. BIG. we won't be back. read more

April 2020 update: I found this exact same ring on overstock.com for $46! Shame on you Lindy for selling this for over $220 in your store. While you gave me a discount bc it was my anniversary it still wouldn't have cost you hardly anything to replace it for me when it broke. You truly are a fraud. read more

Having this knowledgeable and trust worthy jeweler in Fernandina on Centre Street is a huge plus to our town.

My wife always likes jewelry that I get her from Lindy's. I walk in with a budget, and I never leave unsatisfied. They've never let me down!

When I went to Lindy's the first time, I was impressed with the quality of their items as well as their customer service, however, since I have learned they do not stand behind their product. My mom got me a silver necklace on a very delicate chain for Christmas. Within 3 months, the chain snapped. When I called Lindy's to see if I could send the chain back for fixing (I live in another state), Jordan, the sales person I spoke to was rude and unaccommodating. She explained that the chain was only 'worth $20' and blamed me for the break because it 'obviously pulled on something' (I had it around my neck when it broke, so not sure what it pulled on other than my hair). She said I should just take it to a jeweler near me because it wasn't worth me sending it in. I told her that I assumed she would want to stand behind her product so it shouldn't matter if it is $20 or $100, they should fix it! Then she proceeded to say if it meant losing me as a customer, I should send it in. I was taken aback by her rude tone as well as the comments she was making. They have now not only lost me, but also everyone I tell about my experience as a customer! read more

I went to Amelia Island on vacation recently and walked by Lindy's several times before I finally I gave in and went inside. I ended up purchasing two BEAUFTIL and good quality pieces for a very reasonable price. I highly recommend this store to any locals and /or tourists in the area; it's a must-see for jewelry lovers! read more

Fabulous service - although this store features high-end items, the staff is refreshingly down-to-earth and kind. Don't miss a trip here when in Fernandina Beach! read more

great store and great service. lindy's has many "one of a kind" pieces and have customized jewelry for me. i love lindy's!!! so thankful to have them local for my gift giving needs. read more