First, it seems that most of the reviewers here don't mention anything about how long they trained their dog with Joe Rosen (JR). This point is quiet important, you shouldn't be expecting your dog to be a well behaved one, or even trying to rate a trainer, in only a few classes (it's irresponsible and unfair). My 2 years old boxer (Hugo) and I are students at JR's school for over 3 months...and every week I see significant change in him; and I keep bringing him to JR's class not because I see degradation in his behavior but because I want to be completely stress free when I take him for a walk.
So, to put you in perspective, Hugo...is a boxer, lots of energy which seems to translate in a very volatile behavior: (i) very crazy playful to, what it used to be, (ii) very aggressive (towards new dogs). My wife and I, at one point, we counted the number of "dog-friends" he had and it turned out to be around 20...but every time he saw new dogs he would, sincerely, loose it and would charge at them. Also, every time people or DOGS walked in front of our place he would bark none stop until they were out of sight (mind you, he's a big teddy bear with children and strangers). And, on his walk, every time he saw someone walking towards us, he would pull towards them (did not show signs of aggressivity) but, honestly, people would get scared (I completely understand them). So, we were in a very delicate situation, I would be stressed coming from work thinking of where can I take my dog for a walk without any sort of complications...and, man, did I not want to leave Hugo excluded from society...things would have certainly got a lot worse. So, at one point we thought of giving him away (which hurt me so much, we are so attached to him and he trusts us with his life, extremely loyal) but who would have taken him anyway? And one last thing, as soon as we got Hugo at 7 weeks old, we called a trainer who only believes in positive reinforcement. This guy, honestly, also did a great job. But at one point, with Hugo's impulsivity and power and with his desire to become head of the pact (it would seem), we had to think like a parent and start to put him in his rightful position.
If at this point, your dog's behavior does not match Hugo's, don't worry, JR dealt with all sorts of dogs (ex: simple puppies and dogs that are unfriendly to: children, cyclists, skateborders, pedestrians, cars...and dogs ;) ) . Joe believes so much in his capabilities that he would assess the situation before hand, and he would then fixe the price; if however you need more classes or you want more classes, he would not charge you a penny more (unless you want a different type of training; ex: guard dog)!
Now, the one point that seems recurrent in the reviews relates to his methods. One thing that I have to tell you is that the people who quit his class before the end of their corresponding program, will tell you mostly inaccurate things on JR: that he hates dogs and that he apparently insults his clients! First, I have to tell you, for those who don't know, the dogs are rarely the ones to be blamed on for their bad behavior, so you should also be expected to receive some adequate education from any trainer, including JR. So, during your first classes with JR, you should expect a more conservative approach, where he will quickly tell you when to: make you dog sit, when to start walking with him, make him sit again, walk, sit, etc. And if the dog does not listen or if you don't correct your dog accordingly, Joe will intervene. And when he intervenes and if you mistakenly generalise his methods on the inaccurate reviews here, you'll think that Joe does not train dogs properly and you'll think that he insults you...but after some time in his class I came to realise that he is very direct in his comments because he simply does not want your corrections to be repeated unnecessarily. Yes, as taboo as it seems nowadays, we use such things as the choker in his class, BUT trainers like Joe, teach us how to properly use the choke so that dogs are not harm by it (as opposed to the other reviewer who probably did not stay long enough in the class) and if used properly only the sound of the chain does the job...no need to choke him at all!
At first, I was very worried about using other techniques than positive reinforcements, believing the possibility that Hugo would get even worse than his initial situation. HA! now, after 3 months in JR's class, Hugo not only walks by me with no leash when other dogs are around (see, don't need the choke anymore) but, so far, he made 5 new dog friends (something I would never have imagined)! I even get compliments on his behavior, and I have seen so far no unexpected bad behavior coming from him. In a few words, JR has fixed every problem I mentioned and thanks to him, I avoided doing something extremely regretful: abandoning him! read more