A dining experience with a flashback to the 50s and 60s. Very good food. Very good portions. Very good location. read more

Had a birthday coupon so decided to stop in got a malt and a grilled chicken sandwich. The malt had ice crystals kid is like ice cream that has defrosted a little and refrozen does. The chicken was not grilled put steamed giving it a wet appearance not really appealing and they did not use salt. The salad I had as the side was ok nothing to make me go mmmm. Julia was really nice but a little bit underwater poor thing. read more

I have ate at this establishment 4 times since living in Casper; gotten sick each time, it has to be something that they're using to cook their food in. Probably a very low quality cooking oil. read more

Awesome home baked pies of all sorts. Fresh hot coffee. Lot of great 60's menu items. Just stopped in for some Apple pie ala mode and some coffee after driving from Colorado Springs. Heated pie, cold ice cream, hot and fresh coffee. Ahhh!!!! Music is playing from the 60's, people enjoying their burgers, fries, Nathan dogs, pies, Elvis burger, shakes and malts galore, etc. Wow! Wish I had more room to eat more. Had to take some Strawberry Rhubarb pie back to the hotel for my wife. We'll stop in on the way back from Montana. Yikes!!! Love it. Life is good. read more

See all

A good start, but a miserable finish to this meal. This was a random stop before a long drive to another city in Wyoming. The pot roast was raved about by the waitress/salesperson and that is usually a safe choice at a diner. The meat did not look like pot roast, but the first four strips were tender and very tasty and semi melt in mouth. The last two big pieces of meat though were inedible, fatty, tough and downright "how could you put that on a plate and serve it" The mashed potatoes were lumpy in a bad sort of way and the carrots and celery that came with the dish did not seem to have been cooked with that pot roast. The vanilla coke had no vanilla taste and ya know this diner food is probably good enough for the boring people of Casper's palette's, but anybody from the other 49 states should keep on driving past this divey diner. read more

Johnny J's Diner - Pot roast, skip - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

This is a super cute 50s style dinner with great food. We had chicken green chili omelet, chocolate chip pancakes, breakfast sampler platter, and biscuits and gravy. And they had real old fashion cherry and vanilla coke! They serve breakfast, lunch, desserts, and milk shakes. It is about a mile from down town but still an easy find and worth the effort. The staff was friendly and given the steady stream of customers this seems like a local favorite. read more

See all

Had lunch here was good food good for price satisfied with service I would recommend this is a good place to eat

It was ok.... burger was pretty dry and service was so-so. I'm sure there are better options to find an awesome burger. Will give it props for the decor though read more

We found this place on 4th of July. It was one of only a few places open. We had GREAT service and good food. Our food came out a little on the cold side, which was strange as it seemed very fast. But it was delicious. We both had biscuits and gravy with eggs and potatoes. My potatoes were a little underdone, but it was probably the beat biscuit I've had. Fluffy and flaky, yum. We also had a hot and fresh pecan roll straight from the oven. Our service was fantastic. I really think the milkshakes here are where it's at though. I didn't have one but several other tables did and they were huge and looked super tasty. read more

See all

Great place to eat. Looks like it popular (there was 15 minutes wait to be seated). Service was quick and food was very good. read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

Doing well under Miss Pat's leadership, but have found even in the best well-oiled machine, an occasional item slips up. Found the breakfasts are still great, the Cobb salad a delight, but cannot recommend the fried chicken--tough and way over cooked. Will continue my patronage as there are still great items on the menu as exemplified by the huge crowds still there at eight o'clock at night! read more

Friendly service! Lots of great stories about this diner. Shakes are awesome! Any 3 flavors for under $5. Onion rings are tasty. Reason for 3 stars- lots of flies everywhere. Guacamole tastes packaged and not fresh. Hamburger buns are too bready and thick-taste story bought and takes away from the taste of the meat. read more

Easy to navigate to from I-25. Good burgers, really friendly service The atmosphere is fun and acoustics are good. The shakes and pies looked delicious. read more

I love this place . My daughter and I stopped in while we were on a road trip and the whole experience was fantastic . The atmosphere is super fun , the staff was all incredibly friendly and the food was all delicious . read more

Every single thing about my experience at Johnny J's was memorable. The decor was authentically diner decor, which I appreciate as someone who grew up going to diners. The food. Oh my god. The food was so good. I had chicken-fried chicken, with mashed potatoes and fried okra, and I could not have been happier with my meal! And the oreo milkshake was simply out. of. this. world. But really, truly, the thing you'll find at Johnny J's that's so special, and why it really merits a detour, (and a thus-far nonexistent sixth star) was the service. The place was run well, which is nice and all, but truthfully, the whole staff was delightful, kind, inviting, and thoughtful. I interacted most with two servers named Shannon and Cassidy. They were both fantastic as people and incredible as servers. There is a sweetness, and a love that clearly emanates from this fantastic diner. And while it's true, that the food is very good (very, very good), it is the incredible service here that makes it so memorable. If you are in Casper, you MUST go to Johnny J's. And if you aren't, start hauling ass and get there, because you have no idea what you're missing. read more

This is a very busy place for lunch. Took a good 15 minutes to get seated. Servers were fast and friendly so I'd give this place a 3.5. I had the burger with green chili. The burger was a bit dry for my taste and the green chili really didn't have any flavor. Granted I like spicy green chili. The French dip was very good and the onion rings were amazing. We also had a malt and that was good as well. I moved my rating to 4 stars because of the malt. Lol read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

This place is hit and miss, they will bring your order fast but the food itself is subpar (below my standards). If you're sat by an elderly woman than your service will most likely be bad. Manager that's been working there her whole life is loosing her touch. I think it might be time for new oversight. read more

Service is usually pretty good. Most of the menu is good for breakfast. You can't beat the $5.99 breakfast special. Lunch and dinner is ok, but not as good as their breakfast food. Expect to wait to get in on Saturday and Sunday mornings as they can get busy. If you like 50 diner decor, this is your place. read more

See all

We had great service and great breakfast at Johnny J's. We were a relatively large group and the host bent over backwards to get us seated quickly. Our waitress was also first rate, and the food outstanding. Loved it! read more

Chicken leg of a meal smelled spoiled? Vanilla milkshake average. Fried okra 3 star. Atmosphere makes this place. Friendly waitstaff. read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

Friendly waitstaff. The owner thanked us for coming in. The cherry pie and shakes were very good.

50's inspired dinner with amazing customer service, out server Jessica was super nice. The food is tasty! I would recommend this place! read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

See all

All new barstools. Johnny Js This place has always been fantastic. Im so happy Ill be able to find a seat on those busy Sunday mornings when Im all by myself. read more

Great diner with even better service. Brittany was awesome and made sure I was taking care of while I worked off their free WiFi. Absolutely would come back. Nice, friendly and good prices read more

The staff seemed overworked. The service was slow. The meatloaf was well done and dry. The Elvis burger was lackluster. Maybe we caught them on a bad day read more

This place was so fun. Our waitress, Shauna, was great! Food was yummy and the coconut cream pie was soooo good. I would definitely come back! read more

Food is so great here. Tanner is an awesome server. He always recommends something good. He remembered me and my wife after only coming in a couple times. Go see tanner at the counter. read more

I love the waitresses here they are so sweet especially Kelli. I love going on Sundays and having the turkey dinner special. It's typically crowded but that's because the food is so good read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

Great place to go for a good milkshake and a cheeseburger! Also got a huge pecan roll to go and it was wonderful. We will definitely be going back to this diner Great atmosphere , great customer service and good food read more

Really had a great time at this traditional 50s style diner! The staff was amazingly hospitable, and made us feel more welcomed than we have at any restaurant, ever. It was as though we were regulars instead of out-of-town travellers. We got there just after 5pm, and it was packed within a half hour - glad we got there early! Our food was delicious, and what a lot of choices. A cool selection of burgers, and sandwiches that you rarely see in restaurants these days. I wish I could come in every day to sample a new meal. They have the well-deserved reputation for the best milkshakes in Wyoming - we had the mint chocolate chip. And thanks to Gabby for the topnotch service! read more

I figured I've give them another chance....you know the old saying fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me? I should have heeded the old saying. Ordered the ham and 3 cheese skillet. It is a mixture of sliced fried potatoes that we're either crunchy or raw. It had set waiting for the two eggs so long that the melted cheese was hard as a rock and required a knife to cut it Two strikes and you are out. I won't be back. read more

My family and I went here once and it was horrible, I would never come back again! Service was awful! I asked for a box to go and they lady just tipped everything over into the box and handed me 4 boxes with no bag , I looked at her and said excuse me can I please have a bag? She rolled her eyes and handed me one bag for four boxes. read more

I love this place. Ive had dinners and lunches here. Everytime I feel like its a home cooked meals. Pot roast, meatloaf and burgers is what ive had. Each have been great, along with their awesome pies and shakes! read more

Johnny J's Diner - American Near Me - Casper, Wyoming

Location and atmosphere are fantastic. The menu is somewhat surprising in that they have more than the typical burgers and milk shakes that you'd expect at a 50's style dinner. The chicken parmesan for example is quite good. As for they rest of the food, I've never had a bad meal here. It's all good as far as I can tell. It's often very busy, especially for breakfast. Service is usually pretty good but for some reason every time I've ordered a malt or a shake, it takes forever. I don't know what the deal is with that. read more

I was looking forward to eating here, when I saw the building. I first ordered the combination player and substituted the mushrooms for more jalapeño poppers. We never received it and the waiter had no answers. I ordered the chicken fried chicken with mashed potatoes and fried okra. The potatoes were cold, the okra was soggy and the chicken was more like over battered fried chicken. Then we ordered dessert and you guessed it, waiter got that wrong too!!! Good luck if you choose to eat here. Was not impressed from the moment the table that sat down after us 10 mins later got their appetizer. I was going to give it 2 stars until the dessert came out wrong too!!! read more

Pretty good breakfast good price. Veggie omelet with hash browns. Had too much cheese. But other than that it was good. Liked the cofee. Friendly service. read more

Casual, friendly and fun break from the road. The excellent food seems to keep locals on hand, or is it the amazingly friendly customer service? Or the unique, fun, environment and music driven atmosphere? read more

See all

This place really does have the best milkshakes. It is so cute too. A real throwback to a 50's diner. Lots of variety on the menu. Prices are reasonable. Good soup. Lots of locals so you know the food is good. Stopped here on the way to Buffalo. Definitely worth stopping for. Good service too. read more

You earned it the chicken fried steak was bomb. Bomb is great. This was a great surprise thanks yelp community I'm here for the day from billings. The green beans I don't do healthy I got a extra dish man that was beyond good. Then pie time had the peach. Tasted like a fresh picked not sweet it was fantastic. The crust super flakey. . Pie lady adopt me please ... manager she was great came over and made us feel like she knew is forever she id's a class act. Oh yeah real freaking mashed tatters. Casper your so lucky. If you don't like this place move so those of us who know quality can move in read more

Good diner food and a cute atmosphere! Friendly staff. They have great pie and huge cinnamon rolls/caramel pecan rolls. Good shakes and malts too read more