Elizabeth is one of those restaurants where I had a very good experience but am in no rush to go back.
The Great:
-The atmosphere, saturated by red, is stunning. I always prefer bar seating and that's the predominant option. This is a restaurant meant for parties of 1-3, which I love.
-If I've ever had better halibut, I can't remember where. The Flétan en Papillote was impeccable. Stuffed with clams and smothered with an impossibly rich sauce, I'm still dreaming of this dish. The portion size is fine too.
-The Souffle gets raves, and they are well deserved. I've had very few souffle experiences in my life but this is the best. A huge portion of rich custard and pistachio ice cream that you won't want to share.
-Our bartender (who is also an actress) was exceptionally excellent.
The Not-So-Great:
-When you price your restaurant in the same range as Scales, I'd much rather go to Scales. There's just better places in this price range, for both food and drinks. There's one glass of wine that is $13 and the rest are $14-$18. Cocktails are the same price, and are ok, but there's numerous better spots. A $230 all-in dinner for two can be had at many Old Port restaurants and I don't think Elizabeth is one of the very best. Also, the online menu prices are not accurate. That amazing Halibut was $44.
-Not everything on the menu is a winner. The Cigarettes et Caviar was just a few bites for $27. It was mostly tasteless. The steak tartare was not one of the better versions I've had. Woodford F&B for instance, does it much better.
Elizabeth is a good restaurant and deserving of the 4 stars. But they've priced themselves to compete with the best, and I'm not confident they are there yet. Still, if you're craving French food I'd recommend. read more