My husband went in for pizza and wings today. Once he got home, he opened the box to see his wings were looked extremely over done. So he called to see if they could fix the wings for him. However, the lady over the phone was a bit rude with her response and at first didn't want to redo the wings to which she replied "they come out like that because they cook them 3 times" after having a exchange of words she agreed to remake them. I decided to leave a review not only because the wings were over done, but mainly because it was more her attitude. She wasn't attentive or showed any positive customer service. read more

Double Play Pizza - Wings... - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

It was a delicious dinner for myself and kids had the cheese and a pepperoni pizza. Both were cooked perfectly and nice and toasty how I liked it would definitely recommend read more

Amazing service! The pizza tastes so amazing, reminds of the old school shakeys pizza. The crust is soft and the cheese has a nice pull. The owner is so kind, this is the best lunch special in La Puente. read more

Double Play Pizza - Our lunch specials enjoyed at La Puente Park - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

It's very convenient, the owner is very friendly and the food is great, the place looks clean and in good condition.

Great mom and pop pizza shop. Pizza tastes great and the wings are always juicy. I recommend getting one of their take out specials for a good amount of food at a great cost. read more

This is definitely a hole in the wall! Came here for lunch and they had a great pizza deal. I got a small pizza for $6 that included a free drink as well. The pizza consists of 6 slices with 1 free topping and each additional topping is $1 extra. For the price and size of the pizza, the small will definitely fill you up. But if not, getting the medium for a few bucks more will def be good for 1 person. I love how they make the pizza right when you order so you get it hot with fresh ingredients and long cheese pulls! You can't beat the price, I will def be back for a hot sub! read more

See all

The owners are always nice. They provide the price over the phone. Pick up and are both available. They have many specials. I can tell you, two large pizzas are the prices of one at one of the big named shops. The pizza is good. Highly recommend and I always return read more

Great quality food at an amazing price. Owners are super friendly and inviting. Would recommend checking this place out.

The service is quick, and the pizza is good literally our go to spot from now on . Plus, it is super close to home so that helps a lot.

Double Play Pizza is a great spot if you're looking for good, affordable food. Their lunch specials are hard to beat, especially the calzones. The portions are huge--perfect for having lunch and saving the other half for dinner. They're always quick and Speedy but do recommend that you pick up as no real dining area inside as it's very small with only about one table. So definitely a to-go place. One of the best deals is the two-topping calzone for just $5.99. You really can't find a better price for the quality and quantity anywhere else right now. If you're in the area, I highly recommend stopping by. read more

I've been coming here for as long as I can remember, and the pizza, wings, quality, and prices still never cease to amaze me! My go to order is always their 2 large pizza carry out special for my family of 4 (adults). Comes with a free 2 liter soda and I always add an extra topping to both. This is enough food for 2 days for us and is about $25. Thats a STEAL! Their spicy oven baked wings are so tender and good. And if you ever come for lunch, I highly recommend the calzone special!! It's huge and the price is even better. This business is a small place in downtown La Puente for carry out and delivery orders only. I will continue to support this amazing small business for as long as it's here. The owners are always there. They're kind and always provide fast and friendly service! I saw them handing out free cheese sticks to kids on Halloween one year, which I thought was so awesome!! Support your local businesses. read more

Double Play Pizza - Menu as of 8/28/25 - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

See all

So good. Their Pizzas are made to order. Always fresh and yummy. They open at 1030 during the week which is awesome since not many places open that early for lunch. They've been around for over a decade and I visit them whenever I'm craving pizza. This is definitely a hidden gem around the area. $5.50 for a small pizza with one topping and a can of Coke. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I told myself I'd just have one slice... now I'm sitting here with an empty box and zero regrets This pizza is dangerous in the best way possible. read more

Had to feed a crowd last minute and didn't want to serve "fast food" pizza. They did not disappoint! Great quality at a good price. They still got five stars even though the website was too cumbersome to figure out. Called in and got great service. Food was great service was great! read more

I've been coming to Double Play Pizza for years now and never get tired of it. 10/10 - highly recommend

We brought chicken wings and they were burnt and the owner didn't wanna make me new ones or give me a refund I hope they get the place taken down read more

Double Play Pizza - Chicken Salad - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

I've been told by several people this is "The Best" Pizza in La Puente so I had to give them a try, it's a small place looks to be carry out or Delivery Only, they offer many different Specials, I got 2 Large 2 topping pizzas and a 2-liter soda for under $20. First impression the Large pizza's look more like Medium, they don't skimp on the toppings, pizza's look very good, my only real issue was crust, the dough felt more bread like, that part bothered me but to some it might not be a big deal. If you ask me Double Play is similar to your Fast Food chain Pizza places and NOT your good restaurant pizza, 5-Star Value, if not for the bread like crust probably a 4-Star Pizza, but for me it's just OK. 3-Stars OH, and far from the best Pizza in La Puente! Large Ham & Pineapple https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/double-play-pizza-la-puente?select=lpb-kEmHHDvKqv4PKemnlQ https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/double-play-pizza-la-puente?select=Q_IigvmR1AnQcWKkmFBOIA Large Sausage & Jalapeno https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/double-play-pizza-la-puente?select=m9qFQ6XCuMK3x9OOfdMIkg https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/double-play-pizza-la-puente?select=iRDh834HCCnChXzwsSmDiw read more

See all

Friendly, fast and great pizza & prices. Called i order after work and picked up on the way home.

Their pizza is so delicious and fluffy, especially when you get it with extra cheese and their customer service is very nice

Time arrived : 12:30pm on a Friday for lunch Crowd: none Service: great! The person who took my order was super friendly and was patient as I was trying to decide as it was my first time here. Everyone I saw there was wearing masks Parking: plenty of parking as this is within a neighborhood and across a school and close to a town hall so not a lot of traffic Food order : small pizza with two toppings, bread sticks lunch special Overall the pizza was pretty good. Toppings were a good spread and amount. Bread sticks were a little harder than I expected. It might have been the pizza crust dough used and cut into pieces ? The crust on the pizza wasn't my favorite but this only because I'm used to a different kind of crust on my pizza. Idk . it was kind of flat and not as risen and crispy as I was used to. But take this with a grain of salt as I haven't had a small business pizza in quite some time and I was born and raised in NYC. The prices for lunch specials were alright. It was $13~ for small pizza (6 slices/10" diameter?) and bread sticks. Got two meals out of it. Will go back again. Hope this helps :) read more

AMAZING... Everything we have ordered has been GREAT. You know it's good when you order and everyone asks where is this from. The food is just amazing. Pizza...the sauce is great, the crust is tasty, the cheese is cheesy. Wings, meaty and tasty. The prices...very good, especially because it's two for one. The packaging...done well. It's good, yes it's good...order it, don't hesitate. read more

Hole in the wall but super good pizza joint super close to my bfs house. Worth the try! Good prices, tasty, and fast service. read more

Double Play Pizza - Large mushroom and olive pizza for only $9.70! - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

Been coming here for over 15 years no disappoints good prices good portions. Calzones are . I recommend to order ahead, no wait time

Every time I've been here within the past 5 years, I've had a bad experience. Today I took one bite and had to pull a hair from my mouth that was stuck in the cheese. This does it for me. This place is disgusting. Do not waste your time or money here. You're better off going to little Caesar's. read more

Double Play Pizza - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

Cheep pizza and friendly staff. Pizza made fresh so you should call ahead for pick up if you want to avoid a 15-ish minute wait.

This is a family owned pizza shop. We have been ordering from Double Play since I was in high school (early 2000's). Always great service, fresh ingredients and the kindest staff! read more

First time order, very pleasant experience. Friendly, personable owner, really seem to care about the quality of food. Delivery guy is very nice and personable too, gives the vibe of your friendly courteous neighbors. Owner says they don't do Yelp or UbberEats delivery because the drivers don't get paid much, and he wants to treat his employees well. Final bill via credit card is $20.20+tips for 2 medium pizzas with 2 toppings and one 2 liter soda. Free delivery. Pretty good deal. $0.50 transaction fee for using a credit card to pay. Dough is soft like bread, unlike the hard, oily crust from typical chain pizza places. Definitely taste the quality difference. 10 year old boy ate 4 slices, including the edges! He says it's way better than Pizza Hut. Love the pepperoni and sausage toppings. 8 year old small skinny girl ate 3 slices. She says she doesn't like the taste of the pepperoni. But she does like the dough. Main dissatisfaction is she wanted corn, but it was not a topping option. "Comfortable" taste is what conjured in my mind with each bite. 100% real cheese, original dough, natural tasting pepperoni. I'd definitely order again from here rather than from a chain delivery pizza company. I'm a thin-crust kind of person. If they serve thin-crust, I'll definitely bump it up a star. read more

Double Play Pizza - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

See all

I went here with a group of people for lunch. I got the pepperoni onion calzone lunch special. A lot of the people in the group had the 1 small pizza with a beverage and one person had chicken fingers. The food was pretty good. I think that the calzone needed more crunchy texture. read more

My Friday spot Thin crust is where it's at, the cheese is stringy and the sauce is on point. Can't beat their deals either. Highly recommend read more

Double Play Pizza - Thin crust, cheese is stringy. Can't wait for pizza Fridays from here. Two thumbs up - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

I've been coming to double play for 20 years and it's the best home town pizza in La Puente

4 out of 5 because : Good: The calzone is not just very affordable but it's delicious and very filling! It's my favorite in town. The pizza is also a hit! Bad: The chicken wings have a bad flavor to them they aren't the best quality and quite rubbery. The sausage ingredient used for pizzas & calzones is not the best either I do not recommend it to my worst enemy. So beware of the wings & avoid Sausage on your pizza's read more

The Double play calzones are just next level. The only pizza spot that I will go to for now on! Highly highly recommend!

I like how fast the service is and I enjoy getting 2 pizzas every time! Delivery is a must .

Best damn pizza place in La Puente and if you think otherwise, re-evaluate. It's a staple of La Puente and should be a landmark if it isn't already! I love stopping by here and supporting my favorite pizza store when I'm back in my hometown. This place has been a constant in my childhood and the pizza tastes the same all these years later. 10/10 eat it fresh & get the wings! read more

I am a big fan of this place. It's been here for as long as I can remember and quality hasn't changed in my eyes. My absolute favorite item is their calzones. Now I haven't had one for quite some time until today. I was on my way home from work so as usual for pick up orders I called about 20 minutes ahead. The nice lady on the phone took my order, gave me the price, and estimated 15 minutes. I arrived a little more than 20 minutes later and of course my order was ready. A cheese and pepperoni calzone along with the small Chef's salad. Both items came out to a little over $10. Not a bad price in my book. Parking was easily accessible. I was concerned about parking due to the weekly farmers market that is along the main street on Friday's, but to my surpise it didn't affect the lot. Before writing my review, I noticed quite a few Yelpers having issues with Double Play not delivering to their area. It is unfortunate however if we're able to go out and grab a burger or chinese, I don't see the problem with picking up pizza? Just accept their routes have possibly changed and move on. Overall I think it's a great local place to La Puente. It's been there for years and hasn't changed nor closed. So I think it's a safe bet for you to give them a try. read more

Double Play Pizza - Cheese and Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - La Puente, California

See all

Been coming here for 12 years and it's always so good. I don't like that once it isn't as hot the cheese kind of hardens, but over all the flavor of the pizza and wings so good. read more

Best calzones in the area. Great service and flavorful food. Never have to wait long to pay. Place is clean.

Love the pizza from this place!! The owners are friendly and welcoming. I always enjoy my pepperoni, pineapple, and jalapeño pizza. The crust is perfect and the amount of tomato sauce on it is perfect!! read more

Ever since I was very young my parents would buy us this pizza. The pizzas there are very cheesy and tasty! My daughters and I love this place better than other "high quality" pizza! Prices are reasonable too! Also about the owner, very friendly guy, always happy and with a great attitude. read more

Just ordered today for the very first time and am incredibly impressed by the quality of their food. The pizzas are all made to order and will adjust any toppings/amount of cheese to your liking. We ordered a calzone, as well, and they make those custom order with the perfect amount of filling! So so good and fresh. All the toppings were also good quality and fresh. The prices are AMAZING and the staff are extremely nice. Really enjoy this hidden gem. Will be returning!! read more