Solid local deli. They have your standard set of lunch and breakfast sandwiches along with all the other usual deli goodies. Definitely worth checking out! read more

I love some of your items. I am truly addicted to your Southwest chicken salad. I am disappointed that you are again closed on Sundays. I seem to remember, but I may be wrong, that you were closed on Sundays a while back. Correct me iif I'm wrong. But it would be nice if you we're open on Sundays just until 11 AM. Your customers enjoy your breakfasts. Thank you, Mary Y Todero read more

I should have the read reviews before going here! I haven't ordered a deli sandwich in a long time and was feeling like a turkey sandwich today so I ordered online to pick up at lunchtime. I ordered turkey on a wrap with American cheese, lettuce tomato and onion. When I sat down and unwrapped it, disappointed would be quite the understatement! I think there was a piece of turkey (maybe two) and a piece of cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion for $18 ........and the pickle was almost as big as than the sandwich! read more

Deli 51 - Turkey/american wrap with lettuce, tomato, onion and honey mustard. - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

PISSED OFF!!!!!! It's been awhile but I stopped in for lunch. $18+ for a wrap!? #23 Christmas Salad with Grilled Chicken - Spinach. Onion. Blue cheese crumbles. Glazed pecans. Sliced almonds. Dried cranberry's. Balsamic dressing with grilled Chicken Would've been a BIG salad!! Should've stayed with the salad bc this wrap is PATHETIC!! Come on guys!! DO BETTER!!! Rip off is an understatement. I'm STARVING! I ate the wrap and then stopped at Buffalo Grille next door!!! Unreal!!! read more

Deli 51 - a person holding a sandwich in a plastic container - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Great deli great people. Never been disappointed in any sandwich it salad. Keep doing what you Guys do!!!

Wife wasn't feeling well and just wanted a simple Turkey Sandwich. We don't like Greenlawn Deli for a multitude of reasons even though it is closer. We really don't even frequent deli's anymore bc of terrible experiences in the past unless we have too. We now mostly cook breakfast at home... Anyone place was CLEAN and everything looked fresh! They were busy as workers were making to go orders I assume bc I didn't see anyone else standing. An older gentleman took my order and they made my food. I got home and wife was disappointed bc it seemed like they didn't clean the knife and cut it with a knife that had ketchup on it. So I got back in the car and went back. Guy who took my order said that I said to add ketchup. Hey you never know...so close to an egg sandwich order. I believe as long as the human element is attached mistakes will be made as no one is perfect. Small businesses...every dollar counts. Guy apologized took my order and made another Sandwhich. While I was in there a girl came in with her order and I shit you not..."I don't know what I was thinking when I placed my order, can I exchange it and get a Sandwhich". In reality she made this mistake why should they pay? Plus we just had my order...guy took it back...tossed it in the garbage (which he should) and made her what she wanted at no charge. We will be back for a bigger order to reward him for his customer service and good Sandwhich. People complaining about prices...my order was $13.53 and we paid in cash. Priceless...happy wife...happy life AND OF COURSE ITS ALWAYS CHEAPER IF YOU MAKE IT YOURSELF read more

Deli 51 - Display Case....CLEAN AND FRESH - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Don't order hero's or sandwiches here. It's robbery. The pickle is more filling. I ordered a hot Italian it came with 3 slices of meat all lettuce/tomato and salad dressing. Crooks here... $16 for 3 slices of deli meat and bread FOH. Never again. read more

Deli 51 - No meat. This "Italian" is a SALAD SANDWICH! - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Overpriced. Sandwich had very little meat compared other delis in area. Will not be going back. Place has taken a turn quality wise since new ownership. read more

Deli 51 - Italian sandwich. Barely any meat, mostly lettuce and onions. 12.50. - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Been going here for a while and it was great a couple years ago but I don't know if it changed ownership or something. Never going back, way too over priced. Egg sandwich was $15 and they didn't even get it right. When the cook came over, he was immediately offended but I had just asked nicely if it was the right sandwich because I had just paid $15. Stinks because I really liked this deli, but it's definitely clipped now. Avoid this place, and avoid their ridiculous prices. read more

I'm a contractor and I frequent this deli whenever I'm working close by because the food used to be excellent. I went in there today and ordered two Philly cheesesteak sandwiches that used to be made from real cubes of steak cooked on the grill they charged me three dollars extra to add peppers which they hardly put any on. I got a cup of coffee and a bottle of water along with my order and it came out to close to $40. When I got back to the job and sat down to eat my lunch, I opened the sandwich, and it was made from some really low grade steakum kind of meat. There was hardly any on the sandwich It was mostly bread and the steak had a horrible aftertaste that was so bad I threw most of it away I would never recommend this establishment to anyone, and I most certainly will not be giving them any more of my business! read more

I was blown away this morning by "sticker shock " , I think that's the current phrase when encountering high prices due to inflation ? 2 breakfast sandwiches and 2 drinks came to $27 , I even ( and I never do this ) asked the counter person if he had possibly made a mistake, but another counter person came over and confirmed. SMH read more

My favorite deli around, and I'm fussy when it comes to delis. Great sandwich combos, which they'll make into salad bowls if you like. Tuna salad is really good, and their half and half tea is one of the best. They're quick - at lunchtime it's crowded ( like any good deli) but the line moves fast. I just keep going back read more

Deli 51 is the absolute worst! I went there and ordered 2 egg sandwiches. I got all the way to Syosset to drop my son off and when we opened them they completely messed up the order. So I had to go all the way back to get them fixed. Nobody said sorry, they could care less. And then when I brought my son the new sandwich- he opens it and there was a hair on it! This place is gross, dirty and terrible service. I will never return and you shouldn't either unless you want to be grossed out and disappointed! Look at that hair on the sandwich! The grossest! Deli 51- 51 ways to get a customer pissed and sick! read more

Deli 51 - a hot dog with eggs and sausage - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

I always loved Deli 51 for a great egg sandwich in the morning. Unfortunately since changing ownership the place has suffered for it. Number 1 reason is absentee ownership. The young staff has no guidance. They're on their phones when they could be cleaning. Salad display cases are covered in fingerprints. Salads are not turned over regularly so they have that crusty surface that makes them very unappealing. Just a shame. High prices are one thing. Cleanliness should be priority 1. read more

Horrible customer service. They messed up an Uber Eats order and then blamed it on the driver ( as if she made the wrong egg sandwiches) mistakes are understandable but when I then call to say the order was wrong I was hung up on by Kaylee , called back and Put on hold and then hung up on again and called back to ask for manager and Kaylee advised she would not put manager on and hung up again . Never have dealt with any business that made mistake and flat out refuses to even listen to or make good on wrong order . Don't know how long this deli has been in business but it won't be much longer if this is the way they treat their customers. read more

Wow is all I can say about this place. The owner saw my 2 star review of this place due to their attitude. I just proved it when Joseph left me a curse filled response to the review. Just solidified never going back to this place where they have no idea what hospitality is. Insulting and cursing at their customers is insane. It won't be long until people realize the type of people that run this place. It's a shame people who don't know how to run a business has to resort to caveman tactics. read more

When I first started coming here, I was unsure about what to think because of their prices being higher than average for a long island deli. But I have to say, it's worth the price every time. Their food is delicious and served well. The staff is very nice and helpful. The environment is very clean and well set up. read more

For the price should have had twice as much meat and cheese. They do use Boars Head so that's a star. The competition in Greenlawn and Northport gives you your monies worth not here. One piece of Swiss on a turkey and Swiss come on! Plus only half a pickle cheap! read more

Pluses: Solid deli with decent sized sandwiches. Negatives: Way too overpriced & an odd one.... The ventilation needs to be upgraded somehow.... You walk in there, and don't smell the "usual" deli smell..... and walk out of there smelling like an "unusual" deli scent... and need to wash your cloths before it comes out. read more

This deli used to be so good but now it is understaffed and the food is terrible and totally overpriced. My hash browns were ice cold so I had to go back in and the owner and worker didn't even apologize for the inconvenience. My sandwich was cold too. I am not going back to this place again and I used to go daily. Stop spending money on impressive technology and start serving quality food at an affordable price. read more

I went to this deli for lunch and regretted it. I placed an order for the lunch special with added cheese and a drink. I drove home to find no tomato, lettuce or pickles on my sandwich. To top it off they had NOT cut my sandwich down the middle. I had to drive back to have the included items added to my sandwich and to have it served the correct way. I WILL NOT BE GOING BACK. read more

A great gourmet deli, is phenomenal tasting sandwich and fresh soups. I highly recommend stopping by,

They are over priced. And quality wasn't very good. Ordered an egg sandwich. It was $14. Its an egg sandwich. New owner is price gauging. read more

I literally live about a quarter mile from this deli, and I never go there. I've never had a good experience. Today I actually went there and got God knows white of a sandwich! Not even close to what I ordered. I tell everybody to stay away from this place. read more

Deli 51 is my family's go to place for egg sandwiches on the weekends. It's always packed with people from the neighborhood yet the line moves quickly. Actually getting your egg sandwich takes some time but it's kind of a masterpiece once you get it so the wait doesn't bother us. They have a good selection of bagels, whole wheat options unless they run out. They also offer gluten free wraps, which are super thin but if you have dietary restrictions it's nice to know they have gluten free alternatives available. The egg sandwiches are reasonably priced around $6 or so per sandwich and they load the toppings on; my go to is three egg whites, spinach, sautéed onion, hash browns, hot sauce and pepper, delicious. They have healthy breakfast options consisting egg whites, vegetables and protein, build your own omelettes, various sandwich options both cold and hot, salads behind the counter, pretty much everything you can expect to find at a deli they have. Their coffee is okay, they have flavored options and regular. Their baked goods are always tempting. You're guaranteed to see someone you know in here, guaranteed to wait a bit of time for a sandwich but also guaranteed to be satisfied once you get home because the sandwiches fill you up and are delicious. Careful who you get behind the counter, some gals are a tad bit snippy! read more

Deli 51 - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Beyond disgusted. This is the type of Philly Cheese I'd expect to get at the truck stop in middle America. Disgrace of a sandwich and lack of respect for the customers. New York is pretty damn close to Philly and this deli can't even rip off a classic, poor poor execution. Do better or close the doors. read more

Deli 51 - "Classic Philly Cheesesteak"...in what world does this even resemble a Philly cheesesteak. - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Today was my first day here, but my father has ranted and raved about it for quite some time now, as he lives local and frequents there. I was initially pleasantly surprised with the assortment of food in the display case, and all the snacks offered on the shelves. There wasn't a line so I was helped immediately. I ordered my fathers sandwich but didn't know what kind of bread he wanted it served on. The girl helping me was so understanding when I had to call him to confirm with him. Then it was time for me to order, but I was super indecisive. Again the girl was still kind and helpful, offering suggestions, letting me know cold sandwiches could all be made in salads etc. I decided on a sandwich and then after she put it through, I changed my mind. She was so accommodating and they were able to change my order. My father ordered the no.9 - the landscaper, and I ended up getting a egg salad sandwich. The egg salad was so delicious. I was super surprised. Made just the way I like it. And my father enjoyed his sandwich as well which is his regular go too. The deli pickle on the side of the sandwich was a pleasant surprise (for me at least because I love pickles). I also noticed that there was a interesting selection of cheese spreads with some awesome flavors that I'm eager to try, and saw a sign that the cheese spreads come with a bag of their bagel chips (that I believe are homemade - but not certain) . I see a lot of reviews mention a unfriendly staff, but I can say that I most certainly did not experience that at all. And as far as price, I am a firm believer that you get what you pay for. I paid $24 for the two sandwiches and drinks for both of us, and I found that to be fair for what we got. Thanks for a delicious lunch deli 51 ! read more

Went here today for lunch. Had a chicken cutlet hero with mozzarella, bacon, lettuce and mayo. Sandwich was delicious and the place is extremely clean. They also seem to know how to staff appropriately as there were many people working. Overall a great experience. read more

I reviewed this deli when it reopened as 51 several years ago. Not sure why my review was deleted, but here we go again ... Much better than Greenway down the road. Food is fresh and the eggs are real. Egg sandwiches are the best option here. They are superb. Eggs and breakfast items are conveniently sold all day. Everything is made to order. Sandwiches are excellent. Coffee is hot and fresh. Good selection. Varied types of snacks line the racks and shelves. Staff is very friendly. Family owned. They even do Thanksgiving and Christmas orders. They are a bit pricey on most items, but you definitely get what you pay for. Very clean. The employees are constantly maintaining displays and tidying up their stations. They even stay open late. Parking can be tricky but there is an additional lot behind the building. Convenient location. read more

I admit that I was really nervous to try it after reading that ridiculous review that's on here. Maybe a year ago? But there is two sides to every story and I did not Want to go to Dunkin donuts to get fake food. I am glad I came. It was busy which means people are coming back for a reason so I didnt mind. And the staff seems mindful and on the lookout for customers who come in. I appreciated being noticed very much. The food was well made and the roll I got for my husband looked awesome. It was definitely fresh and not stale =). And I got bacon egg and cheese omlette. I am definitely a bacon snob but I loved the bacon. Cooked crisp and not chewy!! I will keep coming back here. read more

My husband just went to get us breakfast. I ordered an egg scramble with cheddar and diced ham and diced onion. The first time they scrambled the eggs and put the ham, onion and cheese on top of the eggs. They didn't remake either of them. My husband still has green peppers in his after saying twice no-green peppers. They didn't pick them all out after the complaint. All they did was pull most of them out. Mine still is not a scramble and still has the large pieces of ham and onions on top and throughout, but not scrambled in. Who wants sautéed onions on their eggs? Disgusting. This is not the first time, but it's the last! We will never go back. read more

Deli 51 - Delis Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Used to be a go to favorite but now it's way too overpriced. While the food is still delicious, it's not worth like $8 for a bacon egg and cheese.... They still have the best half and half though. Also would NOT recommend ordering anything over the phone! I got two different BECs (that weren't complicated at all... very standard orders) and somehow they screwed both of them entirely.... read more

Great neck ? Dix hills ? Manhasset ? Northport ? LLoyd Neck ? Brookville ? Montauk ? South Hampton ? Manhattan ? Noooooooo ........ GREENLAWN !!! This place is a disgrace & a rip off & a tude to boot. A Standard nothing fancy, 2 Eggs, Ham & Cheese on a roll with a coffee $7.70 / 1 thin slice of ham / 1 thin slice of cheese ........ tiny sandwich. Almost every place juice, tea, coffee, or hot chocolate is included, not here it's an extra $2.00 for a small coffee Greenway Deli 3 blocks down 110 Broadway on the other side is $4.79 / 2 slices ham / 2 slices of cheese & further down 223 Broadway at One Stop deli the same egg sandwich is only $4.00 just about 1/2 price & and a more stacked sandwich. Hungry man hero 4 eggs sausage, ham, bacon, potato, cheese $6.50 with a drink included ! What are these people thinking ??? I don't know, but I wont be returning !!! read more

Just a good local deli, there breakfast sandwiches and corn muffins, and crumb cake that are made in house are good

Honestly not a fan of this place. It used to be great but then they hired new staff and raised prices and I'm sad now. The wait is very long in the morning and an egg sandwich will cost you about 7 beans. Just ordered a salad with chicken it cost $11 and there was no chicken in it. On the other hand it's clean and pretty nice inside. read more

I just had Deli 51 cater an office breakfast. I can't tell you the wonderful comments that I had from everyone. I ordered Western Omelets, Italian Omelets, Bacon, egg & cheese as well as sausage, egg & cheese Omelets. They were all served with home fries and were cooked perfectly. The service is always friendly and orders perfect as ordered. I go there M - F, sometimes ordering as many as 12 egg sandwiches at a time - always prepared as requested. I have recommended this deli to many people and all have the same wonderful experience. Try it....you will love it!!! read more

This place has AMAZING food. Literally one of the best bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches I've ever had. Bagel and cream cheese was super fresh. I will order from this place 1000 times over, especially when in need of a hang over cure. Going to try their lunch items soon for sure. read more

Not a hard order: eggs over medium, with ham and Swiss on a roll. The eggs were over easy - so runny that they were all over the outside of the roll and there was no cheese. The sandwich was inedible. Not going back. There are too many other delis in the area read more

I placed my order through Uber eats & the entire order was incorrect. Whatever they sent was disgusting and tasted horrible.

We have a Lady in the office that buys breakfast from your deli. Every time I have had one of your sandwiches they are always fresh, hot & delicious. She catered a breakfast for the office yesterday & everything was wonderful. Keep up the good work. read more