What can I say that hasn't already been said? It's a historical medieval village that once had 72…read moretowers (now there's 14). Building a taller tower than your neighbor was common in these times. It was a symbol of wealth, status, and power. In some ways, this idealogy is very much like it is today. There's even a pair of twin towers that looks like it may have been the architect's inspiration for the World Trade Center. No one knows for sure. You'll learn about the story of Santa Fina in the chapel at the cathedral. I took a virtual walk through a video guide even before boarding the plane to Italy. It was beautiful! In reality, it turned out to be more of a tourist attraction. Was it a trap? It depends on how much time you are given to explore it. I'll explain later.
My impression wasn't as glamorous as my fellow Yelpers. It all started with the public restrooms. People will tell you that paying a euro to use the restroom is normal in Italy. Only people who are not well-travelled will say this. It's absolutely NOT the norm! The situation in San Gimignano is the worse case scenario. I don't mind paying a human attendant who is maintaining the restrooms. That's never an issue for me. These are machines built to accept money (or credit card if the scanner is working) to gain admission into the restroom using a turnstile. Can you imagine using one of these with a full bladder? The person or organization who decided that it was a good idea to use this demeaning restroom design should be asked one simple question. Would you force your grandmother to do this? I mean, really! It's shameful! I would have been better off squatting over a seatless public toilet. To make matters worse, you'll need to touch the rusted turnstile on your way out after washing your hands. It doesn't move easily. It's unsanitary. I just don't like to touch things like that after the pandemic. I was never infected with Covid, and I was not going to let this germy public bathroom defeat me. Just bring lots of hand sanitizer.
There's a lot of tourist trappy things like the torture museums. Don't waste any time or money on that. They have them in all the little medieval villages in Tuscany.
I just have some advice for anyone booking a guided tour group from Livorno that includes this village and a winery. Be aware that you may have less than an hour to explore it. I recommend having a private guide, your own transportation, or simply staying in a B&B near the village. I would have loved to have more time (at least 4 hours with lunch) in the village versus the winery. Not to take away anything from the winery estate (Tenuta Torciano) because it was awesome. You must try the region's Vernaccia & Chianti wine. It's incredible! Oh, and definitely visit Piazza della Cisterna. You don't want to miss Gelateria Dondoli, and its famous Crema di Sant Fina gelato.