I walked into the restaurant on a Friday night around seven. I liked that the place had a fun college feel to it. The front section was full of people, although there were still some tables available. The waitress asked if we wanted to sit in that area or more towards the back where it was quieter. We chose a table in the back, behind the bar. It was much quieter there, so my daughter and I could actually have a conversation. The service was great and the food was served at a good temperature. I ordered the Impossible burger with everything on it. I substituted a pretzel roll for the brioche and for an up-charge, it certainly wasn't worth it. The pretzel roll was tiny, especially for the size of the burger. The fries tasted great - reminded me of Broadway Fries from back in the day. I also appreciated that the soda came in a huge cup so I didn't need a refill. read more

See all

Honestly, I had low expectations for this restaurant and expected it to be greasy and unappealing. It's got a 50s diner decor and layout and was immaculately clean and new (post storm renovation). The servers were all friendly and on top of things - no issues there. The food wasn't bad at all and I really enjoyed their nachos. The fish tacos and fish sandwich were a hit as well. I wouldn't hesitate to put this on my list of island stops for a quick lunch. Prices were fair too. read more

See all

Great atmosphere Full bar Great shakes (or malts) Small menu Fun burger menu Great place to celebrate a birthday read more

See all

What a cute restaurant! So unique. Loved the round shape with windows everywhere. Cheeseburgers and fish n chips were all good. I think the onion rings with the horseradish dipping sauce was the best part - highly recommend. Pam was an awesome server. Stopped by our table at just the right times and even recommended ordering our milk shakes to go, which was perfect for our 40 minute drive home. Perfect casual Mother's Day dinner with my kids after a day at the beach! read more

What an eclectic combination of themes and great food here! This restaurant has been on Sanibel for decades, and even survived Hurricane Ian (although major renovations were necessary). It's got a 50s diner, old town vibe to it. Burgers, milkshakes, floats, and giant sodas. The food was delicious and plentiful, and the staff were quite friendly and each we talked to had been long-time employees. That says something about a business. If you ever find yourself on Sanibel Island this is a must stop for lunch or early dinner (this and most restaurants on the island close early, even on the weekends) read more

Cheeburger Cheeburger - Burgers Near Me - Sanibel Island, Florida

Wow!! Stopped here after our beach day on Captiva because we were drawn in by the name "cheeburger cheeburger." What does it mean? I still don't know! Anyways, after parking in the spacious strip mall lot, we were greeted by clean retro decor, the kind you want to see in a place known for its burgers and shakes. Our waitress, Pamela, was very informative. She helped guide our decision making on sauces and what servings to get of the fries. A single is good for 2 people! I ordered a classic burger with American cheese, tomato, lettuce, and the signature burger sauce. I thought it was really good! I also had the brownie batter milkshake, also great. The sweet potato fries were even better, especially dipped in the signature burger sauce. The food came out quick, the portions were great, and the proved even better. Everyone was happy with the meal! We even got some entertainment when some patrons nearby embarked on the cheeseburger challenge, but we did not stay long enough to see if they succeeded. But I was rooting for them! read more

See all

Always good to visit Cheeburger Cheeburger. This time we did the challenge . Nice additions to the atmosphere!

Nice place to stop by to enjoy a burger and fries. The shakes looked amazing but didn't try one. The Blackened Grouper sandwich was tasty. Very cool decoration to look at. Our server was excellent and quick. read more

See all

Unfortunately I have not visited this location however when they were in Sarasota that was the place I would drive to just to get a REALLY GOOD BURGER...the ABSOLUTE BEST BURGER! read more

You know I've been coming to this island for years and never stopped by here. Finally had a chance . I sat at the bar just ordered a beer, a burger and some french fries and I was pleasantly surprised. Cheeseburger cheeseburger for the win ! read more

Cheeburger Cheeburger - Burgers Near Me - Sanibel Island, Florida

See all

What could be improved? Well everything other than the decor. Save your money; there are plenty of other options on the island considering the menu prices. They don't ask for your cooking preference, they serve basically medium well undersized patties, oversized buns for the illusion of something bigger. A chocolate malt ordered; served no malt (tried to tell the expediter; but ran off), charged $2.00 any how. The server was nice enough but was non existent. Onion rings just soggy pieces. The best part? Leaving. read more

Cool spot with fun 50s vibe. Cherry malt was so good. Large servings of fries and onion rings

Server thought I shorted the bill. Came to our car and I said may I see it because I am pretty sure I didn't. When she saw the mistake was hers she had a problem with the 5% tip. Well your attitude, service and atmosphere warranted no tip, but I left a few bucks. She actually had the guts to say $3.00 really! Won't EVER be back! You should be fired. read more

Best burgers on the island, good service better quality and reasonable prices. Would recommend

Was stuck in Marriott Sanibel. Was highly recommended to visit Cheeburger Cheeburger. Learned from my uber driver (only way to reach it) that it was based off an old SNL skit. Restaurant was big but empty on a Tuesday evening. The decorations were new but retro. Their half cut ancient red car really popped. Sat on the counter and ordered an island burger and cheesecake shake. The burger was basic. Didn't taste much flavor or any twist that wouldn't make it forgettable. The shake tasted more like a watered down Oreo. Overall average experience. read more

See all

We have visited Cheeburger Cheerburger since we were kids vacationing on Sanibel, and the charm is definitely still the same as adults. This is a spot that is worth visiting while you are in the area. The original location is on the island, and though the franchise expanded across the country, I believe that this location is one of the only left-- and it maintains its special vibes. The burgers are delicious and the menu is extensive with options for several sandwiches and sides. You will definitely want to get a milkshake, and you'll need a minute to read over all of the flavors and make the difficult choice of which one to get. we enjoyed the Sanibel hot chicken and the half pounder burger, along with fries and milkshakes. The little touches like the kids meals served in classic car containers and the wall of fame for the burger challenge make the experience really fun. I did only rate our experience as three stars for a couple of reasons. First, we had a group of nine adults, and we were not able to be seated together. We had to be seated at two tables across the aisle from another and not talk to our entire party. I was surprised that at such large and well-known establishment on the island, they are not able to accommodate groups of more than six. Second, none of the handhelds or burgers come with fries. The menu makes it seem that you can order a side of fries, so everyone at the table did. However, the side of fries was quite large... We ended up with way too many fries for the amount of people that we had. I wish the sandwiches would come with fries, or that the menu would make it clear that the side of fries could feed more than one person. Lastly, we ordered our shakes after our meals to have for dessert while chatting. However, they took about 30 extra minutes after we were done eating to come out, and one was missing when they did come out. Our waitress was very apologetic and kind, and we didn't mind sitting, but it would have been an issue if we needed to get somewhere else after eating. Despite the small issues, we really enjoyed the nostalgic experience of eating here and would be back. I would recommend it if you are visiting, and I don't think you can go wrong with any of their menu choices! read more

We are happy to share that yesterday's visit was back to the good ole Cheeburger we love. Service was good. Food was decently quick, hot & delicious. So glad they worked through the issues we had at Christmas. read more

Cheeburger Cheeburger - Burgers Near Me - Sanibel Island, Florida

Cool atmosphere going back to the 60s. Skip this place if you want a juicy hambburger. Well well done only. I don't understand why a place that specializes in serving hamburgers does that. Service was so..so. read more

See all

Cheeburger is located on Sanibel Island and has been a staple in our family for years. They have changed location over the past few years and we have been coming here since their original location on the island. Last year when the hurricane came through, luckily they did not get much damage but they went ahead and remodeled. I would love to say that they have since improved but sadly this was not the case. As I said, we have been coming for years but it might be put on hold for a bit. Their remodel has now included a bar area when you first come in. It is actually really pretty, big bar with stools, TVs and fully stocked. It is very much needed on busy nights or just to stop in for a drink. They also redid the floors and the décor in the restaurant. It feels very bright and open now. I really do like the new design. We had a party of 5, and luckily came at the right time and only had to wait about 10 minutes. The server was literally the best part of the experience. Pam was by far phenomenal and honestly the only reason this is a 3 and not a 1. The service was incredibly slow, we waited almost an hour for our food, we just ordered burgers and a fry basket to share. When the food finally came out, my mom's burger was missing. At this point we were so over the meal, she just asked to have it taken off the menu and shared a burger with my sister. Pam told us that there were new cooks in the kitchen and again was incredibly apologetic about the wait, we did not blame her, but it was still way to long to wait for hamburgers. For food, we ordered, the fried pickles. These also took forever, and we eventually asked Pam to go and grab them. We were all very hungry and starting to feel sick almost. They did come out extremely hot and they were very good. We had never ordered an appetizer here but these were delicious. For entrees, we all order a burger or cheeseburger. We all had different toppings on them, and different cheese. In the past, you were able to choose your bun, and they had about 30 toppings to choose from. They have changed their menu and reduced this a lot. There were only a handful of toppings and only one style of bun. I did miss this part and preferred the old menu. The burgers were just ok. They were all misshaped, some more round and some more flat. They were all supposed to be the same size, but it was just not consistent. They were also extremely greasy. We were very confused as to why a burger was so incredibly greasy. We all commented that we never had a burger which was just incredibly full of grease. We also ordered a basket of their fries. Their fries are always good and just complement their burgers. Overall, I am not sure if this will be a yearly visit moving forward. They are just so classic in our books but it seems they need to get some staffing correct before we will go back. The service was spot on but the kitchen crew needed help. They sent out one table at a time and literally sent the table out about 1-15 minutes apart. For a place that just sells mostly burgers, its what they are known for and in their name, they should be busting them out. Throw a ton of burgers down, the restaurant was fully packed. I really could not figure out what the issue was, but they need to get it together. read more

See all

Quickly greeted and seated. Our waitress was quick to our table. Very friendly. My wife and I split their famous cheese burger. It was delicious. I also got a peanut butter shake and it was awesome as well. Tasted homemade and old fashion. My wife and I loved the fries. This restaurant has a great old fashioned feel. Definitely a neat place. read more

See all

Recently my wife and the of the family had an early dinner at Cheeburger Cheeburger, located on Sanibel Island. We haven't been here in two years, so we were looking forward to returning. Cheeburger Cheeburger is a family -friendly restaurant, serving build your-own burgers, salads & shakes, in a vintage 1950s setting. Once we arrived and checked in with the hostess, we waited about 10 minutes. As we were waiting I noticed that they did some remodeling. They now offer a full bar, which wasn't something they offered two years ago. After we were seated our served came and greeted us warmly. Our servers name was Pam. Since it's been two years we weren't ready to order yet, but all of us either ordered an unsweet iced tea or a water. Pam came back few minutes later and we were ready. To start with we decided to share an order of fried pickles and a basket of hand cut fries. -Entrees: * I ordered an the famous half pound burger ( 8 oz), for toppings I decided on getting pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, sautéed mushrooms* My wife got the classic burger (6 oz) for toppings she got cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, pickles, tomato* My father-in-law order a classic burger, no cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickles* mother-in-law and sister-in-law order a classic burger, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles. After we placed our orders, the wait began. The restaurant was pre busy when we at down at our table, and noticed a lot of tables were waiting on food. So we kinda knew it would take a little bit to get our burgers. 15 to 20 minutes passed by and we haven't received our fried pickles. Our server Pam had been helping serve drinks at the bar during this time. She did make her rounds and came to our table and saw that we haven't gotten our appetizer. Pam was apologetic, absolutely wonderful. She explained that the cooks were new and trying to get a handle on things. She said it's no excuses at all, but that's why we and essentially everyone had been experiencing this. I felt bad for Pam and all the servers. 10 mins later Pam came with our fried pickles. The pickles were hot, nicely salted and had a nice crunch. After another 25/ 30 minutes, the burgers and fries came to the table. All looked good until we noticed my mother-in-laws order wasn't made..... Pam came to check on us and before we could mention it she noticed her order was missing . She once again was absolutely nice and apologized profusely. We asked Pam to tell them not to bother bringing it. We cut our burgers in half and just shared everything. Pam came back and said she would take of several things from our bill. I thought that was nice of her. The burgers were ok at best... Definitely had a little more grease than we were use to, having eaten here before. The fries were also just ok... could've been warmer and seasoned a little more. All in all Pam was the best part of our dinner. Couldn't have asked for a better server. She was in an unfortunate position. Non of this was a servers fault but she handled this like a champion. Thank you so much Pam. read more

See all

Burgers are thick and juicy, shakes and malts a great addition and they also have fun kid meal options, including add on shakes/malts and a fun classic car box. No wait time when we were there, staff were pleasant, great experience. We always make sure to stop here when visiting! read more

Cheeburger Cheeburger - Giant gumball machine... you will need a cup to catch how many come out! - Burgers Near Me - Sanibel Island, Florida

We had relatives from Ohio with us as we enjoyed the day on Sanibel Island. We decided to come to Cheeburger Cheeburger as it is a fun atmosphere, with great staff & good food. Our server Pam was very attentive, friendly & awesome! When the rest of the people at my table didn't like the taste of the water. Pam immediately took the ice waters away and replaced them with bottled water and a cups. Also one of the guests st my table didn't get the condiments on the burger (which was just unintentionally left off back in the kitchen) Our very accommodating server made sure to go back to the kitchen and immediately returned with his requested burger fixings. We were talking with her about music and how we liked the blues, she was very kind to call up a very talented artist on her phone and we were able to listen to the music a bit while eating our food. We thought that was really cool! Our burgers were perfectly prepared. I am the only one that didn't want cheese on my burger and she got that spot on too. She suggested that we get their half & half onion rings/french fries for us at our table to share. Great suggestion! We enjoyed both of them. Onions were crispy & not greasy whole French fries were also yummy! We had a couple of people order milkshakes to go and they were very pleased with them as well. Right before we left Pam brought out a surprise dessert of a chocolate fudge brownie with whipped cream with bits of blueberries & strawberries. Really tasty and pretty. There was a Thanks for visiting them written in strawberry glaze. We felt so welcomed! Pam really went above and beyond for us and it was very much appreciated. We definitely will return for not only the good food and atmosphere but also for Pam. She is absolutely the best server we have ever had anywhere. read more

See all

My two elementary aged boys absolutely love our lunch here. It has a very unique ambience. The food is tasty and the shakes are delicious. read more

Chee Burger Chee Burger Sanibel 6-6-24 We walked in at 4:14 pm on a Thursday afternoon. They were not busy and sat us at a table immediately. This place was clean, neat and had a great 50's vibe. Our waiter Adam came over fast and asked what we wanted to drink. We looked over the menu and decided on a milk shake to start with. I got the Chocolate; my wife got the Strawberry our friends got the Vanilla. We all ordered them thick. Adam came back with our drinks quickly and took our food order. I Ordered the 6 oz classic burger well done with Swiss Cheese, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Pickles and so did our friends. We got a single order of hand cut fries for our side to share as did our friends. I love hand cut fries as they have skins on them, and they are hard to find in this area. These burgers also came with a small cup of Cole Slaw. Our shakes arrived and we started in on them. They looked good with whipped cream and a cherry on top. They were good but not great. They looked big but really were not. They were not as thick as we liked them. Our food came out and the burger was done perfectly. It tasted very good and every item on our burgers tasted fresh and looked good. Our fries were another story. Both orders of Fries looked so brown as they were way over done, they were hard to eat as you can see by the added pictures. We could not finish the Fries they were just too hard to eat. When Adam came back to check on us, we talked to him about the Fries, and he said he would take them off the bill or get us another order of fries, we said no. He said he would get us some to go but we were done eating and did not want to take any with us. How can you screw up Fries? I will give this place a 3 out of 5 stars mainly for the 50's vibe and deduct 2 stars for overdone Fries and their average Milk Shakes. Follow Me For More Reviews Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

This is one of our kids favorite spots to grab dinner. Of all the restaurants on the online, it's one of the more affordable ones. The loaded fries are our favorite and we love the rye panini sandwich! Service is pretty standard. The decor is cute and fun. My kids favorite is the giant gumball machine. It was broken last time we were in, so hopefully it's fixed. read more

Great spot!! Been visiting sanibel since I was super little. Always great memories here. The food was HOT AND FRESH. The server was SO KIND. I don't understand any of the negative reviews. Really great experience, I think everyone should come here. OUR WAITRESS KAREN WAS SO KIND. read more

Great large restaurant to handle the island rush at meal times. Everyone was friendly throughout the meal. Everyone was happy with thier meals. Burgers were a little messy but large and filled us up. Onion rings and fries were both good and crisp. Food was slightly above average. Oreo shake was really good, but the Baileys shake was very disappointing. Basically a scoop of ice cream with a bunch of grated ice and a splash of Baileys. It wasn't mixed and wouldnt even come through a straw. We didn't even finish it. Overall a good value choice on the island, but would avoid any alcohol options. read more

Fun, retro burger joint serving up lots of classics! Everything we ordered came out fast and was cooked to perfection! Service was also top notch- quick and genuine employees. Will definitely come back here! read more

See all

Amazing service. Pam is a great waitress. The food is good, but the service is excellent. Pam was attentive, fast, friendly, and knowledgeable. This is the best restaurant on the Island! I can't wait to go back. read more

We just had a fantastic lunch! Forgot to take pictures but as the name implies the burgers were great! Highly recommend the onion rings as well which they make on site. I think Lindsey was our server and she was so friendly and did a great job. read more

We sat at the high top tables by the bar. The bartender was our waiter and he was not even polite. The burger was good but the french fries were cold and soggy but not in a good way. That evening we both had stomach aches and sent a lot of time in the bathroom. Beware!!!!! read more

I live in a different city but heard good things and wanted to try this place out for an anniversary lunch and online shows they are open everyday besides Mondays, so we made the drive all the way to Sanibel just to see the place was empty and doors locked with new hours posted on the door saying they are closed Tuesdays now as well; It should be updated online for the people who aren't local so that doesn't happen. It was super disappointing and a waste of gas to the island. read more

Prices have gone up, Food was okay at best. Service was slow and not great. Sad because there aren't as many restaurants to choose from post Ian and this wouldn't be a recommendation for me. Location and ambience are the positives. read more

Have driven by on prior visits, but because we come down here with our fur baby, we usually go out to places with outdoor seating options. This time we finally tried and got take out. I'll mention that the decor inside looks clean and fun, and staff was very friendly. I had the Hot chicken sandwich, which was memorable (generous and tasty). Wifey had the chiliheese fries, which were a bit bland (but generous, and packed thoughtfully for take out). Will try again next time in town - I saw many milkshakes made during my (reasonable) wait for food and they looked great! read more

I didn't get a classic milkshake cup with my milkshake. it was brought out in a tall metal cup. very disappointed.

AMAZINGGGG!!!! BEST BURGER EVER. Their milkshakes are so creamy and delicious and whoever thought to put grilled pineapple on a burger is genius. PLEASE COME HERE!! read more

Don't expect fast service for food at the bar, even if it is empty. This has happened to us twice now. We usually enjoy sitting at the bar and service at most places is comparable to a table, not here! We waited 35 minutes for burgers and fries the last time and maybe a little longer before. Too bad for them. We are good customers who tip generously. read more

This adorable diner transforms you. I was waiting for Mcfly to come in for a Coke. The food was delicious ::drool face emoji::. I had a western burger, and it was not only perfectly flavored, it was huge. By far I had the best fried pickles ever. My coffee milkshake was good, but can a milkshake ever be bad? Overall great food and service. If you bring kids order from the kids menu. Their food comes in a cute 50s belair. read more

Cheeburger Cheeburger - Western burger - Burgers Near Me - Sanibel Island, Florida

See all

We have been coming to Cheeburger Cheeburger for many years and this is the first time none of us ordered a burger, we ordered chicken fingers $8.99, portobello mushroom sandwich $7.99 and the Chee-dog $6.99 which is a ft long hotdog. We ordered fried pickles as appetizer and fries and onion rings as sides. For three of us we over-ordered for sure. The fried pickles are plentiful and while the batter is nice and crisp, the pickles are a bit salty. The chicken fingers come with 5 in an order and the chicken is quality. The batter isn't as crispy as I'd like but they are good. The Portobello sandwich is really tasty and worth getting. The Che-dog is quite flavorful and we ordered ours with chili and cheese. The fries are natural cut and quite good and the onion rings are nice. Our server today was Laura and a mage was attentive and friendly. read more

See all