Went to the Callahan location first and was so happy with the results of that meal. When we can…read moreback to Jax then next weekend had to try this location. We ate inside and the dining area was clean enough. Service was top notch helpful. I will say the food was better in Callahan but the staff made up the extra stars.

I love how friendly everyone is here! No matter when you come in, someone is there to get you…read more You order at the counter and they bring it out to you. The food is usually very good - the fried shrimp awesome! I am allergic to peppers but wanted a house salad as a side. Most are pre-made and had bell peppers on top. When I explained my allergy, they made me a fresh one without peppers. It was very good. I got shrimp and scallops they were able but over cooked, had a good blanket flavor to them. The green beans were really good as well. They are quick to clean up the tables and floors!

First I want to say we walked in on Christmas eve. 30 minutes before they closed. We asked the…read moreserver what was fast so she could go home. She said don't worry, we are busy so we will be here a while. I heard the wings are great here so that is what I had. They were cooked perfectly and had plenty of sauce. I would she the wings are great. Our server was very attentive and did not push us to leave. ( we did get out as quickly as possible but they were still busy.). This place has been hiding behind a gas station a long time. Glad we stopped.

Chicken was hot and ready when It was served The whole…read morechicken was fried perfectly and was delicious

Fresh seafood stores are non-existant on Amelia Island. Lofton Creek is a short ride over the…read morebridge, and well worth the visit. All their seafood is fresh and most, if not all of it is sourced locally. The people behind the counter are helpful, firendly, (and in my case) patient and willing to answer our questions. It doesn't get better than that!

They are always welcoming and very friendly, they have everything you want very fresh and anything…read moreyou need for fishing

Amazing fresh fish meals and a great spot to sit by the water and enjoy a relaxing meal. You walk…read moreup to the counter, place your order, and then find a seat while your food is freshly prepared. Everything about this place feels refreshing, from the atmosphere to the food. A simple, casual, and really enjoyable waterfront dining experience.

Haven't been to Safe Harbor since the remodel. It is nice to have a bar and additional seating…read morewhere the fresh catch coolers used to be. There was quite a line when we arrived but we took a seat at the bar (FCFS). Service was very fast and attentive. My wife ordered the fried mayport shrimp as nd I ordered the whole fried snapper. Her shrimp were excellent as usual, but my snapper was overcooked. It was still good, but was dry in the thinner areas. All in all a good visit though.

Great selection and service Ample servings…read more Low noise levels Parking area with easy access

I really wanted to like New Berlin Seafood, but after giving it two chances, I'm honestly left…read moredisappointed. On my first visit (a Wednesday), I waited over an hour just to be seated....only to find out they were completely out of oysters for the week. That was frustrating, especially after such a long wait. I decided to give them another shot this past Wednesday, hoping for a better experience, but unfortunately, it didn't improve. This time, I was told that oysters can no longer be prepared a certain way because it's considered a "special order." Instead, you're limited to however they choose to serve them.....either raw or lightly steamed. For a seafood spot, that's a bit surprising. Most people have a preference when it comes to oysters, and being told you can't customize your order feels restrictive. After speaking with the manager, she did agree to accommodate my request this one time (for one or two dozen), but also made it clear that moving forward, it wouldn't be allowed. That response didn't sit well with me....it gave the impression that customer preferences aren't really a priority. Between the long wait times, limited availability, and lack of flexibility with orders, I left feeling unpleased and unsatisfied. At this point, I'm not sure if I'll be returning.

I've been numerous times over the years, this latest visit was for a large birthday party- so…read morelarge, we basically took over the upstairs! Quay was our personal server and I think he was our bartender too- although there was another person back and forth behind the bar. We added a little chaos to the mix with a handful of family who showed without rsvp-ing. Add in toddlers plus easily 15 people.... Yeah- mad respect for Quay!!! I admit to being sad that I couldn't get my broiled platter- that is my favorite Fish Camp dish, and apparently not available for lunch. I pivoted and got the steam pot for 2. For myself. And guess what- I ate all the crab, hmmm so happy! Laugh- it was hilarious, I was still cracking crab while everyone sung happy birthday! I was thrilled. I brought home most of the potatoes, corn and such- it even had mushrooms and broccoli! YUM! My old fashioned was also perfection in a glass. John had the shrimp and fish basket and loved every bite. Several raved about the shrimp and grits. Caron loved her mahi mahi. Connor got the Spicy Wild Caught Shrimp Linguine with White Wine, Garlic, Tomato, Pecorino and inhaled it! Even the kiddos were super happy with the kids chicken strips, although the kitchen delivered the first plate to the wrong toddler and the lovely parents didn't question how they got food without ordering and that little girl dug right in. Opposite end of the table- this grandma spoke up and we split the food so all the littles were fed. Considering our chaotic group, it went very well. I didn't hear a single complaint from our party. Hopefully we didn't drive the staff too crazy!

I used to absolutely love this place. It was our go-to for seafood, celebrations, family dinners,…read moreand special occasions for years. We recommended it constantly and genuinely enjoyed supporting them. Unfortunately, after our last few experiences, that loyalty is completely gone. The problems really started during a dinner visit with my spouse. We had a reservation for two and specifically requested a booth because my spouse has herniated discs and booths are much easier on her back. The hostess with glasses told us there were "no booths available for parties of two," so we were seated at a tiny two-top directly in front of an empty booth. Minutes later, another couple - who apparently didn't even have the correct downstairs reservation because Wheel House was closed for a private event - was seated in that exact booth instead. When I politely questioned it, I was told they were "accommodating them." Interesting, because apparently accommodating a medical issue for customers with a reservation didn't matter. Still, we decided to give the restaurant another chance for Mother's Day. To their credit, we were seated at a booth this time after I both noted it in the reservation and called ahead to confirm it. Our waiter was someone we immediately recognized from a previous visit, and my parents mentioned he had waited on us before at that same table. Somehow, from that comment alone, he became convinced we were related to Chef Tim Tillus. From there, things got bizarre. He kept talking about "Timmy," mentioning reunions and saying he used to live with him. The restaurant was extremely loud, and my father had forgotten his hearing aids that day, so honestly we could barely understand what he was talking about. We just smiled politely and focused on asking about the menu because we truly had no clue where the conversation was going. Eventually, he came back and realized we were NOT Chef Tim Tillus' family. He then explained that the kitchen staff had apparently been laughing because the chef saw us and said, "That's not my family." So somehow this became a whole ordeal in the kitchen over a completely innocent misunderstanding. We laughed awkwardly because what else do you do at that point? But honestly, the whole interaction felt strange and unprofessional. Unfortunately, the food was even worse than the awkward service. My spouse ordered the all-day seafood soup, and somehow there was basically ZERO seafood in it. That alone was shocking because their soups used to be incredible. My father ordered the broiled platter, and the portion size was honestly embarrassing for a $29 dish. His parsley potatoes consisted of literally five tiny cubes - my mother counted them because we were in disbelief. We have eaten here for years and NEVER saw portions this small. I ordered the fish special, and it was nothing like described. It was supposed to have pecans and blackening seasoning. There were no pecans, no blackening seasoning, and the fish itself was dry, bland, overcooked, and flavorless. For $32, I was served what looked like a tiny sad pile of fish in the middle of a giant empty plate. The pork chop looked beautiful but tasted absolutely awful. At this point I honestly don't know if the kitchen quality has completely collapsed or if nobody is checking food before it leaves the line anymore. Either way, it was terrible. My mother ordered scallops on the half shell as her meal - something she has enjoyed there many times before. This time, the scallops were tiny and somehow greasy. It was shocking these dishes were even leaving the kitchen. What makes this so disappointing is that we truly loved this restaurant. We weren't casual customers. We supported this place for years because we believed the food and experience were worth it. This wasn't just a mediocre meal or an "off night." This was a genuinely terrible dining experience from start to finish, made worse by the fact that it happened on Mother's Day. The service felt awkward and disorganized, the portions were insulting, the food quality was awful, and there seemed to be zero quality control happening anywhere. At this point, our money will be supporting other establishments instead. It's honestly sad because this place USED to be special. I sincerely hope management fixes the kitchen, consistency, and overall professionalism before even more longtime customers walk away.

Food and service were excellent! We were in town for a couple of days and liked our lunch so much…read morethat we came back for dinner the next day. Will definitely visit again when in town.

First hostess didnt even bother greeting us. Sat us quickly and threw the menus on the table…read more Food was so bland and had barely any taste. Not worth it.

What a fun find! My BF and I went to dinner here. Stepping inside, it looks like your traditional…read moreseafood restaurant. The hostess said it would be about 10 minutes before we could be sat inside or 20+ minutes outside. She also offered us to see if we could find a seat at the bar. We looked outside and landed two seats at the bar. Triple bonus- there was a band playing, drinks flowing, and a sun setting high in the sky. Everyone like to be smiling and having a great time, even the staff. He ordered the Ahi tuna, I ordered the Thai chili shrimp. Both were amazing and we would absolutely order again. Both plates were well presented, and came out in a fair amount of time. I can't wait to go back!

10/10 Happy hour…read moredeal everyday at reasonable time? Some of our food didn't make the cut because they lasted on the table for maybe 5 minutes. The blackened shrimp amazing along with the hush puppies. The oysters that had crab on top, absolutely delicious and had a ton of flavor. The staff is SO nice and knew a lot about the menu. She crab soup is a solid 6.5/10 their house salad is very fresh. I'll be back for sure!

Great place on the river, with the marina docks in view of the porch. It's rustic, casual, and…read morecomfortable. Our shrimp was great. Flavorful, nicely seasoned and cooked... grits were excellent. I can imagine the shrimp and grits are delicious. Our server was a delightful student who took great care of us. All together this was a fine local restaurant with reasonably priced seafood in a casual atmosphere. Not fancy, but worth trying.

Great place to watch the sunset across the marsh! Parking is a pain but once you're in there is…read moreinside and outside seating, a bar and sports monitors. They serve Georgia Shrimp which are smaller but have much more taste than farm raised shrimp. The cheese grits and field peas were spot on. Everyone in our group of 12 enjoyed their food. The service was a little slow but attentive - and we were a large group.

I'm sad. I'm sad this place isn't in St Augustine, or have a location closer to St Augustine…read more Ever since I discovered this place, I try to add it in when I'm in the area. Unfortunately, I'm not in the area that much, and only once did I make the journey just to come here. What is the draw, you may ask? Great beer, great food, great atmosphere, great vibes! , That said, every meal I have had here has been delicious. The beer is pretty darn good & cold too! Of course, with the long drive...ya gotta limit it. But it's worth it for anything on the menu. I don't know where to start food-wise, I am trying to eat my way around the menu. The gator tail and fish dip are two of my favorites for small bites/appetizers. The Elk burger, the Taphouse burger, and the Nashville Hot Chicken sandwich are always amazing....and then there's the cole slaw...yummy! Delicious food, and they have more than just sandwiches. The menu offers a little something different. The atmosphere and vibe are always inviting, and the staff is super friendly. The prices are fair, portions are ample, and there is plenty of parking. The decor is fun too! Not to mention, they give a veteran discount with proof of ID. What more can you ask for? Well, I know what I can ask for! To the owners: pretty please, with sugar on top, consider opening a location in St. Augustine. Not in the downtown area, but the folks north of town need something; they need you! Around the Palencia & Kensington area, off US 1 to be exact...or anywhere nearby in that area. The folks there would love something they can walk to, ride bikes to, maybe even use a golf cart to get to...and yes, a short drive is good too. Jus' sayin'! Please just check it out...I said pretty please!

What an odd amalgam of themes or a lack there of…read more Some coastal decor and a huge grizzly bear thats been taxidermied handing out in back. It looks like it might have been a steakhouse before and this is new? Anyway that aside, we had good service and food that was bland. Salt would have helped but there was none on the tables. And if asked for from the waitress, took longer than thr entree/side was around for. We probably wont be back