Castle Liquor Store

5.0 (1 review)

Beer, Wine & Spirits, Convenience Stores

Add Review

Call

Directions

Castle Liquor Store Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Castle Liquor Store

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Mercedes D.

7 years ago

This store has probably the best craft beer selection I've found in the tri-state area! Lots of rare finds. High quality selection as well! Thank you to Lizzie as well for the awesome customer service. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Castle Liquor Store

2514 Broad St
New Castle, IN 47362
Directions
(765) 529-3405
Call Now

Hours

What time does Castle Liquor Store open?

What time does Castle Liquor Store close?

Outdoor Amenities

Does Castle Liquor Store have parking?

Yes, Castle Liquor Store has parking options.

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Castle Liquor Store Inc No 1

4.0(1 review)

0.8 mi

The gentleman I spoke with was very friendly and helpful even tho they didn't have what we were…read morelooking for, a bottle of Port. If you want to see how we ended up here read my review for Sav-On Liquors across the street for a good laugh. If castle Liquor had a better selection i would probably come in more often, but for the most of the basics they have you covered, and with a smile.

LJ's Quik Thru New Castle

5.0(4 reviews)

0.2 mi

I'm so happy we have a local restaurant that serves a large variety of dishes that go from…read morebreakfast to dinner. I have eaten here a dozen times at least and I have yet to be disappointed in any of the food. I would recommend the tenderloin if you're real hungry the nachos are hit with me and the breakfast bowls are outright amazing! If you don't know about LJ's just takes State road 38 or broad if you're local going east and find this hidden gem for a good meal.

Any product there is very good! The staff works hard! It is like a secret gem in Newcastle Indiana!…read moreThey have several varieties to choose from!

Flying J Travel Center

2.7(27 reviews)

6.3 mi

•$

This Flying J has a decent amount of parking. I only stopped in for some ice cream which was $2.79…read morenot bad at all. The cashier was pleasant and checked me out quickly. The inside was okay but it was in the process of being cleaned so no complaints. I will definitely stop in again.

This Flying J location always makes for an ok stop. It is not the best, but not bad. It is a…read moretypical flying J travel center with the usual convenience items. I have been here a few times and always friendly staff. This visit was for gas and a restroom break. We picked up some not so healthy junk food and drinks too and then back on the road. I use a fleet card at times for work and wanted to mention that if you do, those are prepay inside and not at the pumps. It's always an ordeal as you go in, leave your ID and card, then pump gas, and go back in, etc.

Photos

The Scale

See all

Women's Restroom

Village Pantry

1.0(1 review)

1.3 mi

They need to keep there trash pick up in the parking lot they are nasty! they don't bag there trash…read moreinstead they just take their trash cans and put all the trash in the dumpster without bagging it... they fill the dumpster with boxes that they don't break down and then can't close the lids to the dumpster so therefore all the trash just flies out into the parking lot and especially into my yard and frankly, I am sick of picking up their trash they will get reported to the city again and I will continue to report them until something gets done about it

Harvest Supermarket

5.0(1 review)

0.6 mi

I love the deli section best. Best sandwich spread ever!!! Looks like it needs an update though.read more

Hi-Way Liquor Store

1.0(2 reviews)

1.9 mi

I came in at 6:01 and I guess they close at 6. I was basically told to leave a minute later by a…read morevery rude woman. I thought the normal thing to do was tell somebody we actually close at 6. No rush just letting you know. I just grabbed something and left as quick as possible. The gentleman at register was nice though. I'll never come back because the woman was so rude

Terrible, rude customer service. Would not recommend anyone to spend your hard earned money in a…read moreplace that does not appreciate it.

CVS Pharmacy

1.0(2 reviews)

1.5 mi

This place is the worst. Wait is insanely long to pick up prescriptions and their hours are awful…read more Rude too.

I have called for 2 days to check the cost on new prescriptions and have been on hold for 45…read moreminutes both times. It's pretty ridiculous the customer service is that bad! Time to change pharmacies!

Photos

See all

Castle Liquor Store - beer_and_wine - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Things to Do near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Desserts near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Coffee near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Cocktail Bars near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Parking near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Vape Shops near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Liquor Store near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Restaurants near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Grocery Store near Castle Liquor Store

BEST of New Castle, Indiana Smoke Shop near Castle Liquor Store

Best of New Castle

Things to do in New Castle

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Castle Liquor Store also viewed

Pay Less Gas Fuel Stop

5.0

(1 review)

•$

I looked on gasbuddy.com for a station close to me. Other stations showed up with low prices but I…read morealready knew from experience when I went to them you only got the lower price if you have their card or are member, etc. Since I live out of town I don't have that advantage. I decided to try the Pay Less station which was right across the road from my motel. I walked up to the window first and asked the young man if there was anything I needed to know about the station before I pump the gas, like whether the price was the same for cash or credit, whether I needed a special card or whatever. He said, Let me come out and show you, and walked over to the pump with me. He asked me if I had a Kroger card. I told him no because I lived out of town. He asked if I had a few other cards and when he said Fry's I remembered that I had shopped at the Fry's in Arizona frequently and that they were affiliated with one of the stores in San Diego, Ralph's I think. We tried my cell phone number and bingo it worked. I didn't just get the $1.95/gallon gas price that GasBuddy he had indicated, I got $0.03 off of that because of my phone number being on file so I paid $1.92 a gallon. Kudos to the young man who was so helpful to me. I told him this will be my gas station from now on when I'm in Anderson. Close. Easy. Cheap. And a great employee who helped me out. I should have gotten his name. 9/26/16

Harvest Supermarket

5.0

(1 review)

I love the deli section best. Best sandwich spread ever!!! Looks like it needs an update though.read more

Mom & Pops Mini Mart

4.3

(3 reviews)

•$

Nice locally owned mom n pop mini mart in this tiny little town. They have lots of different hot…read morefoods, deli sandwiches, snacks, drinks, candy, basic groceries, and all you expect from a mini mart. Support this small store as its the only store in town to buy basic items without having to drive several miles to a large town.

Great small town vibe and good food. Good to have something locally owned so close by.read more

Winchester No 1 Package Store

5.0

(1 review)

There was a power outage in town that shut down everything but the young man working behind the…read morecounter was awesome and more than helpful!!!

Manning Service

4.0

(1 review)

Let's face it. This is all Saratoga's got. So it's really handy to be able to get basics here when…read moreyou're in town. They have a ton of fireworks at the 4th of July also.

Castle Liquor Store