Talked to the manager Dan when I was trying to place our order as they mess it up everytime. And he…read morewas very rude and didn't want to take the rest of our order. He said he's the only cook there which is not our problem. So I just told him to cancel what order I gave him. This place is in desperate need of training and customers service skills to say the least!

Me and a group of friends just wanted to eat food. We waited for over 30 minutes and still got no…read moreservice after sitting here for that long. As soon as my friend stood up to go speak to someone they got told that we would be helped soon. People coming in after us got served before us. This is terrible service, for honestly mediocre food.

What a surprise. Indeed the beer wall is fun and fairly priced. You come for that. 16 or so taps,…read moreyes! Let me emphasize:the pizza is really good. And I mean really. Thin, crunchy. Not burnt. Generous toppings, really cheesy. The garlic cheese bread is even better. Comfy casual surroundings. Attentive service. stay awhile and enjoy. In historic downtown district. Plenty of parking.

We're in Nebraska City for work and have already eaten at City Tap House three times in two weeks…read more The pizza is seriously some of the best I've ever had -- every time it's been perfect. The beer wall is awesome, too. You can try a bunch of different beers without having to buy a full one, which is super cool. Great food, cool place, and we'll definitely be back again before we head out. Highly recommend!

I can't tell you how long it has been since I was able to enjoy the grand buffet. Well worth the…read moredrive from Omaha. The servers are nice but definitely have that slow town feel where they talk to customer for quite a while. Given it's a serve yourself buffet, I can't complain. The place itself was part Val's family portraits and part Huskers. Seems about right for Nebraska. It was cozy and inviting. They had plenty of options and all the favs here. And if anything was low or sat for too long, they are more than happy to refresh. I really liked the dessert options that I never get when ordering to-go. The prices were actually surprisingly reasonable. And to top it off, kids under 10 eat free on Tuesdays. Not a place you can eat too often and maintain your figure, but we will be back!

Okay, so this is the best place to stop in Nebraska City that has gluten free options, hands down…read more The Taco Bell has terrible reviews. Runza only has gluten free fries and we just made the decision to try out Valentinos and see if it's still good since my husband had it growing up. This is a buffet style restaurant, even though you can order your own gf pizza, but we ordered it for the Buffett and they bring it to you to get as many pieces as you want before they put it on the buffet for others to eat. Soooo nice!!! We got a meat lovers gf pizza and it was surprisingly yummy!!!! We enjoyed the salad, the small town, and we had the nicest waitress!!! She explained our options for gf. We are not buffet fans but we had a lovely time and if we are traveling through Nebraska City again, this is the only place we will stop. (There is a cute cafe in Auburn NE that is with a stop)

Pagliai's has definitely been great the last several times we've visited and ate from the buffet…read more Don't forget to eat a monster cookie for dessert. The servers are always kind and attentive and it's clean!

Just what you want from a small town, family owned pizza place. We were there during the week and…read moreenjoyed their nightly buffet. They kept the drinks full and our stomachs even more full!

Very good pizza and fries. I recommend and the staff are very nice yes. Yes they are the best pizza…read moreplace in town, yes. Because yes, they are good, yes.

The food is not good, the sauce was very sour and the pepperoni had no flavor. The service was…read morenice for high school kids. I would not visit here again.

Placed an online order for pick up and had to wait for over 10 minutes. Pizza was nice and hot. We…read moredidn't stay to eat. Ate our pizza in our car watching fireworks. Pizza like I said was alright because we ordered it Pan, but not good enough to make this a regular

Won't deliver to the Holiday inn & suites hotel less than a mile away. Also their pizza is awful.read more

This is an older building…read more The inside is close quarters. There is enough room to move around, but it's also stocked as full as possible. The world famous Casey's pizza is available. Other snacks, including Rice Krispie Treats and soft drinks, are too. Like other locations, the bathrooms are clean and well kept. Free air is available.

A vagrant was outside near the door harassing customers, asking for money for a pizza. Very…read moreintimidating, and very unusual for a small town. When this was pointed out to the manager on duty, their response was , "So, what do you expect me to do about it?" Well, maybe they won't take action, but our action will be to NOT return. Otherwise, it's a decent store, standard Casey's.

I actually just stopped here to take a shower so I was in and out. The shower was clean nicely and…read morecashier was pleasant. The store was being cleaned so it was nice.

Jon compton has excellent customer experience made me feel welcomed he was a beam light. Very…read morekind and made my hectic day a little less hectic. Thank you for your service with a smile.

The food was very well prepared and the line workers were very accommodating of my hard of hearing…read morestatus and were very patient with me. Nice ambiance!

To expensive for what you get and please clean the tables after a customer leaves! We've been in…read morethere countless times where they weren't even busy and several dirty tables while the employees are hanging out behind the counter or in the back room. Where's the management anyway?!

Beautiful building and wonderful staff. Many beers available, and the appetizers and pizza were…read moredelicious. A definite favorite.

Beyond happy with everything aiding in our experience here. Ordered the special Caprese Pizza,…read moreSpicy chicken pizza, and chicken sandwich; all exceptional. Would eat again without question. Each beer we tried was great. Our favorites were nuttier than squirrel turds, doll face, and stop it Rocco. Definitely worth the drive from Omaha. Will be coming back another time.