This was such a great hole in the wall find for us. The restaurant is hidden, very casual with not a lot of frills but the food is the star of the show here. You can tell that this place has a nice following, many of the guests that were dining seemed to be locals and regulars. The staff was again, casual, but they were super honest, helpful, and seemed to have a passion for their job, it was refreshing. We ordered some mussels in a portuguese mussels and omg- the flavor was amazing. We then had 2 rolls and we were just in heaven. read more

See all

the Lobstah pie with butter sherry and ritz crumbs was delicious. Dining companions enjoyed the lobster roll and fish tacos also. Staff is always nice and restaurant is mellow and clean read more

This place is really hard to find because of GPS but I'm glad I persisted. The food was pretty amazing to be honest. I was hoping for fried flounder since I'm from the south but the restaurant specializes in New England fried cod. I got a platter with the cod, jumbo shrimp, and seasoned scallops with home cut fries and Cole slaw. Everything on the platter was better than expected especially the scallops. They were incredible. This place is literally a hidden gem. I hope to eat here again if I visit Fort Myers again. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Fried cod, jumbo shrimp and seasoned scallops platter with home cut fries and homemade Cole slaw. - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

We learned about this restaurant quite by accident, but we are so glad we did. It ended up being 30 miles from home, but was worth the nice afternoon drive. We think the food is wonderful and so fresh. The breading on the seafood is so thin and tasty. I ordered the Fisherman's Platter and loved everything on it. My husband ordered the shrimp and cod. We both could not stop saying how good it was. I wish I would have taken pictures, but will when we go back. We both had enough to take home to eat for dinner. We cannot wait to go back. I must mention that they are closed this week and next week for vacation. They are going to need a rest before "season" as we are sure they will be very busy. The servers were so friendly and helpful about the menu. read more

Never had a bad meal there. They make amazing meals and soups. Great food, lobster rolls are fabulous and the shrimp is succulent and large read more

It's relatively small with inside and outside tables. It's not fancy. Great place that shows respect to seafood. Really well done The service was friendly and did a great job. Definitely needs to be visited more frequently. read more

If you are looking for the best seafood in town, just come here! Very affordable, outstanding taste and great service! My hubby and I loved it and we did not have to go somewhere on the beach and pay $20-30 for parking! Lobster Rolls are too good and the chowders a must! The inside is so cute and they have a full covered patio! Nice music playing in the background, no rushing environment! read more

Outstanding seafood! We had a wonderful time there. We were a group of 4 and everybody found a match on the menu! The place was very nice and cozy. Two servers took care of us and they were great, just can't remember their names. They have changed the interior and it really looks amazing compared to my previous visits. Always worth the visit when you are craving for good and high quality seafood! read more

I visited Cape Cod Fish for the first time during lunch, on Saturday. It is a hole-in-the wall type place off of McGregor, in Fort Myers. Everything was excellent, especially the New Englander fish sandwich, lobster roll, and lobster chowder. They have indoor and outdoor seating, and a great variety of different options on their menu. Don't worry: if you don't like fish, they have "seagull fingers". Highly recommend if you are in the area! read more

Wife had been craving some good fish & chips and we decided to give Cape Cod Fish a try giving it was on our way back home and also all the rave reviews. Located on the back end of a shopping center parking as you can imagine was plentiful. There was indoor and outdoor seating options. Staff seemed friendly to start and the restaurant seemed quite busy for a mid afternoon lunch crowd. So all signs pointed in the right direction. We all started ordering and my daughters bf wanted a grilled cheese with his lobster bisque. We were told he couldn't order that because it was on the kids menu and he wasn't under 12. Which I found odd particularly since we had an 8 year old at the table. She said there was another type of grilled cheese which he could order. So we went with that. The rest of our order consisted of the Parm & Truffle Fries, Classic Lobstah Roll, Fish & Chips, Chicken Fingers, New England Clam Chowder and Fried Calamari. The fries were hand cut which was a plus and the fish was fried to order. Well fried and steaming hot. Outside of that none of the rest of the food really stood out. Fish although well fried and fresh needed seasoning. The fries needed salt. I mean even our 8 year old asked for salt. The lobstah roll was ok but I didn't feel great after eating it. The Fried Calamari came doused in several sauces and it was all soggy by the time it arrived at the table. I would suggest sauce on the side next time. But I could oversee many food issues acknowledging that people have different tastes and opinions vary from person to person on what may be seasoned or not. But there is one thing I won't budge on and that's service. I never got a warm feeling from the servers. Most of the time they stood behind the counter with their arms folded. I couldn't understand why there was a fountain soda section in the middle of the dining room yet only the servers could use it. There was even a big sign that said "No Self Serve!" But the kicker was being over charged in the end for our kids Chicken Fingers. The bill said 12.99 even though the menu said 6.99. And that grilled cheese that we couldn't get ended up getting charged 10.99 when the kids menu said 4.99. We ended up not saying anything because we just wanted to leave. My wife later told me that she felt uncomfortable and truth be told I did as well. It is unfortunate as we were looking for a nice dining experience and based on the many positive reviews I thought that would be the case. Hopefully your experience is better than ours. read more

See all

We were looking for seafood while we were in Fort Meyers and found this spot on Yelp. Our order: - Flash Fried Calamari - Classic Lobster Roll w/Parmesan Truffle Fries - Cod & Shrimp Combo I enjoyed the calamari and lobster roll the most. They were good, though I'm not sure they quite lived up to the raving Yelp reviews I read. The fried seafood was just ok for me. The lunch portions are pretty small and the prices are still fairly steep, so expect to spend more than normal for lunch here. read more

See all

Delicious seafood, the Portuguese mussels were outstanding and the waitstaff were terrific. We will be back!!

Hidden on the far corner of a strip mall sits Cape Cod Fish Company. The service was very fast and the vibe was casual. My wife and I shared their Classic Lobster Roll with Parmesan Truffle Fries, Cod N Shrimp Combo, and Flash Fried Calamari. The calamari was well executed and although I would have preferred it with less chilli-lime aioli, I couldn't stop eating it. The lobster roll was also good. As for the parmesan truffle fries and cod n shrimp combo... They were just okay. Overall, considering the price, I would expect a better dining experience. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Classic Lobster Roll with Parmesan Truffle Fries - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

I'm from Cape Cod and this definitely doesn't represent our seafood!‍‍‍ I thought the portion was terrible with bad attitudes. Won't ever go back! read more

Came here for a late lunch and wow! The food here is fantastic. The tacos and sandwich special were both equally good. We came from out of town and would go back in a heartbeat. read more

See all

I recently stopped here while visiting family on a drive up to Tampa and I am so glad. The only downside about this place is that it isn't closer to where I live. Everything is made fresh to order and the prices are very reasonable however they are a little bit on the higher side. The Saving Grace definitely for the price point is the fact that it actually comes with a side when you order a lobster roll. Many places that I have been to just give you the role of for the same amount of money. Everything about the role was phenomenal and when it comes to the amount of butter on it I have to say that it was just the right amount, I can't stand when my lobster rolls are swimming in butter and this place definitely knows how to put the right amount of butter without making it too greasy. The staff was very friendly and even said all of their specials and they even apologized that they were out of clams because of a shortage on them. The lobster tasted as if it was caught 5 minutes ago and cooked up right then and there. Seriously one of the best lobster rolls that I have ever had and I can't wait to come back again as soon as I am in the area! read more

See all

We saw the great reviews for this so we put it on our list of seafood places to try when in the FM area for three weeks. We arrived early on a Friday and it was a good thing because people were waiting in the parking lot by the time we had finished (no other place to wait). We were able to get a small table outside which was good though the patio isn't super inviting. Inside the place is pretty small. Our waitress was super friendly and helpful. She did a nice job. Only four non-interesting beers on draft so I started with their white sangria which was pretty good. Thought I was drinking a soda! I tried their NE clam chowder and it was very good. Third time I have tried a chowder or bisque around town on this visit and this was by far the best. Good flavor and the right amount of creaminess without being gloppy. My wife got the blackened salmon tacos and gave them a big thumbs up. I tried their lobster roll with hot butter - I asked for extra melted butter - decadent! It was not huge for $24 but it was filled with large pieces of lobster meat. Lots of claw meat. Excellent! The ambiance isn't great but the food is! read more

After being there a few times before covid we knew we could go now again with no problems we thought. Well the only problem was it's still way too crowded. It was never like that before. What is happening here? Snowbirds still or just no one wants to go back to work? I'm glad the restaurant is doing well anyway. We love it. Our favorite New England clam chowder with clam cakes just like in Rhode Island. You can dip the clam cakes into the soup. It's To die for. We will always go there, no matter what. Good going Joe if you're still there. And we see you still have your great staff and possibly even more people. read more

Cape Cod Fish - New England clam chowder with clam cakes. - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

This is a fabulous hidden gem! The best fried cod I've ever had, including off the coast of Ireland and in the UK. The batter is very light and crispy, and the cod was perfectly cooked and juicy. My Mom is a regular here and I came during last week's visit and I will definitely be coming back. I highly recommend this wonderful place with great service and great food! read more

Came around lunch time on a Saturday and got the shrimp and cod combo. The Cod was amazing and the food came quick! A little pricey, but would come back again. read more

Brings be back home food is outstanding owner is so in love with making great food. His creations are off the chart. The service is so good too very friendly! read more

Food and service was excellent!. This is a place that you must try! You will not be disappointed.

Very tasty, almost like Cape cod seafood up north. Service was great and place was clean

Wicked good seafood and they mean it! The outside is a bit worn but don't let this deter you, you will not be disappointed. The seafood is SO fresh! The hand cut French fries were freshly cut and lightly salted. We ordered the fish and shrimp Combo and the shrimp poboy. I loved the pink sauce that went with the poboy. We will definitely return again! read more

Cape Cod Fish - Fried Shrimp Po'Boy - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

The food is fantastic. The clam chowder, the fish tacos, the clam cakes, the beer, the shrimps, and the food was tasty. Kate is a great server and manager. Thank you! Clams foreva! read more

Yesterday, I got a notification from Yelp reminding me that this casual seafood restaurant has been on my "want to go" list, and so today I checked it out. I'm glad I did. I was very tempted by several things on the menu, including both Maine-style and Connecticut-style lobster rolls, but I decided to try the Fried Shrimp Po'boy as a reliable indicator of overall restaurant quality. Based on that, and a few additional elements of my experience, I'd definitely rate this place Top Notch. I started with some perfectly brewed iced tea and a cup of delicious Lobstah and Sweet Corn Chowdah (see photo). The chowder was very flavorful with noticeable chunks of lobster. It was a little sweet (from the corn), and I added some ground black pepper to give it a little bite. I also added the packet of Oyster Crackers that came with the soup, which helped give it more heft. I would definitely order (a bowl of) this soup again. The Fried Shrimp Po'boy came out a little fast (I was still savoring the soup) but it was perfectly presented (see photo) and was extremely good. Indeed, when the server asked me what I thought after my first couple of bites, I honestly said I felt like I was on Bourbon Street. The Po'boy is quite traditional, with a classic, buttered and toasted French roll (with a great crunch and chew), a medley of Romaine lettuce and diced tomatoes, plenty of large, perfectly cooked breaded shrimp, and a drizzling of "spicy mayo," which wasn't actually very spicy but had a nice subtle Cajun flavor. Some additional spicy mayo was served on the side, which I gladly added. The shrimp were hot, plump, and juicy. The breading was a little too thick and a little too bland for my taste, but it was definitely in a New Orleans style. The whole was supremely satisfying, as were the Hand-Cut French Fries. I cut the sandwich in half using the thoughtfully-provided serrated knife, and added some Crystal Hot Sauce to the second half, which nicely boosted the overall taste. The restaurant has a nice vibe with a very friendly staff, and several parties including individuals, couples, and families came in to eat while I was there. There's also outdoor seating in the front, and although there really isn't any significant view from there, a nice variety of New England artwork and other decorations, as well as plants, makes for a nice atmosphere. There's nothing very "Cape Cod" about a Shrimp Po'boy, but this location has a significant sense of itself and a thorough commitment to overall quality. I will definitely be back to try some of the more New England style items. read more

See all

It was just ok. Not anything I'd need to do again. Seafood was as good as I could get in several other places.

5 stars! Drove up and ordered carryout about 45 min before closing time, and so happy we made it in time! Everything was so delicious and fresh! And not badly priced considering the quality of food. The ladies who were serving and taking orders were so sweet and helpful, we truly enjoyed their hospitality :) My lobster roll was absolutely scrumptious and I fell in love with the fried fish from my husband's "captains dinner". I wasn't a fan of the yellow belly clams but that's just a personal preference, nothing to do with quality. My only regret is not living closer to eat here every week lol! read more

See all

No wait, food was amazing, a real taste of southern New England, and Michelle was an awesome server!!

The BEST SEAFOOD restaurant in Fort Myers! Avoid all the traffic, and have a phenomenal meal!! read more

YOU MUST try Cape Cod Fish. Local place that provided spectacular service (Michelle was awesome) food was amazing - we can't wait to go back. read more

Great New England seafood. My daughter came from Denver and had her Lobster Roll!! Waitress Michelle was great. Especially with our 2 yr old grandbaby. read more

The servers were really great. The food was so good We had the mussels and truffle fries with two classic lobster rolls and the shrimp tacos and it was all just so so so good. 10/10 recommend. read more

See all

Great little restaurant with good service and nice fresh seafood, nice, cozy environment with very friendly staff. I had the fried captains platter with cod scallops and shrimp. Super good and fresh. The only reason I don't give the restaurant five stars is because I haven't tried other menu items but soon will. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Captain's Basket - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Another great lobster dinner! Excellent service great place to bring family! Great deal on fish! read more

Cape Cod Fish - Lobstah Lobstah - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Delicious seafood here especially the cod & the coleslaw. Inside & outdoor seating. Convenient location. Waitresses are very good & help each other. Have eaten here 3 times in last 2 weeks. Started by a couple from Cape Cod. read more

I had heard of this place and had to try it. We ordered the lobster and corn chowder, a lobster roll, and a Captain's Platter (fried). Everything was delicious! Fresh, large portions, and fast! The star of the show is that chowder. The sherry in it is absolute perfection! Michelle was our server and was awesome! We will definitely be back. read more

Cape Cod Fish - Lobster N Sweet Corn Chowder, Captain's Basket, Classic Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

This is one restaurant that tastes as good as the photos online, and also the only restaurant whose food actually looks like the photos they post when you get it served. Fish n chips are perfectly portioned . Not that gigantic piece I get in RI that's all batter. My favorites: Salmon Tacos, NE Clam Chowder, of course the lobster roll, Big surprise to us were the Truffle fries but you gotta share 'em. read more

This is fantastic Cape Cod seafood restaurant in an unexpected location (ie strip mall) and I highly recommend a visit. I had the lobster roll and it was perfect and I also had the lobster and sweet corn chowder and it was also perfect. Service was super friendly and the prices were right. All in all, the food is wonderful here and I will gladly return. read more

Wowsa! We started off with their New England clam chowder. Certainly better than any chowda I've had in New England. Stock full of clams and so flavorful. Wicked good. Short intermission from the food. The people who work here are so nice and helpful. Back to the food. We had the classic lobster roll. OMG, it came out looking small, but damn, there was a ton of lobster stuffed into that perfectly buttered roll. We also ordered a side of their wasabi shrimp. Side??!! Huge portion of the best shrimp ever! Perfectly fried and drizzled with a wasabi/lime and soy and Thai chili sauce. I wanted to lick the plate. OK, I lied, I licked the plate. Fabulous. Come here at once. Thanks for an incredible meal...Your new best friends from NY via California. read more

See all