Good price for pretty good donuts. Stick to the traditionals, (glazed, crumb) they taste the best. Can be crowded and tough to maneuver in and out the door with a line, but they are really working hard behind the counter to move quickly. It's a fun little spot to grab a few non-chain donuts and bring home. read more

We were visiting the campus and found out that Buckeye Donuts was just plain tradition. So after eating our share of Anthony Thomas buckeye chocolates which are literally at every checkout stand at every store in Columbus, we had to have a buckeye donut. First off, the girl working the counter was just awesome. Great attitude! The actual place is really small but has this vintage diner feel which we loved. We only tried the buckeye donuts and they were perfection. For people visiting OSU, you gotta make this one of your stops! read more

We enjoyed our first try of their donuts. I suspect their gyros and breakfast sandwiches are delicious. Donuts were worth it, but not so phenomenal it requires going completely out of your way. read more

This is a great place to grab a donut. They're best being their red velvet. They also have some pretty decent French fries for a quick snack. Nicely seasoned, good portioned, and pretty cheap. It's also nice to grab something and walk down the street to another cool shop. read more

Gave this one a roll while in business in Columbus. Nice. Go for the cream-filled donuts, don't get sucked in for "the buckeye" read more

The lady and I stopped here before our day trip to Cleveland. Breakfast sandwiches - delicious. I got the sausage one (kielbasa I think). It's a good balance of egg, cheese, and sausage. Donuts - unique. Pumpkin and blueberry are good. Prices - OK. $10 for 2 breakfast sandwiches, 2 donuts, and a coffee. A little pricey in my book, but nothing to revolt about. Side note: Ambiance was admirable. Cashier knew people by name. People brought in their own coffee cups. They say the best places to eat are the places that the locals eat at. The locals definitely eat here. read more

My boyfriend started taking me here around the time we started dating, and it is the quintessential college campus diner. It's one of those places that, if you go to OSU, you will definitely go here at some point. The menu is pretty extensive. In addition to donuts, they also have a good breakfast menu and Greek food. The owners are super nice and love their regulars. During the week, they have specials on gyro combos and breakfast sandwiches. They are also open 24 hours a day. If your roommate is pissing you off or brings all their friends to your room late at night - go here. It can get a little loud, but I still never have a problem studying here. read more

The review is just on the basis of one donut I ate. Was very fresh and tasted very good. They have a huge variety as well.

Ahh where to start. This place is just the best. They are THE Ohio State. They are the reason Lebron and Urban Meyer came back to Ohio. They are gods gift to High street. It's a shame that local politicians haven't deemed this place a historic landmark. I've been coming to buckeye donuts for many years. Sometimes at 4am for an epic #1 combo after a long night out. Indulging in the juiciest gyro meat with the freshest toppings. Sometimes at 7am before class for a breakfast bagel next to my professors reading the local paper. It's the only place I can hit twice in one day. If you go to Columbus and miss Buckeye donuts then you shouldn't have gone to Columbus. read more

Man. Late night foods, delicious donuts. The history of the place. What's not to love!!

Oh Lordy! It's a good thing we don't have a Buckeye Donut Shop in Arizona! The chocolate cronut was beyond yummy and the old fashioned was really good. read more

After reading all the great reviews we got some gyros and donuts to go from Buckeye Donuts recently. The Buckeye donut was an iced donut that you would find at most donut shops with filling inside, but this one had chocolate icing with a dab of peanut butter on top, no filling and it was not fresh, and I would expect fresh from a 24 hour joint The gyro is small, but priced less accordingly. The gyro meat was not good, in fact, I didn't finish mine because of the odd taste even after picking off the overpowering onions. Service was good and prices are good, but I wouldn't go here again, unless it's after hours and there was nothing else in the area open, even then I would not order a gyro. As for the others in my party that also had the food, they are of the same opinion. read more

I went for the first time today and can't say how good the experience was. The cashiers were funny, friendly, and personable. The donuts were SO fresh... we ended up getting seconds to take some home ^_^. I also had a breakfast sandwich and tots which all came out made-to-order and piping hot. There is a hige variety of donuts and some very original flavors along with all the classics. I would DEFINITELY recommend the buckeye donut. read more

All I can say. Apple and Spice donuts are the best thing ever. Good late night campus stop.

Good donuts and your typical greasy spoon type food, but actually tasty. So next time you have the munchies this place might be able to hit the spot. read more

Showed up at close to midgut, got a half a dozen donuts, went home, and died of happiness. They were SO good, and the staff was really nice. They mentioned coming early in the morning for the freshest donuts, but I was very happy with what I got. The eclair filling is super good and creamy, and even the regular glazed was really good. Can't wait for an excuse to go back! read more

Best breakfast diner in Columbus. The people are cool and the food is great! It's all about the tots.

Their "Buckeyes" donuts are fresh and awesome! It's a must to eat before any Buckeyes games!!!

A CLASSIC!! Whether you need a coffee and a snack, a late night grub session, or donuts that will knock your socks off this place has got it. Think college diner cheap delicious and get ready for a trip to the land of happy tummies. There are donuts with bacon. The gyros are also very popular (with good reason)! read more

I don't always like a fat oniony lamb gyro and a crumb cake donut at 10:00 pm, but when I do, it's wonderful that I can accomplish this on High Street for a grand total of $6.50. Yup. read more

Great donuts! Nice atmosphere. Greek salad, falafel, and samosas are good too. It's also nice that it's open 24 hours.

Great donuts (especially the maple bacon one) and surprisingly amazing chicken tenders and fries!

Stopped here once for some cream filled doughnuts (long johns or bismarks, whichever tickles your fancy) and was a little disappointed as the donuts tasted stale and didn't have much cream. They were Krispy Kreme level doughnuts which I hate for the same reason. Give me Jolly Pirates or Der Dutchman over this place any day. I love supporting local businesses but mediocre doughnuts just won't keep me coming back. read more

Used to be my favorite donuts, but wasn't impressed with the dozen I got today. Very little cream filling and not as fresh as normal. I probably won't be back. Even Krispy Kreme has better products than that. read more

I could eat here everyday. I love the donuts and the lunch specials. Great place to eat any time of day!

Fantastic for breakfast, lunch, and late night drunken eating escapades alike. The donuts are pretty grand, and the coffee is surprisingly good. What is often over looked though are the gyros. "Gyros, at a breakfast joint? Eugh!" The uninformed reader may be saying to himself. However, the gyros offered here are great, and very affordable to boot. After overcoming your trepidation and ordering a gyro I'm sure you'll be hooked. The only complaint is the seating area is very limited and the place gets slammed during breakfast and lunch hours. If you live near the campus area buckeye donuts is a must. read more

I become a big fan of buckeye donuts after I first eating it. I am so love it. It's so delicious and my dorm is so close to buckeye donuts. It 's so convenient to get some delicious donuts whenever I am hungry. It opens 24 hours,so amazing! read more

Great tasting doughnuts. Whether you like cake or yeast, you will find the perfect doughnut here to quench your sweet tooth. If in the area do yourself a favor and stop on by. I was in at about 10pm a couple nights ago and the were fresh and moist just like you would expect at a early morning bakery. You cant go wrong with this place. read more

The kid working in the kitchen may have been the slowest short order cook I'd seen - cooking each ticket to completion before even starting the next. So, if you go for food, plan to wait. The DONUTS are ready to go and are tasty af! Vanilla iced/Vanilla cream is all they need. The "buckeye" donut wnt filled or anything - just a small blob of sweetened peanut on top, kind of disappointed. Great donuts! read more

Definitively love this spot. I have been going to Buckeye Donuts every since my Freshmen year at OSU. Everything on the menu is basically excellent. I have tried everything from their breakfast sandwich, gyros, to their donuts. The Philly Steak Gyro in my opinion is my favorite and any of the breakfast sandwich with the Croissant is amazing! read more

Breakfast sandwiches are always amazing. The maple bacon donuts are good, but I think if they had candied bacon crumbled into the maple frosting they would be incredible. 10/10 read more

This place is off the chain, its extremely good for everything. This place is legendary for Buckeyes fans and its right off the campus on High St. I am in Cincinnati I need a trip back to Columbus just for my Buckeye donuts. I highly recommend this place for every man, women and child its good you will thank me later. read more

This place is where you want to hang with friends at 3m donuts coffee and hope peaches is at the helm. Love the place. Got me through college. read more

Great cheap gyros and a huge donut selection. Open 24 hours to boot!

The donuts were pretty good but don't waste your time with the breakfast sandwiches. I ordered an egg and cheese on a croissant, it took 15 min to make and the croissant was hard and dry and it all just tasted like grease. Would be nice if they told you that the meat and eggs were cooked on the same cooktop especially if you are a vegetarian. read more

Apple spice donut is divine. It was the only open place we could find after the ROTR festival. It served the purpose well.

I requested a huge donut the size of a large round cake and Buckeye Donuts delivered! My daughter asked for this for her birthday. It had a chocolate glaze with custard filling. It was the most delicious donut we have had in I don't know how long! The staff is very friendly, helpful and fantastic to work with. I will return just for a simple donut since the quality is so good. Thank you!! read more

awesome service, great prices, and the best food around. unlike men, buckeye donuts will never let you down and always be there for you.

Excellent Donuts indeed. We were passing through Columbus on a road trip West and a friend's son who goes to OSU made sure we stopped off there. Really worthwhile and the killer donuts and coffee helped wit the drive. Kids say the breakfast sandwiches are off the charts!! read more

very dry is all I have to say. unless you want to dunk your donut these are not what you want for nine dollars a dozen. the yeast donuts have a heavy yeast taste and the fritters were raw in the middle. they had a donut deal buy 4 cake get 1 free. i chose 5 cake donuts, but since i added a fritter and cinnimon wheel they said i could not get the deal. the deal was only for an order of 5 cake donuts and nothing else. clearly not mentioned on the sign. read more