I would not recommend this company under any circumstances - But if you do decide for some reason to make a purchase, DO NOT USE THEIR 'COMPLIMENTARY' RESIZING OFFER. I sent my Wedding Ring away to be resized after 2 months. Once UPS (The only carrier they use) had received it, they refused to deliver my ring back to me until I paid an additional £172.39 in customs fees. As the ring is being resized, it does not constitute a sale, and you should not be charged any additional fees. The reason they requested these fees is because according to them, Blue Nile incorrectly filled in various documents for the resizing process. Blue Nile's advice was to pay the fees and they would assist in getting a refund. I paid the fees, and UPS has subsequently refused to offer a refund. Blue Nile now ignore my emails and will only get in contact if I chase THEM up. They have not offered any apology, they have taken no accountability, they have not offered any refund and they certainly haven't offered any compensation. Their 'Customer Service' has involved me being passed around from person to person, with no help being offered. To spend four-figures on a Wedding Ring, only for this to happen, is utterly heartbreaking and maddening. What is supposed to be one of the most personal and joyous experiences in life has been marred and tainted by this awful, awful company, who have acted horrendously, and also defrauded me out of hundreds of pounds. I will not stop until this story has a satisfying conclusion, and I will let you know how I get on. read more

My husband bought me a diamond ring from Blue Nile for our anniversary and our experience was wonderful. We went into the Blue Nile King of Prussia store to see the setting in person before we purchased it. The sales associate helped us pick out a beautiful diamond. Also, I reached out to Blue Nile with some questions and the customer service associate on the phone was very helpful. The whole process was easy. I love my ring! It's beautiful! read more

the service is terrible!! they didn't have many selection and the lady who try helping us had an attitude. so i decided to leave i also felt discriminated. sadly i did not get her name because of the uncomfortable vibe and her body language. this review doesn't even deserve one star, if anything a -3! read more

Absolutely in love with my engagement ring from Blue Nile! They offer a wide array of signature pieces to choose from, as well as the option of customizing what you want. All of their diamonds are GIA certified and all rings come with the proper paperwork. My fiancé had a great experience coming here to choose my ring, and really appreciated the great customer service skills. The employees are very invested in making sure you are happy with your experience, and pleased with your purchase. They are honest and upfront, and offered much advice and guidance. I highly recommend checking them out for anyone interested/ready to pop the question, and they also have a great selection of jewelry in general, that is definitely worth taking a look at! read more

Blue Nile - My beautiful engagement ring! - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

My husband purchased my engagement ring from Blue Nile 11 years ago. Right after he proposed and gave me the ring, he mentioned that the diamond looked very cloudy to him. I told him it was fine. I mean, he just proposed, so what was I going to say? Well, we recently visited a Blue Nile store now that they exist, and I couldn't believe how cloudy my diamond was in comparison to those in the case at the store. I'm very disappointed that this company would sell such a low-grade stone at such a high price point. And, of course, you can't compare when ordering online, which was the only option at the time. I'm giving them one star because the customer service has always been great. However, I feel like we were robbed. I'm also embarrassed that I've recommended this company to so many people. It will not happen again. read more

Wow will you look good with jewelry from this place it put a smile upon my face! Thanks for the incredible ring I received and I will wear it to show my affection and love and our relationship is so awesome and we are matched by love read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

The service and Selection of the pendant were great. My biggest complaint was the teeny tiny chain size that came with the pendant. My jeweler looked at it and said he was surprised with the small chain size that Blue Nile sent with the pendant and said they used to send better quality chains with their pendants. The platinum chain is so small that it knotted up next to the jump ring. The first time I could get the knot out with a needle and the second time I couldn't and had to break it off my neck. I called Blue Nile and they said their policy is that they would not be able to service the chain without the pendent too. Both had to be shipped back to Blue Nile. I told them there was nothing wrong with the pendant, it's the chain only that needs to be repaired. They still would not accept the return or a refund for the chain only. I will not do business with them again. read more

terrible company. UPS delivered to the wrong address. company does not care. I am out $2k and no ring. They DO NOT STAND BEGIND THEIR CUSTOMERS!! read more

My husband purchased me a diamond tennis bracelet the other day. It's pretty nice overall, but I never pay retail for things like this since I have a wholesaler license. I can purchase diamonds and all types of jewelry at the San Francisco diamond center for a huge savings... I really love the fact that Blue Nile diamonds are NOT blood diamonds, so that is extremely impressive and highly important to me! The bracelet is very nice as you can see from the photo but I also prefer platinum every time and it's white gold. It's a little small for my taste and was a bit too large on my dainty wrist LOL read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

There are no words to describe how amazing Liz Vasquez is! She made our ring shopping experience so pleasant and easy. She has the patience of a saint! I went back and forth SO many times and she never seemed annoyed with me (because I probably would be lol). The store itself has a good amount of rings to try on. It doesn't carry everything on the website but enough to help make a confident decision. We ended up with the most GORGEOUS engagement ring! It truly is the most perfect diamond I have ever seen. I get compliments every day since we got engaged! The girls there are so pleasant and Liz is really an expert at what she does! We recently chose our wedding bands (thanks again Liz) and we will certainly return back to Blue Nile for future sparkly purchases :) read more

See all

just a terrible experience. ordered a diamond on December 4th with delivery expected on Dec 11th. as of December 22nd, nothing delivered and no forecast for when it will be delivered. no help from customer service. no solutions. just a terrible experience Update... they got it there in time in the end but it was painful... read more

My fiancé and I had such a wonderful experience shopping for the engagement ring. Liz helped us narrow our search and we never felt pressured to make a purchase. The fiancé called in to place the order (leaves a hint of surprise in my e-ring) to only find out the setting was back ordered in my size! They sent additional recommendations....and at this point, the store manager, Joyce, also assisted (super sweet and helpful). Fast forward, we just came back to purchase our wedding rings and Liz helped us through this process. All in all, fabulous experience and I highly recommend. I would suggest to make an appointment and arrive on time. I personally appreciate the Covid precautions taken and love that the store isn't crowded. It lends for a very calm and wonderful experience. read more

I came to this place with my fiancé after obsessing over engagement rings on their website for the longest. We just happened to be walking to Nordstrom and when I saw this I freaked out and pulled in my then boyfriend to look at my dream ring in person. The staff were super helpful, gave us a lot of info and answered any questions I had. No pressure to buy and they also gave us tips on getting the best bang for our buck that I had already known from doing tons of diamond research but it was nice to know that they didn't try to b.s. us. Long story short my fiancé proposed to me with a Blue Nile ring one year later on our 7th anniversary trip in Paris. I am totally in love with my ring; the web room is great for really getting an idea of what you want and my fiancé said that they were so easy to shop with and they answered all of his questions over the phone. He also requested 6 prongs rather than 4 which to me was a plus because it's what I had ultimately wanted and they did it with no issue. I highly recommend this place and Blue Nile in general. read more

Blue Nile has to be the worst company I have ever made a purchase from. They sent my wedding band AND my husbands wedding band in the incorrect size and did nothing to fix this. We did not have my husbands ring in time for our wedding after various promises that it would be here in time. We were given horrible recommendations on what size and style to get as well. The people working in the show room were even talking badly about their co workers right in front of our face. In our time they also passed three different associates to help us due to how unprofessional they are. After going to my local jeweler they were in disbelief of the recommendations given to us. There was a couple screaming yelling at the people who worked there in the show room and I should have listened to my gut instinct and not purchased from them. To make up for my various issues from them they gave me a 20% off coupon that did not apply to other sales when their website is always on sale. My local jeweler also said they were low quality diamonds. I have wasted so much of MY TIME trying to fix THEIR issues and ended up getting no where. read more

I bought a bracelet after my dad passed away, with the money he left me. The bracelet was pricey and I debated on getting a Tiffany but thought I would give Blue Nile a chance. WHAT A COLOSSAL MISTAKE. After sending the bracelet back for repairs, it broke because it's so cheaply made! it was sent back with suggestions for " some other jeweler to fix it"!! I was blown away at the poor service from this company. So the bracelet sits in a bag, too cheap to be fixed and BLUE NILE COULD CARE LESS!!! DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY!!! THEY WILL NOT STAND BEHIND THEIR PRODUCT!!! read more

I can't say enough good things about my experience at Blue Nile in the Roosevelt field mall. I was helped by Lisa. We briefly spoke on the phone on the day before my "Covid friendly" in person visit. Lisa took the time to preselect diamonds that fit my requests to help me narrow down the selection process. I was never rushed or pressured and the result was pure perfection. The Savings discount for using a wire transfer was an added bonus. Thank you Lisa and the blue Nile team! read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

Awful experience. I went to their showroom in Charlotte, NC to exchange a necklace for a bracelet. I was told in the store that my item would arrive the following Thursday. It did not. So I called the customer service (if you can call it that) and was told that it hadn't been mailed out yet. They said they would overnight the item. Again they didn't. Lie number 2. When I got the shipping information, showing it hadn't been overnighted I called again. I was told a supervisor would call me back to discuss. No one called me back. Lie number 3. I called again 4 days later and was told tough. They also accused me of lying about what I was told in the showroom. Avoid this company, they don't tell the truth and take no accountability when found out. read more

I've always been a big fan of Blue Nile, as has my father, but when it comes to trying on expensive jewelry I prefer to do so in person. That said, I also love doing extensive research, enter the first standalone Blue Nile store in Roosevelt Field mall. Now I can do both. While the space isn't large, I was able to try on wedding bands to see if they actually match my engagement ring setting. While as helpful as the sales associates are online seeing them in person is much better. Kudos Blue Nile! I just realized this is my 500th review and my 100th FTR...cool I can't think of a better place to have it be! read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

Just got engaged with a ring I bought from Blue Nile!! Jennifer H. helped me get through the steps of picking the perfect one. She took the time to explain what I should and shouldn't be looking for. She is really knowledgeable when it comes to the Cs of diamonds. She was very accommodating when we were focusing on round diamonds at first then made a huge turn to look at oval diamonds instead. The ring itself is better than expected and we are so happy how it turned out. Blue Nile team and Jennifer specifically made the process so easy! She def deserves a raise haha! read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

Do not deal with this company! they have nothing left, only samples. They make an order for you after payment, but your order may not arrive by your significant date. And their support does not work, they answer calls, receive information, but do nothing afterwards. Bypass this company if you don't want to have a bad mood, a spoiled holiday and an incomprehensible number of days of waiting for a refund because you didn't receive it on time. read more

Blue Nile was recommended by my good friend/coworker. She specifically suggested this place due to its variety, price, and reliability. Went to Roosevelt mall to look at the ring setting person, had assistance with the customization of my diamond (forgot the rep's name, but she was POC) and came out of the store satisfied! Would come back to buy the wedding bands. read more

Received poor customer service when asking about 3 stone designs and the employee told me to go "look at it by myself near the door" since she didn't want to assist me. Lol. Just walked out. read more

It is a small showroom. Only a few people are allowed inside at a time due to COVID. An okay experience. I wish they had the item I wanted in stock. read more

My wife and I began shopping at Blue Nile nearly 20 years ago. They had very good products and the prices were competitive. What a different rating I would have given them then. We noticed over that years that the quality has gone down dramatically. In March 2021 I purchased a $600 twisted rope chain for my wife for our anniversary. She wore it a couple of times in the ensuing months. The third time she wore it she felt it dangling on her neck and noticed it was unravelling around its core. We sent it back to Blue Nile who said that it could not be repaired. They also said that since it was past 30 days there was nothing they could do about any refund. They did say they would give us 20% off if we wanted to buy something else. $600 for a junky necklace that she wore a few times. Blue Nile still has the worthless thing since it can't be fixed and we have no use for broken jewelry. They have really gone down hill. I saw an article dated October 2021 saying they have gotten better and better. I can't believe they didn't pay to have that article written. We were loyal customers of theirs and their stuff is utter crap. read more

My fiance had ordered a ring size 5.5 but we received a 6.5 instead. I called BN to explain that I had measured the ring utilizing their own ring sizers and many other sizers online and in other stores, and we could clearly see the ring we got was a 6.5, not a 5.5. Since my fiance bought the ring in February and he proposed in April (because he was waiting for the right time), they explained we would have to pay for the return shipping ourselves, EVEN THOUGH IT WAS THEIR MISTAKE. In the end, I had to pay almost $100 in insured shipping to return them the ring they had incorrectly shipped us to get the correct size. My fiance and I are now looking for our wedding bands and will make sure we don't even consider this place again, terrible customer service. read more

I thought this was the most overpriced store for diamonds in existence. Every piece was 10 x more than anywhere. There customer service was horrible and unhelpful. They do not know how to use gift cards and what kind of store won't accept cash. The reason they are overpriced you are paying for their use of credit cards. I Would recommend anywhere else. Jarad and Kay are reliable. Buying a diamond over the web is ridiculous. read more

This is the best place to put your money for a engagement ring i made a lot of store visit with other jewelers and nothing could match bluenile with there prices. Excellent customer service from Liz Vasquez. Thanks to her i found my fiancee's perfect ring. read more

See all

While I love the jewelry they showcased in the shop, I didn't find the necklace I wanted. The staff kindly offered a similar-looking one, but that kind of defeats the purpose of why I went there. read more

The team at Blue Nile is very patient and knowledgeable. We had so many questions and they were all greeted with a smile and an explanation. Buy a diamond is not easy but they made it less stressful. everyone i met said they same thing when they saw my ring "that is a beautiful stone"! read more

Blue Nile - Jewelry Near Me - Garden City, New York

Jeanne Johnson was wonderful to work with and a big help. Jeanne seemed to genuinely want to help, offered to research diamonds for the engagement ring I was shopping for, and followed up quickly with some great choices. Jeanne even helped find the perfect setting; one that I had not even considered before. My (now) fiancee loves the ring and get complements on it regularly. I would highly recommend working with Jeanne Johnson at Blue Nile in Garden City for any purchase through Blue Nile! read more

I loved the Blue Nile diamond experience. Personal Jeweler Leslie Bapliste helped Every step of the way. Loved the low financing, free delivery as easy process. I was not disappointed with the quality of my diamond. read more

Blue Nile is a horrible company to do business with. I bought and paid for a loose diamond for my wife and that went very well. I subsequently purchase a pair of gold earings for my wife. They were fairly inexpensive less than $300. When they were delivered I showed them to my wife and she hated them. I immediately returned them with the return shipper supplied after talking to Blue Nile about the return. They said that the amount charged would be credited to my account. That was over 3 months ago and I got a statement today from their lending source Comenity Bank for $45.92. $13.98 the fee Blue Nile charged for the return and the difference was late charges,. The Customer Service guy at Comenity Bank waived all the late charges, but I had to pay the $13.98 return fee. Blue Nile had told me prior to ordering that returns were never charged anything and that if my wife did not like it they would credit my account for the full balance. Well hello they charged me. It is not the $13.98 it is the fact that they lied and further never contacted me until today that the account was past due. So the 3 credit bureaus also were dinged from this. This is unacceptable as a business practice and this is only the first of many, many rating sites I plan to drag them thru over the next few months. I will get this resolved and Blue Nile will contact all of the credit bureaus to change their reporting or they will never hear the end of this. I have run social media sites, and rating systems for many years and Blue Nile in now in my sights. They have 7 days to respond before I unleash on them everywhere under many assumed names and email identities I have created over the last 15 years or so. I wonder what impact a 1 Star drop in their ratings will mean to their bottom line. read more

Had a ring that was damaged from less than a month of light wear at home. Tried to leave a review on their site- turns out reviews cannot be posted directly, but have to be sent to customer service, and they will only post it if they approve. This explains all the positive reviews on their site. read more

My fiance proposed to me three years ago with the perfect thing--PERFECT. The halo was set so that there was no gap between the diamond and the inside of the halo. We needed to get it serviced about two years ago, and when it came back the setting had been changed so there was a substantial gap which made me feel sad whenever I looked down--that I used to have the perfect ring. We needed it serviced again in the past couple of months and Joyce made sure to advocate for us to ensure that I got back the ring that I got when my fiance proposed to begin with. We got some back and forth from the people making the changes, but Joyce really went above and beyond to make sure that the ring I got back was PERFECT again. I'm back in love and couldn't be more happy because of Joyce. read more

Had such a good experience here the other night that I had to type a review about it. I came here explaining to both Joyce and Terry that my wedding is next year and I was looking for a ring to match my engagement ring. Even knowing I had no intention on buying my ring that night they went out their way to show me different styles, size me and even clean my ring. No I didn't make a purchase, but I will definitely be a future purchase for my ring and my fiancé ring. They took the time to explain everything to me. I highly recommend them. read more

I received a 2 carat solitaire engagement diamond ring from bluenile and it is absolutely gorgeous!!! The setting is beautiful as well as the diamond. It is more beautiful than I could have ever imagined! We have also purchased a wedding band that compliments the engagement ring. Bluenile has great suggestions and it fits my ring perfectly. The diamonds are smaller than I would like, but, it still looks great! Bluenile has AMAZING customer service! Jimmy N. was assisting me with the selection and shipping. He was very knowledgeable, patient and answered all of my questions! Then he followed-up after I received the items. It turns out the rings need to be re-sized. So he assisted with an even exchange for the groom's band and a re-sizing for my wedding band, all FOR FREE! I definitely recommend bluenile for a great price and great customer service! read more

NEVER AGAIN!!! From a company like Blue Nile I would never expect such a bad behaviour like we experienced when buying a pink diamond. We have bought a pink diamond from their shop and without even notifying they cancelled our booking. After some days I checked the tracking and it said that the purchase was cancelled. After some attempts I was forwarded to a lady that was, indeed friendly and helpful, but did give us the wrong information. She said that the diamond was already sold and that it was a tecnical issue we could buy it at all. They did not offer any discount or anything and as a substitute they did not offer diamonds that were comparible to the diamond we bought. After some days we saw the EXACTLY SAME DIAMOND online again at the much higher price. After calling the support again they told us that the price was wrong and that their supplier decided to not ship it. LUYING TO CUSTOMERS AND TRICKING THEM IS ALWAYS A BAD BEHAVIOUR! From a big company like Blue Nile and their suppliers I would expect much more professionality. Will never buy again because you never know if you will really get your diamond or not!!! read more

Blue Nile has to be one of the worst companies i have ever dealt with. I came to the garden city location and worked with Joyce.She was super nice when making a sell but has no idea whats the difference between an exchange and return. I have called the customer service line spoke to DEE DEE WILLIAMS AND Margaret K (Customer Care Advocate). They have not been helpful at all and say the same thing over and over. I have sent over all the documents and paper work of my return and they keep stating its an exchange. There employee makes a mistake and they want the customer to pay. I am not sure how DEE DEE and Margaret are even qualified to be SUPERVISOR. They make the customer pay an extra $2,000 for no reason. this company has to be a joke. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND JUST NOT DEALING WITH BLUE NILE at all. I HAVE SPENT OVER $15,000 with them and it was the biggest mistake. I will never step a foot inside the store again. Please go to any other jewelry store other than Blue Nile as they will steal your money Now i know why blue nile is in business because they are a corrupt company , who steals people money. If you guys want proof, feel free to contact me and i will send all the documentation. I have never posted on yelp before but i had to warn others of how they treat there customers. please be aware. Thank you Omar read more

Updating my review on Blue Nile to provide transparency to future customers who ultimately decide to purchase their jewelry. This is the worst customer experience I have ever had. While I continued to maintain contact via BBB as a mediator, Blue Nile did not want to negotiate or concede to fair customer treatment. Blue Nile notified me that security will be in contact in the near future, and after speaking with their Loss Prevention team, I still came to no conclusion where my actions were justified. Rather, I was penalized in the end for trying to some to a fair resolution. Every customer service representative and Loss Prevention representative lacked the transparency and empathy. They continued to deceive me by deflecting my concern and focused on getting payment information. Time and time again I requested to talk to a manager to help resolve this issue, however, I never able to reach one. While the LP personnel attempted to negotiate on my behalf, the explanation I received did not provide any additional insight to further negotiate a fair settlement. In addition to deception, they also relied on fear tactics. Customer service representative continued to deflect explanation on each other, and stating that my case will be brought to security. In my BBB complain, they explicitly stating the following: "However the mistakes occurred, we don't ever wish to cause such frustration to a valued customer, nor do we excuse the mistakes and mishandling that may have happened along the way. While we cannot undo what has already occurred, we are committed to providing whatever service you need to complete and finalize your purchases. Due to the nature of the situation, our Security team will be in touch to assist further." The language is very clear: we want our money without compensation. Their loss prevention (LP) team did reach out and I tried to request a dialogue with someone who would be able to provide more insight to a fair settlement but again, there was no connection and it was deflected back to the LP team. I do not recommend Blue Nile for anything. Customers, please research the customer reviews covering Blue Nile as there is merit to the complaints. I believe how the company has responded to their customer complaints speaks volumes on how they manage their business. They do not care about customer service nor do they want to help you find something perfect or special for you. Please stay away from this company. Unfortunately, BBB could not able to further pursue the complaint as I believe Blue Nile stated they would take legal and criminal action if I did not resolve this directly with them. Please see my BBB filing to see the full complaint. read more

Went to the Roosevelt Field mall location with my girlfriend, now fiance. Joyce Genova made the entire process feel magical and so natural-- we bought an engagement ring the same day we walked into the store. We feel blessed to have Joyce guide us through the entire diamond buying process, the 4 C's and teaching us about the perfect Holloway score diamond. She is exceptionally knowledgable about every step of diamond quality, cut, procurement and ring taste. She played a major role in making us become engaged. We even got our wedding bands from her-- and she was exceptionally helpful and made the whole process feel seamless too. I could give a million stars for this review to Joyce and the Roosevelt Field Blue Nile store if I could. I tell all my friend and family to go there and shop there. They will not be disappointed!!! read more