Don't miss this gem. Freshest oysters ever! My wife is the oyster freak and I usually don't…read morebother but I even loved it! Very creamy, not muddy at all and with the perfect level of brine. Nothing else like it! You know it's the freshest can be when you sit next to the baskets of oysters sitting in the water ready for collection. Just awesome!

Most excellent oysters available and a perfect location right next to the estuary making for a…read morepleasant evenings dinner. The Starfish Spaghetti also looked good.

With limited options in Batemans Bay, you could do a lot worse than to end up at The Starfish Deli…read more The location undeniably can't be beat, the service is sweet and efficient, and you won't be short on meal options, even if you're dealing with a food allergy/aversion. The food was... fine. I think we would have done much better by sticking to seafood (the rock oysters and shared fish platter looked stunning) instead of venturing into some more gourmet choices further down the menu. The wood-fired margarita pizza was more thick cheese-bready than light, fluffy and blackened-blistered, so I'd avoid pizza completely and instead go for something like the anitpasto platter, which was well stocked and delicious. While The Starfish might not satisfy your epicurean longings, it'll certainly fill you up in that "cheap 'n' cheerful" way that is sure tough not to like.