I just ordered a large half pepperoni half sausage and green peppers and it was absolutely delicious. It looked just like an advertisement.

Just had 4 slices of Aurelio's sausage and pepperoni pizza unbelievable! Went to the one in Munster, Indiana. They just rebuild this Location a few years ago. They have a special east side door for takeouts. PiZza was hot. I got there just in time for the cub game it's the sauce which taste never changes! Thank you Also, I use my $10 off coupon for my birthday to purchase this get the app they'll give you a birthday coupon every year read more

Aurelio's Pizza - A pizza with pepperoni and sausage toppings in a cardboard delivery box on a kitchen countertop. - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

Server was super sweet! Pizza is always amazing. A few less green peppers and I give it a 10

Always without exception, great food, generous portions, get delviery experience.. PJ... A Real Estate Professional

One of my family's go-to place when in the Chicago area. Thin crust pizza is very good. Quality seems to vary a bit based on location. This location is great and very consistent. Service has always been very good and customer-friendly as well. Don't sleep on the Antipasto Salad; lots of fresh ingredients and excellent dressing. read more

Awesome appetizers, awesome cheese, sauce, and crust. Pizza best I've had in awhile.toasted ravioli's, sweet chili wings and cheese sticks all where great! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Meatballs and pepperoni, yummy! - Pepperoni pizza slices with cheese and pepperoni toppings on a metal tray, placed on a red and white checkered tablecloth. - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Unbelievably slow. Takes hour and a half to get a pizza. Once an institution. Now just insufferable service. Place wasn't even that busy. Sat at 5:30. Didn't get our pizzas until 7:00. Then, one was cold. The other one people were burning their mouths on. Then they have the audacity to charge a credit card transaction fee when paying with a card. Insane. Right now, I'd have to say they have officially lost me as a customer. And we've been going there for 50 years. No more. read more

I grew up eating Aurelio's pizza and all the locations I've been to have not disappointed. The pizza itself features a sweet sauce, thin crispy crust and thick layer of mozzarella cheese. They have a variety of toppings, and all are good quality. The staff is friendly and attentive, and the price is reasonable. This is a good pizza place for a family dinner or for a quick takeout. read more

We ordered a family size pizza. The cheese is very different as well as the sauce was salty from the one in Chicago. I was not satisfied.

This is one of the worst pizzas I've had in a long time. I am completely disappointed in Aurelios. My pizza is soggy and does not even taste like the original Aurelio's that we all know in love. however, they did tell me they would make another pizza or give me $10 towards another pizza. after tasting this pizza, I didn't want another pizza and will not use the $10. read more

Was a lifelong customer until the recent change that forces customers to place an order via their app. This is clearly a scheme to loop you into marketing campaigns and I'm not in support of that. If I cannot place my order over the phone I will not be ordering. read more

If you want consistently great pizza, Aurilio's is the place for you! I always enjoy having pizza there! Its one of the best!!! Service is great!! Ambiance is good for a pizza place! read more

Classic Aurelio's! Pizza was great and just as I remembered. Take-out was timely and easy.

WAY too much cheese on their pizza. Literally can't taste anything else. The cheese is 3x thicker than the bottom crust of the pizza . Teenage staff there gives you dirty looks like you're desperate for waiting to dine in. Only reason this place gets 2 stars is because the older lady that served us was very sweet and patient and working her butt off. read more

was there last night won't return again the crust was overcooked and hard and the waitress was a young Filipino girl with a major attitude

Thanks Aurelio's for refusing to take my order, essentially because my deafness inconveniences you. You knew what the call was for, picked up, even asked for my phone number on "pick up" after "relay" was explained to you. (I've ordered pizza already hundreds of times there through the same relay service, so it should be well known, no excuses) Then, you told me you didn't have time for "this" because it's the dinner rush. And hung up 3 times, I even asked you to please serve me, because I also want dinner. SMH Again, Thanks for choosing not to service me because it inconveniences you, and because it interferes with 2 minutes of your time, which was used to better serve your customers without a hearing loss. read more

See all

Our first clue should've been we were the ONLY customers in the place.... which made it quiet. Lol! We ordered 2 breads (garlic and tomato) and both were delicious! The pizza was good, but not as good as I remember. Living so far away from an Aurelio's, i really missed the pizza... but I guess time takes it's toll. They had a bunch of gnats that really liked our table (enough that i covered my drink with a napkin), the waitress wasn't around much and the pizza was just okay... to top it off something really got to me and I started sneezing and nose started to run. I don't usually have allergies, but something in there disagreed with me. Been out of there for about 20 minutes and it's all starting to subside... weird. read more

Can't wait to have Aurelios pizza every time I'm in NWI. Sweet sauce and sausage. Delicious!

Where I'm from, Aurelio's reigns supreme. Everyone talks about their pizza and most of my family and friends rank it as their favorite in the world. I have to say, it's in my top 3. The sauce is what really seals the deal. If you like sweet sauce, this is the place for you. It's also thin crust with just the right amount of crisp. For me, I looove their sausage. A good sausage is really important to me on my pizza. I'd highly recommend going into the restaurant because that's when the pizza is best; however, after my last experience, I wouldn't recommend due to service. We'd never had service issues like we did the other night. Our waitress would actively look away from us so she wouldn't have to bring us more of anything. It was pretty frustrating when all our drinks had been empty for about a half hour and we had to flag down someone else's waitress at one point. Thankfully, the delicious pizza and other amiable staff members made up for this unfortunate customer service experience. As far as locations go, the Crete one is also solid and so is the original Homewood one. Give it a try if you're near Chicago! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

We really wish we didn't love their pizzas so much, because the people taking our orders over the phone are so rude. We literally put the phone on speaker every time we call hoping that one time will get somebody who is professional and polite. Most of the time they pick up the phone, don't say anything and put you on hold immediately. Customer service just isn't what it used to be. read more

If I could give you a 0, I would. Our delivery order was scheduled at 8:09 (1 hour), I reached out at 8:31 and they said they were on their way. At 8:47, 20 minutes later, I reached back out again, and they said it was on the way. 1 hour and 40 minutes past the time I ordered. I tipped in advance, that will not happen again. The manager is in the background saying if you do not get the delivery in 5 minutes, call me back, and then they turned their phones off. They close at 9, but they turned their phones off early, so I have no resolution, except cold wilted lettuce (Taco) pizza that was delivered 50 minutes late. You should be embarrassed by this, but you seem to relish in it. 2.5 miles away from my address. I have understanding for the sole delivery driver that still had pizzas to deliver after us...this is directed at the Manger of the location that does not want accountability. You had my number, you refused to answer the calls, shame on you. read more

Dirty on the outside and even dirtier on the inside. Pop was hot. An abundance of free gnats all over our food. Nasty nasty nasty.

The past 2 times we have TRIED to eat here (6 months apart), we were strongly discouraged by the teenagers working the front counter. Both times, there was a sign posted on the front door they are short staffed; ok. So the first time we were told the ding room closes as 6:30 (it was 6:25 pm); we left. Tonight, we approached the front desk where 3 girls were standing doing, idk what (mean mugging the customers so they will go away?) and one girl barked "is this carry out or dine in "; we replied "dine in "( (2 of us)., to which the girl behind the counter sighed and said "it will be a 10 minute wait"; no problem. I noted she did not take my name, never said another word to me. I had the distinct feeling (similar to the time before) that they wished we would just leave. There was one family of 3 ahead of us. The next couple that came in faced the same routine but were told a 25 minute wait, they huddled in the vestibule with us. Next, an elderly couple came in; they were told a 30-35 minute wait they left. Next, a party of 13 walks in, and are told a 5-10 minutes wait! Um what? The 25 minute couple & I met each other's gaze, both thinking "um what?". Mind you the whole 10-15 wait we were there the 3 girls behind the desk are chatting amongst each other, there is a lady slaving away by herself making pizzas and bus boy and wait staff working diligently to serve the half full dining room. Soooo after a minute of contemplation, we decided to leave being pretty convinced that we would be punished with bad service for staying and most definitely would be ordering behind the party of 13 that walked in several groups behind us. Such a shame, this is a place my parents took me to growing up and it holds a lot of memories for me. We walked out as did the 25 minute couple. I have your solution Aurelios, fire the mean mug crew at the front and replace them with people who are welcoming and help out their co-workers. Afraid 3rd time won't be a charm... read more

It is the sauce!! Family favorite for over 50 years. Aurelio's slices the competition.

This place just really bums me out. I used to like their pizza but it seems like every time I have it, it tastes different. So inconsistent! I'll stick to the original location in Homewood. What is consistent is the service, which is not good. It was not the fault of the waitress, the poor lady was the ONLY waitress there working 3 rooms that were FULL!!! What the heck?!?! She was nice and tried hard but because they didn't have adequate staffing it was a bad night. She brought us our food but we never go checked on after and I was so thirsty that my hubby got up and went to the front asking for a refill. There was no parmigiana cheese on the table which we like. It was on everyone else's... Didn't have a chance to ask for it and we gave up. When I finally got my refill I was worried it might not be diet (I'm diabetic and had enough carbs already) but the waitress couldn't remember and got me a different drink so she was 100% sure that it was. She was really nice and kept apologizing because she was so swamped. This happens every time we go!!! Bad management. I feel bad for the staff because patrons place the blame on the wait staff. :-( this room was understaffed and almost always is!!! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Wth? Chips with Italian Beef?!!! Yuck. Fries are extra it already cost 7.95!!! - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

I ordered Aurelio's pizza last night for delivery and was pleased overall however there are some factors that I will note. First our order was for a large thin crust sausage and pepperoni pizza. I asked specifically that the crust be crispy as that's how my wife likes her pizza. When the pizza arrived the receipt did note that it requested a crispy crust (see receipt in photo) however the crust we received was very soft. My order also contained a medium stuffed spinach and tomato pizza. This pizza was cooked to perfection. I like how this pizza was not cut. I presume that is saved for the consumer because a ride in a delivery car with a sliced stuffed pizza would result in the contents being spread throughout the entire box. I'm giving four stars today for two reasons...one because of the mistake with the thin crust crispy request and secondly for what seems to be the norm as far as delivery with this restaurant. On Friday or Saturday nights it always seems that the delivery time during peak hours is between 90 minutes and one hour and 45 minutes. This was the timeframe I was quoted last night and although they stayed with in that timeframe I would order from this restaurant more if they could deliver faster. I am not saying that I would be a daily customer, but I can say that at least 10 times in the last year I wanted to order from this restaurant but made the decision to go with another pizza place based upon the timeframe for delivery. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - My delivery box and receipt. - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

I always loved their pizza. We ordered for delivery online, said it would take an hour. We waited 2 hours and the pizza was cold. We were so hungry we just microwaved it and ate it (so obviously we didn't love it this time). If I knew it was going to take that long, I would of done a pick up . When I did call, they told me the website time is always wrong. If it's always wrong, why doesn't this problem get fixed? read more

I love Aurelio's. I grew up eating at the Homewood location. We have been ordering from Schererville for a long time. A couple of weeks ago I tried to order and they didn't answer. I figured that the phone lines were down. I tried to order again yesterday. I was hung up on 5 times! I decided to send an email to see if it was the phone lines (you never know- it could be). I received an email back and they told me that they were busy and not answering the phones. I was surprised. I wonder if that is the franchise owner's policy. Sad that they don't want business. read more

By far the worst service in NW Indiana! Don't waste your time dinning in at this location! The waitstaff lack the skills needed to do their job not to mention management could care less whether the situation is rectified! I'm truly disappointed with this establishment and wouldn't recommend it to ANYONE! 0.00 tip read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Best part of the meal - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

Since the new management took over, this Aurelio's is ON FIRE. Never a bad pie, either take out or dine in. The service is fabulous. You can count on consistency, crust is always perfect, the sauce is unbelievable, the antipasto salad is delicious. One improvement would be to get better lettuce. Add some spring mix to the iceberg.... We had been going here for over 35 years, but quit between 2008 - 2014. Everything has improved so much...even the bathrooms. The women's bathroom is in a horrible place however...smack in the middle of the din8g room, very gross. Overall, an A+! read more

Poor service good food. Ordered appetizers and got 2 of 3 items then 3rd. Ordered medium pizza received large. Beer came no head on it. Waitress did not know menu. Another table got food for one person then later for other. Another customers pizza hut the floor. Mgmt discounted bill for them. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

See all

I love Aurelio's and try it in different states, never disappointed. But not at this location. I should have read the reviews and noticed no good ones since a year ago. Anyway I ordered a delivery as soon as they opened. I was right down the street from the store and was told it would be 1 hour 20 minutes. Once delivered I found they didn't get the order correct. Save your time and money and go somewhere else. read more

Haven't been to an Aurelio's in ages. The pizza was good as usual. Deep dish and a thin crust. Antipasto salad was good but needs smaller pieces and shredded cheese. The building is old and tight fitting but the service makes it work. read more

Went to dinner with my family. With no one else waiting it took 10 minutes to seat us. Then we sat for over 20 minutes and no one even came to take our drink order. We've been to the Homewood store plenty of times and love it. This one, though is a definite miss. Won't waste my time here again. read more

Ordered a pizza with tomato, mushroom, half black olives, half spinach... easy right? Nope. Got some of the toppings on part of the pizza. I guess my crazy ordering was too confusing. When I pointed out the incorrect order there was no concern or interest in making amends for their mistake. $40 for dinner we don't even want now. I understand no one wants to work and that's the excuse we're now using for bad service, but give me a break. I'll go elsewhere next time so I don't add to the strain of the fractured workforce. Adding insult to injury, the pizza wasn't even cooked all the way through. Save your money, go to one of the fast food pizza places and roll the dice. The rectangle pizza in 5th grade was a five star meal compared to this monstrosity. read more

went last night and waited almost an hour to take our order nobody came so we had to walk out. There was only three other tables that was filled in the whole restaraunt so is not at all busy. What is going on there? read more

Well I must say this is my first time stopping here, out of all the times I've seen this place I've never gave it a thought not til today. I ordered a medium sausage cheese and pepperoni thin crust and a side salad. The pizzas had great flavor, not to saucy, just enough cheese, crunchy just like i enjoy my thin crusts. The pizza was brought to the table pipping hot A+. The atmosphere was ok although there was a slight odor immediately when you came on the door and ironically for a restaurant there's only a 1 stall 1 door bathroom C-. The side salad i had was ok but the French dressing tasted like it had pineapples in it. The waitress was working the floor. I would go back because of the amazing tasting pizza. read more

See all

Usual pretty good but last two months bad. Pizza is cut like a four year old did it. Just slashes all over it. The lettuce in my salad was brown. Terrible read more

Great pizza and walking distance from where I am at first tobacco shop! I will be visiting often

We have order from the Schereville for years. We have called multiple times with theses issues and enough is enough. They have become terrible almost 2 hours to deliver!!!! Customer service bad , pizza has become substandard! Its a shame after almost 17 years of ordering several times a month and have multiple family get togethers there to have to say goodbye. Today was the last straw! read more