I've been with AAnderson Insurance, in my case with Amy Anderson Young, for several years since my…read moreprevious broker departed from my insurance at the time and transferred my policy to a different agency. To be honest, at the time I was resistant and had every intention of canceling my policy. However, Amy reached out to me and heard my concerns and committed to earning and keeping my business. To be honest, that's exactly what she's done. She's a broker. This means that she represents multiple agencies and works to get you with the one that will best meet your needs. When I first started with her, I was with a different agency that decided to get out of personal lines. We got with a different agency and I likely ended up with better coverage for the same price. I've not had a claim since she's been serving my insurance needs, but anytime I've had a question, concern, or problem she's responded in a timely manner and gotten a quick and easy resolution. There were a couple hiccups when I transitioned to a new company, but she worked through them and made sure everything was good and I was protected. She's friendly, attentive, and responds quickly. She makes recommendations, but she's not constantly trying to sell things and she has a nice balance so she's never intrusive. I'm admittedly a fairly stable customer. While prices matter to me, I tend to be fairly stable and don't tend to shop around a lot. I also pay my bills on time. I'm probably someone who is most concerned about customer service and Amy has been top-notch from day one and has done what it takes to earn and keep my business. I'd definitely recommend her and/or her agency - she offers home/rental, life, auto, motorcycle, umbrella insurance, RV, and Boat/Watercraft.

They have had our insurance for 20 plus years. The staff is always and nice and accommodating. Easy…read moreto deal with and they seem to have my best interests. Definitely would recommend.

From the owner: Mantooth Insurance Agency proudly serves the Avon, Indiana community with comprehensive Auto, Home,…read moreBusiness, and Life Insurance solutions designed to protect what matters most. Our team is committed to delivering dependable coverage, competitive pricing, and personalized service for every client we serve. In recognition of our dedication to excellence, Mantooth Insurance Agency was honored with the 2014 Best of Avon Award in the Automobile Insurance category by the Avon Award Program.

Called for AAA at the McDonald's at Lynhurst and Washington. Told me would be there at 6:41. Called…read moreat 6:50 to see where they were. Was told by AAA time had been changed to 8:00 pm. but nobody bothered to call and tell me that after I'd already waited an hour and a half. 2 homeless guys ended up helping me buy fix a flat and putting air in it. I called AAA back at 8:15 - over 3 hours after my original call to tell them never mind because I, a single handicapped woman, in a bad neighborhood had to rely on 2 homeless men to help me because the service that I pay for couldn't bother to show up at the 1st OR 2nd time promised. Thanks for putting my life in danger AAA. You're the 1st thing getting deleted out of next years budget!!!!

I was recently in an accident and the staff here not only provided professional guidance but also…read moreemotional support during a very trying time. As a new customer I could not be happier that we made the switch. My sincerest thanks to Dewanna, Angie and Shawna. 10 out of 10 would recommend!

My family and I have been with American Family Insurance for years. They offer many different…read moreinsurance packages for different situations to fit specific needs. They are very reasonably priced and available when needed as well. On many occasions they have even scheduled appointments/consultations after business hours to be more convenient for working customers. The service that the Dewanna Mooneyham agency provides is exceptional. The ladies at American Family Insurance (Avon) are always pleasant, helpful, and seem to go the above and beyond to ensure that the customer is well taken care of. They provide thorough insight and offer plenty of explanation regarding their different policies. If you want a solid insurance company that minimizes insurance stress and headaches, I would strongly recommend doing business with this branch! Jacob D Bills